It starts with a blurry photo. You've seen it on your Instagram feed or a frantic text in the group chat: a plastic stick with two pink lines, usually accompanied by some goofy caption about a "surprise" or "oops." Then, twelve hours later, the "April Fools!" reveal drops.
Some people laugh. Honestly, though? Most people just cringe.
The April Fools pregnancy test prank has become a staple of the internet, but the vibe has shifted significantly over the last few years. What used to be seen as a harmless, albeit unoriginal, gag is now widely regarded as a massive social faux pas. It’s one of those things that feels funny in your head until you realize the sheer weight of the biology and emotion you’re actually messing with.
The psychology of the fake positive
Why do people do it? Usually, it’s for the hit of dopamine that comes with a notification explosion. Announcing a pregnancy is one of the few life events that guarantees universal attention. If you’re looking for a quick way to get 200 comments on a Facebook post, this is it. It’s low-effort drama.
But there’s a massive disconnect between the "prankster" and the audience. When you post a photo of a pregnancy test, you aren't just sharing a joke; you are triggering a specific emotional response in every person who sees it. For your parents, it might be a sudden, heart-thumping hope for a grandchild. For your friends, it’s a shift in how they view your future. You are essentially "borrowing" the gravity of a life-altering event for a five-second laugh. That’s why it often feels so cheap.
The internet is forever, too. Even after you’ve deleted the post or updated the caption, that digital footprint sticks. Google’s algorithms and social media caches don’t always catch the "just kidding" part immediately.
Why the internet started fighting back
If you look at the trending topics every April 1st, you’ll notice a huge wave of "PSA" posts. These aren't just people being "sensitive" or "snowflakes," as some might argue. The pushback against the April Fools pregnancy test comes from a place of deep, lived experience regarding infertility and loss.
🔗 Read more: The Real Caffeine Amount in Cup of Coffee: Why Your Daily Brew is Never Consistent
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), roughly 1 in 6 people globally experience infertility. That’s a staggering number. Now, think about your follower count. If you have 600 followers, statistically, 100 of them might be struggling to conceive. For someone who has spent years—and thousands of dollars—trying to get those two lines to appear, seeing someone treat it as a punchline is like a physical gut punch.
Then there is the reality of pregnancy loss. The CDC and various health organizations note that about 10% to 20% of known pregnancies end in miscarriage. For a woman who has recently lost a pregnancy, seeing a fake test isn't funny. It’s a reminder of a trauma. It’s a mockery of a moment they would give anything to have back for real.
The backlash became so intense that organizations like Path2Parenthood and various fertility clinics started running awareness campaigns specifically for April 1st. They’re not trying to ban humor; they’re just pointing out that there are a million things to joke about that don’t involve reproductive health.
The logistics of the prank (and why they fail)
If you're still thinking about doing it, consider the technical hurdles. Most people who try to pull off an April Fools pregnancy test prank use one of three methods. None of them are particularly clever.
First, there are the "fake" tests sold on sites like Amazon or at joke shops. These are designed to turn positive regardless of what liquid hits them. They often look slightly "off"—the plastic is cheaper, the lines are a weird shade of purple-pink that doesn't look like a real HCG reaction. Anyone who has actually been pregnant can spot a fake test from a mile away.
Second, people use markers. This is the most common and the most embarrassing. Using a pink highlighter to draw a second line on a real test is incredibly obvious when the photo is high-resolution. The "ink" doesn't bleed into the wick the same way a chemical reaction does.
Third—and this is the weirdest one—is people buying "real" positive tests from strangers online. Yes, there is a secondary market on sites like Craigslist or certain subreddits where pregnant women sell their positive tests. Beyond the obvious "ick" factor, this is a massive privacy risk. You're bringing someone else's biological material into your house for a joke? Think about that for a second. It’s objectively strange behavior.
High-profile fails and celebrity backlash
Celebrities haven't been immune to this temptation either. One of the most famous examples of this blowing up in someone's face was Justin Bieber back in 2019. He posted a photo of an ultrasound, and when fans got excited, he doubled down with a photo of his wife, Hailey, at a doctor’s office.
The backlash was swift and brutal. People pointed out that it was insensitive to those who can't have children. Bieber eventually apologized, stating he didn't mean to be insensitive, but the damage was done. It became a textbook example of how even a "harmless" joke can alienate millions of people in an instant.
The lesson here is that the "April Fools pregnancy test" doesn't just annoy strangers; it can actually damage your brand or your personal reputation. It makes the prankster look out of touch.
🔗 Read more: The Real Reason Christmas Lights Old Fashioned Style Are Making a Massive Comeback
What to do if you’ve already posted it
Maybe you’re reading this and realizing you messed up. Or maybe you did this years ago and it just popped up in your Facebook Memories.
If you just posted it: Honestly, the best move is to take it down. Don't leave it up for the engagement. You can post a simple "Hey, realized this was in poor taste, my bad" and move on. People appreciate self-awareness.
If you’re seeing someone else do it: You don't necessarily need to go on a crusade in their comments section. Sometimes a private message works better. "Hey, I know you’re just joking, but I’ve got a couple of friends going through IVF right now and this might really hurt them" is usually enough to make someone rethink their post.
Better ways to be funny on April 1st
Humor is subjective, sure. But good humor usually punches up, not down. Or it’s just plain weird. If you want to prank your partner or your parents, there are plenty of ways to do it that don't involve life-altering medical news.
👉 See also: How to Use Magnanimous in a Sentence Without Sounding Like a Dictionary
- The classic "broken screen" wallpaper on their laptop.
- The "non-lathering" soap (clear nail polish over a bar of soap).
- Switching the salt and sugar (old school, but effective).
- Telling everyone you’re moving to a country you’ve never visited.
- Announcing you’ve joined a competitive kazoo league.
These things are light. They’re reversible. They don't leave people feeling emotionally manipulated.
The bottom line on the April Fools pregnancy test
We live in an era where we’re more aware of each other's hidden struggles than ever before. We know more about the "silent" grief of infertility because people are finally talking about it. Because of that, the April Fools pregnancy test just doesn't fit into the modern world anymore. It’s a relic of a time when we weren't as tuned in to the person on the other side of the screen.
If the goal of a joke is to make people laugh, and your joke makes a significant portion of your audience feel sad or resentful, it’s a bad joke. It’s that simple.
Actionable Steps
- Audit your social media history. If you have old "fake pregnancy" posts from your younger, less-informed days, hit delete. They don't age well.
- Think before you "Like." If a friend posts a fake test today, don't feed the algorithm. By not engaging, you help that post die a natural death rather than pushing it into more people’s feeds.
- Educate yourself on infertility. If you don't understand why people get so upset, read a few stories from people who have gone through loss. It’ll give you a lot of perspective on why those two little lines are so sacred to so many.
- Find a better bit. If you want to be the office prankster, go for something that involves googly eyes on everything in the fridge. It’s funnier, it’s cuter, and it won't end with you having to write a public apology.