Why Apricot Lane Farms from The Biggest Little Farm is Still Sparking Debates

Why Apricot Lane Farms from The Biggest Little Farm is Still Sparking Debates

It started with a barking dog named Todd. That’s the real reason John and Molly Chester traded their cramped Los Angeles apartment for 200 acres of dirt in Moorpark, California. If you’ve seen the 2018 documentary The Biggest Little Farm, you know the story looks like a fairy tale. Two dreamers buy a dead piece of land, plant thousands of fruit trees, and suddenly nature is singing in harmony. But honestly? The reality of Apricot Lane Farms is a lot messier, more expensive, and more controversial than a 90-minute film can ever capture.

People usually come to this story looking for hope. They want to believe that we can "fix" the planet by just planting more things. While that’s partly true, the Chesters quickly found out that nature is kind of a jerk. You plant an orchard, and the snails arrive to eat the leaves. You bring in ducks to eat the snails, and then the coyotes show up to eat the ducks. It is a constant, exhausting cycle of life and death that most "homesteading" influencers conveniently leave out of their Instagram grids.

The Brutal Reality Behind the Cinematic Magic

When the cameras aren't rolling, the farm is a massive business operation. This isn't just a couple of people with shovels. The Biggest Little Farm shows the struggle, but it doesn't always show the sheer scale of the investment required to bring a "dead" farm back to life. Alan York, the legendary biodynamic consultant who mentored the Chesters until his death in 2014, was the architect of this madness. He didn't just suggest a garden; he designed a massive, self-regulating ecosystem.

Most people don't realize that the soil they started with was basically concrete. Decades of monocropping (growing just one thing over and over) had sucked the life out of the dirt. To fix it, they had to move beyond organic. They went for regenerative agriculture. This isn't just a buzzword. It involves cover cropping, massive composting operations, and rotational grazing. The idea is simple: use animals to fertilize the land so you don't need synthetic chemicals. But executing that on 200 acres? It's a logistical nightmare that requires a massive team and significant capital.

Why Some Farmers Are Skeptical of the Dream

There is a bit of a divide in the agricultural world regarding Apricot Lane Farms. On one hand, you have the environmentalists who see it as a blueprint for the future. On the other, you have multi-generational farmers who point out that the Chesters had access to funding most farmers will never see. It’s hard to talk about the farm without mentioning the backing of investors like the late Marc Friedland.

Can a regular family start a "Biggest Little Farm" without a film crew and a massive bankroll? Probably not at this scale.

✨ Don't miss: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know

However, dismissing the project because of its funding misses the point. The Chesters aren't just growing food; they're running a massive experiment. They are proving that you can bring biodiversity back to a wasteland. When the Thomas Fire ripped through Ventura County in 2017, the farm's healthy soil and moisture-heavy ecosystem acted as a partial buffer. That’s not just "nice"—it's a survival strategy for a changing climate.

The Great Snail and Coyote Wars

The film's most famous "arc" involves the snails. Thousands of them. They were destroying the citrus trees. Instead of spraying pesticides, John and Molly turned their ducks loose. It worked. The ducks got fat, the snails disappeared, and the trees thrived.

But then came the coyotes.

This is where the sentimentality of the documentary hits a wall. To run a farm like this, you have to accept that things will die. A lot. The coyotes slaughtered the chickens and the ducks. It was gruesome. The solution wasn't to "exterminate" the coyotes, which is what most traditional farmers would do. Instead, they brought in livestock guardian dogs and reinforced their perimeter. They chose to live with the predator rather than just erasing it. It’s a bold choice, but it’s also one that requires constant vigilance and more money for infrastructure.

What "The Biggest Little Farm" Teaches Us About Soil

Soil is everything. Seriously. If you take away one thing from the Chesters' journey, it should be that dirt is alive. Or at least, it should be. At Apricot Lane, they track the health of their soil with the same intensity a day trader tracks the stock market.

🔗 Read more: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles

By using diverse cover crops, they pull carbon out of the atmosphere and store it in the ground. This makes the land a giant sponge. During California's brutal droughts, a farm with high organic matter in its soil stays green much longer than a neighbor’s dust bowl. It’s a practical application of the science found in studies by the Rodale Institute, which suggests that regenerative organic agriculture could actually sequester more carbon than we currently emit.

Is it a perfect system? No.

John Chester has been very open about the fact that they are still learning. Sometimes the "balance" they seek feels more like a frantic see-saw. They have over 75 varieties of stone fruit, plus lemons, avocados, and a whole zoo of livestock. Managing that diversity is infinitely more complex than growing 200 acres of just almonds.

Misconceptions About the Farm's Impact

A common criticism is that Apricot Lane Farms is just a "boutique" project that can't feed the world. People argue that we need industrial agriculture to keep billions of people alive.

Here’s the counter-argument: Industrial agriculture is currently killing the very land we need to survive. We are losing topsoil at an alarming rate. While Apricot Lane might be a high-end example, the techniques they use—like minimal tillage and integrated pest management—are being adopted by large-scale commercial farms out of pure necessity. They aren't doing it to be "green"; they're doing it because their soil is dying and their yields are dropping.

💡 You might also like: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong

Key Practical Insights from the Apricot Lane Model

If you're looking to apply some of this "Big Little Farm" energy to your own life or small-scale garden, here is the reality of what works:

  • Observation is better than intervention. Before you spray a bug or pull a weed, wait. See what eats the bug. See if the weed is actually protecting the soil. The Chesters spent years just watching how the wind and water moved across their land.
  • Diversity is your insurance policy. If you only grow one thing and a specific pest hits, you’re done. If you grow fifty things, you’ll lose five, but the other forty-five will keep you afloat.
  • Compost is the only "magic" solution. They produce massive amounts of "liquid gold" (worm compost tea). It’s the engine of the farm. If you want healthy plants, you stop feeding the plant and start feeding the soil microbes.
  • Accept the "Death" part of the circle. Whether it’s Emma the pig’s health scares or the loss of a flock, a working farm is not a petting zoo. It requires a certain toughness that the movie softens with beautiful cinematography.

The Future of Apricot Lane Farms

Today, the farm is a certified biodynamic powerhouse. They sell at local farmers' markets, to high-end restaurants, and through their own online shop. They’ve become a destination for researchers and filmmakers alike.

But the real legacy of The Biggest Little Farm isn't the movie itself. It's the 200 acres of Moorpark that used to be a desert and is now a lush, humming ecosystem. It serves as a proof of concept. Even if you don't have millions of dollars, the principle remains: nature wants to heal. It just needs us to stop getting in the way.

To really grasp the complexity, you have to look past the beautiful shots of the sunset and the cute piglets. You have to see the mud, the debt, the heartbreak, and the endless work. Regenerative farming isn't a return to the past; it's a high-tech, high-intelligence leap into a future where we actually work with the planet.

Next Steps for Implementation:

Start by testing your own soil's organic matter. You can't manage what you don't measure. If you're a consumer, look for the "Regenerative Organic Certified" label on products, which is a much stricter standard than "Organic." Support local farmers who are integrating livestock with crops, as this "closed-loop" system is the gold standard for land restoration. Finally, if you're ever in Moorpark, check for their occasional farm tours or volunteer days; seeing the density of the life there in person changes your perspective on what "productive" land actually looks like.