You’ve seen the post. It’s usually an old acquaintance from high school—someone you haven't spoken to since 2012—sliding into your DMs with an "exciting opportunity." They’re glowing. They’re using words like "financial freedom," "boss babe," and "passive income." But beneath the shiny Instagram filters and the hashtags lies a business model that has systematically drained bank accounts for decades. People often ask, why are MLMs bad if everyone involved seems so happy?
The short answer? It’s a math problem masquerading as a lifestyle.
Multi-level marketing (MLM) isn't just a quirky way to sell leggings or essential oils. It is a predatory structure. While the person in your inbox might be genuinely kind, the system they’ve bought into is designed to ensure the vast majority of participants lose money. We aren't talking about a few bucks, either. According to a landmark study by the Consumer Awareness Institute published on the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) website, roughly 99% of MLM participants lose money after expenses are factored in.
Think about that. 99%. You’d literally have better odds at a blackjack table in Vegas.
The Mathematical Impossibility of Success
MLMs survive on recruitment. That’s the core issue. In a normal business, you make money by selling a product to a customer who actually wants it. In an MLM, the "product" is often secondary to the "opportunity."
To make the "big checks" you see on social media, you have to recruit a "downline." Then those people have to recruit people. And so on. It sounds simple until you do the math. If everyone in an MLM recruits just five people, and those five recruit five more, you exceed the entire population of the Earth in just 14 cycles. It’s a closed loop. Eventually, the market becomes so saturated that there are no "new" customers left, only distributors trying to sell to other distributors.
📖 Related: Private Credit News Today: Why the Golden Age is Getting a Reality Check
This is why the FTC often investigates these companies to see if they cross the line into pyramid scheme territory. The distinction is razor-thin. If the majority of the company's revenue comes from selling starter kits and mandatory monthly inventory to its own members rather than selling products to the general public, it's essentially a pyramid scheme with a product attached as a legal shield.
Why Are MLMs Bad for Your Relationships?
It turns every friendship into a sales lead. That’s the saddest part.
When you join an MLM, you are often told to make a "List of 100." This is a list of everyone you know—family, friends, your dentist, your ex-boyfriend’s mom. You are coached to "rekindle" these relationships, but with an ulterior motive. This creates a profound sense of betrayal. When a friend reaches out to grab coffee, you expect a chat about life. Instead, you get a pitch for a "revolutionary" weight-loss coffee or a skincare line that "literally changes lives."
The psychological toll is heavy. MLMs often employ "love bombing" techniques. When you first join, the community showers you with praise and validation. But the moment you question the lack of profits or express a desire to quit, that support vanishes. You’re told you aren't "hustling" hard enough. You're told you have a "poverty mindset." This creates a cult-like environment where leaving feels like losing your entire social circle.
The Financial "Pay to Play" Trap
Let's talk about "garage-qualifying." This is a term used in the industry to describe distributors who buy massive amounts of inventory just to stay active or hit a certain rank.
👉 See also: Syrian Dinar to Dollar: Why Everyone Gets the Name (and the Rate) Wrong
Most MLMs have a "minimum monthly volume" requirement. If you don’t sell a certain amount, you lose your commissions. If you can't find customers, you end up buying the product yourself to keep your status. This is how people end up with garages full of LuLaRoe leggings or crates of overpriced vitamins they can’t get rid of. You’re not a business owner; you’re the MLM’s primary customer.
- Initial Investment: Starter kits can cost anywhere from $99 to several thousand dollars.
- Monthly Fees: Back-office website fees and mandatory auto-ships.
- Conventions: Distributors are pressured to spend thousands on travel and tickets for "training" events.
- Marketing Materials: You pay for your own samples, catalogs, and "swag."
When you add it all up, the "side hustle" is actually a massive liability.
The Regulation Gap and Vague Income Disclosures
Why are these companies allowed to exist? Because they have powerful lobbies. The Direct Selling Association (DSA) spends millions ensuring that regulations stay loose.
If you actually look at the "Income Disclosure Statements" that MLMs are legally required to publish, the numbers are grim. For example, in many major MLMs, the "median" annual income for the bottom 90% of distributors is often $0. And that’s before expenses. These companies use "lifestyle" marketing to distract from these stats. They show the 0.1% who won the "free" car (which, by the way, is usually just a lease in the distributor's name that the company pays for only as long as they hit high sales targets). If your sales drop, you are stuck with the monthly lease payment for that white Mercedes.
Actionable Steps: How to Spot and Avoid the Trap
If you’re being pitched or if you’re already in deep, here is how you navigate the situation without losing your shirt or your sanity.
✨ Don't miss: New Zealand currency to AUD: Why the exchange rate is shifting in 2026
1. Ask for a Real Profit and Loss Statement
Don't look at "gross commissions." Ask the person pitching you to show their actual net profit after taxes, inventory costs, shipping, and fees. If they can’t or won’t show it, walk away.
2. Check the "Retail to Internal" Sales Ratio
Ask what percentage of the company’s total sales comes from people who are not signed up as distributors. A healthy company sells to the public. A predatory one sells to its "workforce."
3. Research the "Anti-MLM" Movement
There is a massive community of former "top earners" who have left the industry and are now exposing the truth. Look up creators like Hannah Alonzo or Roberta Blevins (featured in the documentary LuLaRich). Their stories provide the context that the glossy brochures leave out.
4. Set a "Hard Quit" Limit
If you are currently in an MLM and convinced it will work, set a date and a dollar amount. "If I have not made a net profit of $500 by June, I am done." This prevents "sunk cost fallacy" from keeping you trapped for years.
5. Protect Your Boundaries
It is okay to say no. You can be firm: "I value our friendship, but I do not support the MLM business model and I’m not interested in the products or the opportunity. Let’s talk about something else."
MLMs are bad because they monetize hope and weaponize community. They target the vulnerable—stay-at-home parents, military spouses, and people struggling with debt—and sell them a dream that is statistically impossible to achieve. Real business involves risk, but it shouldn't involve a 99% failure rate built into the very blueprints of the company. Understanding the mechanics of these organizations is the only way to protect your finances and your future.
If you are looking for a side income, consider freelance work, tutoring, or selling a skill on a platform where you own the work. You don't need a downline to be successful. You just need a fair shake, and MLMs aren't giving you one.