We’ve all said it. You're standing on the edge of a big decision—maybe quitting a soul-crushing job or finally asking out that person who makes your heart do weird rhythmic gymnastics—and you mutter those five words: what's the worst that can happen? Usually, it’s a throwaway phrase. A bit of bravado to mask the fact that your palms are sweating. But if you actually stop to answer the question, you aren't just being a pessimist. You're practicing a psychological technique that goes back to the Stoics of Ancient Greece. They called it premissio malorum. Basically, it's the "premeditation of evils." It sounds grim, I know. It’s actually the secret to staying sane when the world feels like a dumpster fire.
Humans are notoriously bad at predicting the future. We overstate the joy of winning the lottery and wildly overestimate the agony of a breakup. Psychologists call this impact bias. We think a "worst-case scenario" will break us permanently. It rarely does. When you actually sit down and map out what's the worst that can happen, you usually find that the "worst" is just… inconvenient. Or maybe it’s a bruise to the ego. Sometimes it’s a financial hit, sure, but it’s rarely the literal end of the world.
The Science of Defensive Pessimism
Most self-help gurus will tell you to "visualize success." They want you to close your eyes and see the yacht. Julie Norem, a psychology professor at Wellesley College, suggests the opposite. She’s spent decades studying "defensive pessimism." This isn't about being a glass-half-empty person who brings everyone down at parties. It’s a cognitive strategy where people set low expectations and then mentally play through all the things that could go wrong.
Think about an Olympic athlete. They don't just imagine standing on the podium. They imagine their lace snapping at the starting block. They imagine a false start. They imagine the crowd booing. Why? Because when you’ve already "lived" through the disaster in your head, the anxiety loses its teeth. You develop a plan. If the lace snaps, you have a spare. If the crowd boos, you have a mantra. You’ve already answered what's the worst that can happen, so you aren't paralyzed when things get messy.
Real Stakes and the Fear of the Unknown
Let’s get real for a second. Sometimes the worst-case scenario actually involves loss. Real loss. In the business world, this is where "Pre-Mortems" come in. Gary Klein, a cognitive psychologist, popularized this. Instead of a post-mortem (looking at why a project died), a team sits down before they even start and assumes the project has already failed miserably. They ask: "It’s six months from now. The project is a total disaster. What happened?"
👉 See also: Finding the University of Arizona Address: It Is Not as Simple as You Think
This shifts the brain from "defensive mode" to "detective mode." People start spotting the cracks in the foundation that they were too "optimistic" to see before. It’s not about being a hater. It’s about being prepared. Honestly, the unknown is always scarier than the specific. "Failure" is a big, scary monster under the bed. "Losing $5,000 and having to move back in with my parents for four months" is a specific problem with a specific (if unpleasant) solution.
When Fear Becomes a Roadmap
Tim Ferriss, the "4-Hour Workweek" guy, has a famous TED talk on this concept he calls "Fear Setting." He literally writes down a list of his fears. He defines the worst-case scenario in detail. Then he writes down how he would prevent it. Then—and this is the kicker—he writes down how he would repair the damage if it happened anyway.
If you’re wondering what's the worst that can happen regarding a career change, your list might look like this:
- The Worst: I quit, the new job fires me in three months, and I can't pay rent.
- The Prevention: I save six months of expenses before quitting.
- The Repair: I take a temporary retail job, drive Uber, or ask my brother to crash on his couch while I hunt for a new role.
Suddenly, the "catastrophe" is just a series of logistical hurdles. You realize you’re resilient. You've survived 100% of your bad days so far. That’s a pretty good track record.
✨ Don't miss: The Recipe With Boiled Eggs That Actually Makes Breakfast Interesting Again
The Trap of Toxic Positivity
We live in a culture that’s obsessed with "good vibes only." It’s exhausting. And frankly, it’s dangerous. Toxic positivity tells you that if you just think happy thoughts, nothing bad will happen. That’s not how reality works. Reality is indifferent to your vision board. When you refuse to look at the "worst," you leave yourself wide open to getting blindsided.
Acknowledging the dark stuff doesn't manifest it into existence. That’s a myth. In fact, people who practice "mental contrasting"—a technique developed by NYU psychologist Gabriele Oettingen—are significantly more likely to achieve their goals. You imagine the goal, but then you immediately imagine the obstacles. You look the "worst" right in the eye. It gives you the energy to actually move, rather than just daydreaming.
How to Actually Use This Without Spiraling
There is a fine line between being a "defensive pessimist" and just plain old rumination. Rumination is when you replay the same scary movie in your head over and over without ever finding an exit. That’s not what we’re doing here. To use this strategy effectively, you need to be a pragmatist.
First, define the "worst." Be specific. No "everything goes wrong." What is "everything"? Is it a lawsuit? Is it a bad review? Is it a broken leg?
🔗 Read more: Finding the Right Words: Quotes About Sons That Actually Mean Something
Second, look at the probability. We often treat a 1% chance of disaster like it’s a 90% certainty. It’s not. If the worst-case scenario is "a meteor hits my house during the presentation," you can probably skip the contingency plan for that one.
Third, ask yourself about the "Cost of Inaction." This is the part people forget. While you’re worrying about what's the worst that can happen if you do the thing, you should be terrified of what happens if you don't. What’s the worst that happens if you stay in that dead-end relationship for another five years? What’s the worst that happens if you never try to start that business? Usually, the "worst" of doing nothing is a slow, quiet death of the soul. That’s way scarier than a failed business.
Actionable Steps for the "What If" Mindset
If you’re currently paralyzed by a big choice, stop trying to be "brave" and start being "calculated." Courage isn't the absence of fear; it’s the realization that something else is more important than fear.
- Write the Disaster Script: Take 10 minutes. Write down the absolute messiest, most embarrassing, most expensive outcome of your current dilemma. Don’t hold back. Get it all out on paper.
- Assign a Recovery Score: On a scale of 1 to 10, how hard would it be to recover from that disaster? 1 is "I’ll be fine by lunch," and 10 is "I am literally dead." Most things in life are a 3 or a 4.
- Identify the Permanent vs. Temporary: Almost everything is temporary. Money can be remade. Reputations can be rebuilt. Even heartbreak heals. Very few things are truly permanent. If your "worst case" isn't permanent, it’s manageable.
- Audit Your Track Record: Look back at the last three times you were terrified. What actually happened? Did you die? No. You’re here. You probably learned something. You might even have a funny story now.
- Flip the Question: Once you’ve handled the worst, ask: "What’s the best that could happen?" Give that scenario equal time. If the "best" outcome is a life-changer and the "worst" is just a temporary setback, the math is in your favor.
Stop letting the "worst" be a blurry ghost in the corner of the room. Turn the lights on. It’s usually just a pile of laundry. Once you see it for what it is, you can decide whether to fold it or just walk around it. Either way, you're moving again.