It was late 2022. Bath and Body Works dropped a collection that, honestly, felt a little different from their usual lineup of bright citrus and sugary vanilla. They called it Bath and Body Works Midnight Amber Glow. Within weeks, the fragrance community on TikTok and Reddit went absolutely nuclear. People weren't just buying a bottle; they were clearing shelves.
You’ve probably been there. You walk into a store, the air is thick with a mix of a thousand different scents, and suddenly you catch a whiff of something that smells... expensive. Not "mall store" expensive. Like, "boutique hotel in Paris" expensive. That was the magic trick this scent pulled off. It managed to bridge the gap between affordable body care and high-end gourmand perfumery.
But then, as Bath and Body Works often does, they pulled the rug out from under everyone. The scent was discontinued from the main floor, relegated to the chaotic bins of the Semi-Annual Sale, and then seemingly vanished into the ether of reseller sites. If you want a bottle now, you’re looking at eBay markups that would make a sneakerhead blush.
The actual chemistry of why Midnight Amber Glow smells so good
Let’s get into the bones of this fragrance. Most people describe it as a "coffee scent," but that’s a bit of a simplification. It’s more complex than your morning latte. The official note profile lists smooth amber, caramel latte, and vanilla bourbon.
Amber is the anchor here. In perfumery, "amber" isn't a single ingredient but a "fantasy note"—usually a blend of labdanum, benzoin, and vanilla. It’s what gives a fragrance that resinous, golden warmth. When you mix that with a sharp, slightly bitter coffee note (the caramel latte), you get a contrast that stops the scent from being cloyingly sweet.
Wait. There’s more.
👉 See also: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
The "vanilla bourbon" isn't just a fancy name. It adds a boozy, oak-aged quality. This is why many fragrance enthusiasts compared it to high-end scents like Kilian’s Angel’s Share or Yves Saint Laurent’s Black Opium. It has that same "dark" gourmand energy. It’s heavy. It’s cozy. It’s the olfactory equivalent of a cashmere sweater you found in a vintage shop that somehow still smells like a rich person’s house.
Why did it get discontinued if everyone loved it?
This is the question that haunts the Bath and Body Works subreddit. To understand why Bath and Body Works Midnight Amber Glow isn't sitting on a pedestal in every store right now, you have to understand the brand's business model.
They thrive on FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out).
Bath and Body Works operates on a high-velocity seasonal rotation. They need "newness" to drive foot traffic. Even a massive hit sometimes gets the axe to make room for the next "bright, floral spring" collection. It’s a brutal cycle. However, the discontinuation of Midnight Amber Glow felt particularly egregious because it was a "Signature Collection" scent, which usually implies a longer shelf life.
Some insiders speculate it was a supply chain issue with the specific fragrance oils used for the coffee-caramel blend. Others think it simply didn't hit the massive, broad-market numbers that something like Champagne Toast hits. Champagne Toast is safe. Midnight Amber Glow is a statement. Not everyone wants to smell like a boozy latte at 9:00 AM on a Tuesday, though clearly, a very vocal group of us does.
✨ Don't miss: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
Comparing the forms: Mist vs. Cream vs. Body Wash
If you’re hunting this down on the secondary market, you need to know that not all versions of this scent were created equal.
- The Fine Fragrance Mist: This is the lightest version. It has a high alcohol content, which means the "boozy" note is very prominent in the first ten seconds. It’s great for layering, but the longevity is... okay. You’ll get maybe three hours before it becomes a skin scent.
- The Ultimate Hydration Body Cream: Honestly? This is the superior way to wear it. The fat content in the cream holds onto the fragrance oils longer. If you use the cream on your arms and neck, the scent lingers for six to eight hours. It’s richer, creamier, and the caramel notes really pop.
- The Eau de Parfum: This was the "holy grail" of the collection. It came in a glass bottle and had a much higher fragrance oil concentration. If you find this for a reasonable price, buy it immediately. It’s the most "perfume-y" and least "body spray-y" of the bunch.
Real-world performance
I’ve spoken to people who wore this to weddings and people who wore it to bed. The consensus is that it’s a "compliment getter." There’s something about the way the amber reacts to body heat that makes it project. It’s not a "clean" scent. It’s a "come closer" scent.
The "Dupe" culture and what to buy instead
Since you can't just stroll into a mall and grab a bottle of Bath and Body Works Midnight Amber Glow anymore, the hunt for dupes has become a full-time hobby for some.
If you’re looking for that specific vibe, you might want to look at Coffee Break by Maison Margiela. It’s significantly more expensive, but it captures that creamy, atmospheric coffee shop vibe. For a cheaper thrill, Eilish by Billie Eilish (the gold bottle) has a similar cocoa-vanilla-amber warmth, though it lacks the specific coffee "zing" that made Midnight Amber Glow special.
Another solid option is Vanilla Mocha Martini from Bath and Body Works' own back catalog. It pops up occasionally during sales. It’s close, but it’s heavier on the chocolate and lighter on the sophisticated amber. It’s the younger, louder cousin of Midnight Amber Glow.
🔗 Read more: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
Is it actually worth the eBay prices?
Let’s be real for a second.
You’ll see bottles of the mist going for $30, $40, or even $60. Is it worth that? Probably not. At its core, it’s still a body mist with a high alcohol-to-fragrance ratio. However, if you are a collector or if this was your "signature scent" that made you feel confident, then value is subjective.
What made this scent so iconic wasn't just the smell, but the timing. It launched right as the "clean girl" aesthetic was starting to pivot back toward "indie sleaze" and "grunge gourmand." We wanted something darker. We wanted to smell like we’d been sitting in a dimly lit library drinking espresso.
How to make your remaining stash last longer
If you’re lucky enough to still have half a bottle of Bath and Body Works Midnight Amber Glow tucked away in your bathroom cabinet, don’t waste it.
- Store it in a dark, cool place. Heat and light are the enemies of fragrance oils. If you keep your mist in a sunny bathroom, the vanilla notes will oxidize and turn "off" or sour within a year. Put it in a drawer.
- Layer with unscented oils. Apply a thin layer of unscented jojoba or almond oil to your pulse points before spraying. The oil gives the fragrance something to "grip," extending the wear time significantly.
- Spray your clothes, not just your skin. Fragrance evaporates faster on warm skin. On a cotton shirt or a wool scarf, Midnight Amber Glow can last for days.
Actionable steps for the Midnight Amber Glow fan
If you're desperate to get your hands on this scent or something like it, here is your game plan:
- Check Mercari and Poshmark frequently. Sellers on these platforms often bundle items. You can sometimes find a "lot" of three or four items for the price of one single bottle if you're patient.
- Look for the "Amber" keyword in new releases. Bath and Body Works often repackages old scents under new names. Keep an eye out for any scent that lists "latte," "amber," and "bourbon" or "woods" together.
- Join the communities. The "Bath & Body Works" Facebook groups and Subreddits are usually the first to know about "warehouse finds" or if a scent is returning for the Semi-Annual Sale.
- Explore "The 7 Virtues" Vanilla Woods. If you want a high-quality alternative that is readily available at stores like Sephora, this fragrance has a similar smoky, woody vanilla profile that scratches that same itch.
Midnight Amber Glow was a lightning-in-a-bottle moment for a brand that usually plays it safe. It proved that mass-market consumers actually have an appetite for complex, darker, and more sophisticated scent profiles. While we wait for its inevitable (hopefully) return, we'll just have to savor every last drop of the bottles we have left.