She isn't the tank. If you go into Hell-A expecting to soak up damage like Ryan or Carla while playing as Amy, you're going to see the "You Are Dead" screen. A lot. Amy is weird. She’s a Paralympian runner with a prosthetic leg, a high-speed glass cannon, and arguably the most technical character Dambuster Studios put into the game. Most players pick Jacob because he’s on the box art, or Dani because her health regeneration is basically a cheat code. But Amy? Amy in Dead Island 2 is for the people who want to play a combat rhythm game while everyone else is playing a brawler.
It’s about the hustle.
Her stats are lopsided. She has the highest Agility in the game, which sounds great on paper until you realize her Toughness and Peak Health are bottom-of-the-barrel. In a game where a single burning Walker can ruin your day, having low health is a massive risk. But that’s the trade-off for being the fastest thing on two legs in Venice Beach.
The Reality of Amy's Playstyle
You have to move. Constantly.
Amy’s kit is built entirely around "Divide and Conquer." Her innate skills reward you for isolating zombies and hitting them with thrown weapons. This is where most people get frustrated. In a horde-based game, being rewarded for finding a single enemy feels counter-intuitive. However, once you realize that Amy in Dead Island 2 is designed to thin the herd before the herd even knows she’s there, the game changes. You aren't a frontline soldier; you're a skirmisher.
Analyzing the Innate Skills
Let's look at what she actually brings to the table:
- Relief Pitcher: This is her bread and butter. You get stamina back every time you hit a zombie with a thrown weapon. In the early game, this feels useless because you only have a couple of shoddily made pipes. Later? When you have specialized throwing knives and elemental curves? It's infinite energy.
- Divide and Conquer: You get a minor damage boost when attacking isolated zombies.
"Isolated" is the keyword. It doesn't mean a mile away from everyone else. It just means they aren't shoulder-to-shoulder with another shambler. This encourages a very specific loop: throw a weapon to proc Relief Pitcher, sprint in, hit the isolated target with the damage buff, and dash out before the rest of the pack rotates.
It's sweaty. It’s high-effort. Honestly, it’s some of the most fun you can have in the game if you hate just standing still and mashing the R2 button.
Why People Struggle With Her
The "Toughness" stat in Dead Island 2 is a measurement of physical damage reduction. Amy starts with a 1 out of 5. That is pathetic. If a Crusher lands a overhead smash and you don't dodge, you aren't just hurt—you're basically a red smudge on the pavement of Ocean Avenue.
Because of this, Amy players have to master the Dodge mechanic immediately. While Ryan players can rely on the Block/Parry system to regain stability and health, Amy relies on the Dodge-offset. If you time your dodges perfectly, you regain stamina and can trigger a counter-attack that usually results in a limb removal.
The Gear Problem
You can't just use any weapon. Well, you can, but you shouldn't. Amy excels with Finesse weapons. Think hunting knives, katanas, and anything with high attack speed. Heavy, blunt weapons like sledgehammers actually work against her Agility. Why would you want to slow yourself down with a 20-pound mallet when you could be landing four stabs in the same timeframe?
The "Sharp" weapon class is her best friend. Since she lacks the raw strength of the larger Slayers, she relies on Bleed damage and Maiming to neutralize threats. If you cut the legs off a runner, they aren't a threat anymore. Amy is the queen of "de-legging."
The Best Skill Cards for Amy
You need to lean into the glass cannon archetype. Don't try to fix her health; it's a lost cause. Instead, make her so fast and so deadly that nothing can touch her.
Dash Strike is non-negotiable. It replaces your heavy attack with a forward-lunging palm strike that weakens enemies. For Amy, this is a literal lifesaver. It closes the gap instantly or allows for a quick escape. Pair this with The Limb Reaper (regain health on maim) and you suddenly have a way to stay in the fight without relying on medkits.
Then there’s the Street Surgeon card. This rewards you for—you guessed it—maiming. Since Amy is already incentivized to go for limbs to keep herself safe, this card creates a recursive loop of damage buffs.
Is Amy Actually "The Best" Slayer?
Honestly? No. If we’re talking about "meta" efficiency for a casual playthrough, Dani or Bruno usually take the top spots. Bruno has insane critical damage from behind, and Dani’s explosions on heavy attacks make crowd control a joke.
But Amy in Dead Island 2 offers a different kind of "best." She offers the best movement. In a game that can sometimes feel a bit "clunky" and heavy, Amy feels like she’s playing an entirely different engine. She’s fluid. If you’ve played games like Mirror's Edge or Dying Light and you miss that sense of momentum, Amy is the only Slayer who even comes close to scratching that itch.
Mastering the Throwing Mechanic
Most players treat weapon throwing as a last resort. You throw your sword when you're about to die or when a Suicider is getting too close. With Amy, throwing is your primary opener.
- The Combo: Throw a low-tier "bait" weapon to proc Relief Pitcher.
- The Follow-up: Sprint toward the staggered enemy.
- The Finish: Use a high-crit Finesse weapon to take off a limb.
- The Recovery: Retrieve your thrown weapon while dodging out of the way of the next zombie.
It sounds complicated because it is. You're juggling your inventory constantly. But by the time you reach the pier in Santa Monica, you'll be doing this instinctively. It feels like a dance. A very gory, prosthetic-assisted dance.
Misconceptions About Amy
A lot of people think her prosthetic leg affects gameplay. It doesn't. It's a cool character detail and part of her backstory as a runner, but she doesn't have a "weakness" there in terms of hitboxes. Zombies don't target it specifically.
Another misconception is that she’s a "ranged" character. While her skills focus on throwing, Dead Island 2 is still 90% a melee game. You cannot play Amy like a traditional archer or sniper. If you try to stay at range forever, you will run out of weapons to throw and get cornered. You have to be comfortable being in the "pocket"—that dangerous space just outside a zombie's reach.
Practical Steps for Amy Players
If you’re just starting your run or thinking about switching to a new save, keep these specific strategies in mind to avoid the frustration of the early game.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Angry Birds Red Twitter Account is Actually Peak Internet Comedy
- Rush the Dodge Skill: Do not stick with Block. You are too fragile to absorb the impact of a heavy hit even if you block it. Switch to Dodge the second the card becomes available.
- Prioritize Agility Mods: When you get to a workbench, look for mods that increase your attack speed. You want to be a whirlwind of paper cuts.
- The "One-Two" Rule: Never swing more than twice at a zombie if there are others nearby. Swing, swing, dodge. If you get greedy, you'll get grabbed, and Amy's low health means a grab from a basic Walker can take out a third of your bar.
- Carry "Trash" Weapons: Keep two or three low-quality knives in your wheel specifically for throwing. You don't want to throw your legendary, fully-modded katana into a bush and lose it during a chaotic fight.
Amy in Dead Island 2 is a specialist. She’s the character you pick when you’ve already beaten the game once and want to see if you actually mastered the mechanics. She’s punishing, she’s fragile, but she’s undeniably the most rewarding Slayer to play once you stop trying to fight like a tank and start moving like an athlete.
Stop standing still. Start throwing things.