/wion/media/post_attachments/files/2023/09/21/381029-american-horror-story-ranking.png)
Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk basically changed TV in 2011. Before they dropped Murder House, the idea of a "horror anthology" series on a major cable network felt like a massive gamble. It wasn’t just about ghosts. It was about the vibe. The aesthetics. The weird, uncomfortable sexual tension mixed with genuine gore. Since then, we’ve seen over a decade of leather men, witches, clowns, and aliens.
Looking back at all of the seasons of American Horror Story, you start to notice a pattern. Every single year, fans claim the show has "lost its way," yet they keep coming back. Why? Because AHS isn't just a show; it's a repertory theater company where Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, and Jessica Lange get to chew the scenery in different costumes. Sometimes it’s brilliant. Sometimes it’s a total mess. That’s kind of the point.
The Era of Peak Camp: Murder House, Asylum, and Coven
The first three years were the "golden era." Murder House took the classic haunted house trope and injected it with modern family trauma. You’ve got the Harmon family moving into a Los Angeles mansion that is, frankly, overcrowded with spirits. It was tight, focused, and genuinely creepy. It also introduced us to the Rubber Man, a visual that basically defined the show's marketing for years.
Then came Asylum. Honestly, many critics still call this the peak of the entire franchise. It was dark. It was bleak. It had Briarcliff Manor, a possessed nun, a serial killer named Bloody Face, and—just for the hell of it—aliens. It shouldn't have worked. It was way too much plot for one season. Yet, because of Lily Rabe’s performance as the possessed Sister Mary Eunice and Jessica Lange’s descent into madness as Sister Jude, it remains the gold standard for horror TV.
By the time Coven rolled around, the show shifted gears. It became "Tumblr famous." The aesthetic moved to New Orleans, focusing on a group of young witches at Miss Robichaux's Academy. It was less about scaring you and more about the "bitchy" dialogue and high-fashion funeral wear. It introduced the concept of the Seven Wonders and gave us the iconic "Surprise, bitch" meme. It was the moment AHS realized it could be a lifestyle brand as much as a horror show.
🔗 Read more: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
When Things Got Weird: Freak Show and Hotel
Freak Show is where the cracks started to show for some fans, though visually, it was stunning. Set in 1950s Florida, it followed one of the last remaining trope troupes. Twisty the Clown was a masterpiece of character design—genuinely terrifying—but the season struggled with its pacing once he was gone. It felt like a series of vignettes rather than a cohesive story. But you can't talk about Freak Show without mentioning the musical numbers. Jessica Lange singing David Bowie? It was weird. It was polarizing. It was peak Murphy.
Hotel was the first year without Jessica Lange, which felt like a death knell at the time. Enter Lady Gaga. Playing The Countess at the Hotel Cortez, Gaga brought a different kind of energy—vampiric, cold, and incredibly stylish. The season was drenched in blood and neon. While the "Ten Commandments Killer" subplot felt a bit like a Se7en knockoff, the production design was arguably the best the series had ever seen.
The Experimental Middle Years: Roanoke and Cult
After the glitz of Hotel, the creators pivoted hard. Roanoke was a "show within a show." The first half was a parody of those "My Roanoke Nightmare" paranormal documentaries, and the second half was a "found footage" nightmare where the real actors and the "re-enactment" actors were trapped together. It was divisive. Some people hated the meta-commentary; others loved that the show finally felt scary again. It was a stripped-back, brutal experience that proved the show could still surprise people.
Then came Cult. No supernatural elements. Just clowns and politics. Released right after the 2016 election, it tapped into the collective anxiety of the country. Evan Peters played Kai Anderson, a manipulative cult leader, and it was easily his most demanding role. He played multiple historical cult leaders in flashbacks, too. It was a season that felt uncomfortably real, trading ghosts for the horror of what people do to each other when they’re afraid.
💡 You might also like: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
Fanservice and The "Double Feature" Experiment
Apocalypse was basically a gift to the hardcore fans. It was the long-awaited crossover between Murder House and Coven. Seeing the witches return to stop the Antichrist (Michael Langdon) was high-octane fanservice. It wasn't the most logical story—lots of time travel shenanigans—but seeing Madison Montgomery "tell" someone they’re a "basic bitch" one more time was enough for most viewers.
1984 took us to Camp Redwood. It was a total love letter to 80s slasher films like Friday the 13th. It was campy, gory, and had a killer synth-wave soundtrack. It didn't take itself seriously, which was a refreshing change of pace.
Then we got Double Feature. This was an odd one. It split the season into two distinct stories: Red Tide (vampire-like writers in Provincetown) and Death Valley (aliens and Eisenhower). Red Tide started off as one of the best-written arcs in years, but the ending felt rushed. Death Valley, on the other hand, was met with a pretty cold reception. It was a bold experiment that didn't quite stick the landing, but you have to respect the swing they took.
The Modern Shift: NYC and Delicate
The most recent entries in the catalog of all of the seasons of American Horror Story have felt more somber. NYC was a departure. Set in the 1980s gay scene in New York, it dealt with a mysterious illness killing people—a clear allegory for the AIDS crisis—while a leather-clad killer stalked the streets. It was haunting and tragic. It felt more like a prestige drama than a campy horror show.
📖 Related: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Then came Delicate, the first season based on a book (Delicate Condition by Danielle Valentine). It also marked the first time Ryan Murphy didn't serve as showrunner, handing the reins to Halley Feiffer. Starring Emma Roberts and Kim Kardashian, it focused on the horrors of pregnancy and fame. It was a slower burn, more psychological and "gaslighty" than the explosive seasons of the past.
Why the Order of Your Rewatch Matters
If you're planning on diving back into the anthology, don't just go in chronological order. The show is built on connections. If you watch Coven and Murder House back-to-back, Apocalypse hits much harder. If you want pure horror, stick to Asylum and Roanoke. If you want a fun, neon-soaked ride, go with 1984 and Hotel.
The reality is that AHS is a "vibe" show. You don't watch it for airtight logic. You watch it for the performances, the costumes, and those moments of pure, unadulterated "what did I just see?" that only Ryan Murphy can provide.
How to Rank Your Own Experience
Everyone's ranking is different. That’s the beauty of it. To get the most out of the series, keep these things in mind:
- Acknowledge the tropes. The show loves to subvert classic horror cliches. If a character seems like a stereotype, they probably won't stay that way.
- Watch the background. Especially in seasons like Murder House and Hotel, there are often ghosts or clues hidden in the shadows of the frame that you won't see the first time.
- Follow the actors. Part of the fun is seeing Sarah Paulson go from a medium to a reporter to a head witch to a conjoined twin. It’s an acting masterclass disguised as a soap opera.
Whether you're a "Coven" stan or an "Asylum" purist, the impact of the series is undeniable. It paved the way for shows like The Haunting of Hill House and Channel Zero. It made horror "prestige" again. Even when it’s bad, it’s interesting. And in a world of boring, safe television, "interesting" is a win.
To truly appreciate the evolution of the series, try watching one "classic" season (1-3) followed immediately by a "modern" season (10-12). The shift in cinematography and tone is wild, but the DNA—the obsession with American myths and the monsters we create—remains exactly the same. Turn off the lights, ignore the plot holes, and just let the madness wash over you.