Why All Things Fall Apart Novel Still Bothers People (In a Good Way)

Why All Things Fall Apart Novel Still Bothers People (In a Good Way)

If you’ve ever sat in a high school English class, you’ve probably seen that iconic orange and black Penguin Classics cover. It’s everywhere. Honestly, All Things Fall Apart novel is one of those books that feels like a permanent fixture of "literary culture," but most people treat it like a museum piece rather than a living, breathing, and frankly violent story. Chinua Achebe didn't write this to be a dusty textbook. He wrote it because he was sick of seeing Nigerians portrayed as "savages" by European writers like Joseph Conrad.

He wanted to hit back. Hard.

The book is weirdly polarizing if you actually read it closely. Some people see Okonkwo, the main guy, as a hero. Others think he’s a toxic nightmare. But that’s the point. Achebe wasn't interested in making a "perfect" African hero to counter European lies. He wanted to show a complex, flawed, and deeply traditional society that was falling apart from the inside long before the first missionary even showed up.

The Okonkwo Problem: Hero or Villain?

Okonkwo is a lot. He's obsessed with masculinity because his dad, Unoka, was—to put it bluntly—a "failure" in the eyes of Umuofia society. Unoka liked music. He liked flutes. He didn't like war. In a culture that valued titles and yams, Unoka was a "woman" (agbala). So, Okonkwo spends his whole life overcompensating. He’s the guy who works harder than everyone, talks louder, and hits his wives. It’s uncomfortable to read.

But here’s where it gets nuanced.

Achebe shows us that Okonkwo’s trauma isn't just personal; it's cultural. The Umuofia society demands this kind of rigid strength. When Okonkwo kills Ikemefuna—the boy who called him "father"—it’s one of the most devastating moments in literature. He does it because he’s terrified of looking weak. He’s a victim of his own culture's expectations as much as he is a champion of them. It’s a messy, brutal cycle. You sort of pity him, but you also kind of want to see him get taken down a notch.

What People Get Wrong About the "Clash of Cultures"

Most summaries of All Things Fall Apart novel say it's about "colonialism vs. tradition." That’s a bit of a surface-level take.

Basically, the book is split into three parts. The first part is just... life. It’s about wrestling, yam harvests, and complex judicial systems involving masked spirits (egwugwu). Achebe spends so much time on this because he needs you to understand that Africa wasn't a "blank slate" before Europeans arrived. It was a functioning, sophisticated world with its own laws and its own flaws.

Then comes the shift.

When the white men arrive, they don't just show up with guns. They show up with a new religion and a new government. And the genius of the book is showing why people joined them. It wasn't just forced conversion. The outcasts of the village—the people the traditional culture rejected—found a home in Christianity. The "osu" (outcasts) and the parents of twins (who were left to die in the Evil Forest) saw the new religion as a way out.

✨ Don't miss: What Day is the 3 Kings Day: Why Your Calendar Might Be Overlooking the Biggest Party of the Year

The breaking point

The tragedy isn't just that the British "invaded." It's that they found the cracks that already existed in the village and wedged them open. Nwoye, Okonkwo’s son, leaves his father to join the Christians. It’s not because he’s "brainwashed." It’s because the traditional system, with its demands for child sacrifice and rigid masculinity, didn't have room for his sensitive soul.

The title, borrowed from W.B. Yeats’ poem The Second Coming, is literal. The center could not hold because the center was already under immense pressure from within.

Achebe’s Language: Writing Back to the Empire

Achebe did something radical in 1958. He wrote in English, but he made the English "sound" Igbo.

He uses proverbs constantly. "Proverbs are the palm-oil with which words are eaten." This isn't just flavor. It’s a political statement. By incorporating the rhythms and metaphors of the Igbo language into a Western novel structure, he forced the English language to carry the weight of an African experience. He didn't translate the "untranslatable" bits. He made the reader work for it.

Some critics at the time—and even later, like the Kenyan writer Ngũgĩ wa Thiong'o—argued that African writers should only write in African languages. Ngũgĩ eventually stopped writing in English altogether. Achebe disagreed. He felt that English was a tool he could subvert to reach a global audience and tell the story of his people on his own terms. It worked. The book has been translated into over 50 languages and has sold millions of copies.

The Ending That Still Stings

The ending of All Things Fall Apart novel is a gut punch. After Okonkwo commits suicide—an act that is a "legal" abomination in his own culture—the District Commissioner looks at his body.

He doesn't see a man. He doesn't see a tragedy.

He sees a "paragraph" in the book he's planning to write, titled The Pacification of the Primitive Tribes of the Lower Niger. That’s the ultimate insult. Okonkwo’s entire life, his struggles, his titles, and his fall are reduced to a footnote in a colonial bureaucrat's memoir. It’s a haunting reminder of how history is written by the victors and how easily a complex human life can be erased by a pen.


How to actually "use" this book today

If you’re looking to get more out of your reading or study of Achebe's work, don't just treat it as a historical artifact. It's a lens for looking at how any culture deals with rapid change and internal dissent.

  • Read the sequels: Most people stop at the first book. Read No Longer at Ease and Arrow of God. They complete the "African Trilogy" and show how the trauma of Okonkwo’s generation trickled down into the modern Nigerian state.
  • Compare the "Manliness" Narrative: Look at Okonkwo alongside modern discussions of toxic masculinity. His struggle to differentiate himself from his "unmanly" father is a theme that resonates in almost every culture today.
  • Study the Proverbs: If you’re a writer, look at how Achebe uses metaphors. He doesn't just say "life is hard." He says, "a man who pays respect to the great paves the way for his own greatness." It's about specificity.
  • Watch for the Silences: Notice who doesn't get a voice in the book. The women, like Ekwefi, have powerful stories, but they are often suppressed by the patriarchal structure of Umuofia. Examining those silences tells you just as much as the dialogue does.

The best way to respect this novel is to argue with it. It’s a book meant to provoke, to challenge, and to remind us that "falling apart" is often a slow process that starts long before anyone notices the cracks. Go back and read the scene where the egwugwu appear in the village square; it’s one of the most vivid depictions of a living tradition ever put to paper. Then, look at the final sentence again. The gap between those two worlds is where the real story lives.