Venice is a literal maze, and honestly, most of the food there is pretty mediocre. You walk past those menus with faded photos of spaghetti and realize you’re about to pay 20 Euros for something that came out of a microwave. It’s depressing. But then there’s Al Covo restaurant Venice. Tucked away in Castello, far enough from the madness of San Marco to feel like a secret but close enough to walk to, this place has been a holdout for real cooking since 1987.
It’s run by Cesare Benelli and his wife, Diane, who is originally from Texas. That sounds like an odd mix for an "authentic" Italian spot, right? It isn't. Diane handles the desserts—which are legendary—while Cesare obsessively tracks down the best ingredients from the lagoon. They aren't just making dinner; they're preserving a specific, fragile ecosystem of Venetian flavors.
The Fish Nobody Else Wants to Cook
Most tourists want sea bass. Or maybe salmon, which isn't even from here. At Al Covo, they look at you a little differently. Cesare is a founding member of the Ristoranti dell'Alleanza Slow Food, which basically means he's committed to local biodiversity.
You’ll see things on the menu like go. It’s a small, ugly lagoon fish. Most chefs won't touch it because it’s a pain to clean. But in a risotto? It’s pure silk. That’s the thing about Al Covo restaurant Venice—they take the "poor" ingredients of the Adriatic and treat them like gold.
They use moeche, those tiny soft-shell crabs that are only available for a few weeks in the spring and autumn. If you see them on the menu, order them. Don't think. Just do it. They’re deep-fried until they’re crunchy and saline, tasting exactly like the sea. If you miss that window, you’re stuck with the standard stuff, which is fine, but you’re missing the soul of the place.
📖 Related: Seeing Universal Studios Orlando from Above: What the Maps Don't Tell You
Is It Actually Worth the Price Tag?
Let’s be real. It’s not cheap. You’re going to spend money here.
Expect to pay around 80 to 120 Euros per person if you’re doing the full experience with wine. Some people complain about the portions because they expect a giant "American-style" mountain of pasta. That's not what this is. This is precision.
The wine list is actually one of the more interesting parts of the experience. They focus on "natural" wines—organic, biodynamic, things that haven't been messed with in a lab. If you aren't into that funky, fermented taste, tell the sommelier. They have plenty of traditional stuff, too, but the selection of white wines from the Friuli and Veneto regions is genuinely world-class.
Why You Can't Just Walk In
Venice is crowded. Like, "can't move your arms" crowded. Because Al Covo restaurant Venice is a darling of the Michelin Guide and basically every food critic who has ever stepped foot in Italy, you need a reservation.
👉 See also: How Long Ago Did the Titanic Sink? The Real Timeline of History's Most Famous Shipwreck
Don't email them the day of. Don't show up at 7:00 PM hoping for a miracle.
Booking a week or two out is the minimum for dinner. Lunch is sometimes easier, and honestly, sitting outside in the Campo della Pescaria when the light is hitting the bricks just right? It’s better than dinner. You get to watch the actual residents of Castello walk their dogs and live their lives while you eat raw shrimp that was swimming a few hours ago.
The Dessert Trap (That Isn't a Trap)
Usually, in Italy, you skip dessert at the restaurant and go find a gelateria. At Al Covo, that’s a mistake. Since Diane is in charge of the pastry side, there’s a level of technical skill there that you don't find in your average trattoria.
Their chocolate cake is famous, but look for the seasonal fruit tarts or anything involving Zante currants. It’s a weirdly specific thing, but the way they balance sugar and acidity is incredible. It’s the perfect end to a meal that’s usually quite salty and savory from all that lagoon seafood.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Newport Back Bay Science Center is the Best Kept Secret in Orange County
How to Get There Without Getting Lost
Castello is a great neighborhood, but it’s a labyrinth.
- Take the Vaporetto to the Arsenale stop.
- Walk toward the Riva degli Schiavoni.
- Turn inland at the Calle della Pescaria.
- If you hit a wall of tourists, you’ve gone the wrong way.
The restaurant is located at Castello 3968. If your GPS starts spinning, just look for the storefront with the understated wooden sign and the warm yellow light spilling out onto the pavement.
What Most People Get Wrong About Venetian Food
People think Venetian food is pizza. It’s not. Pizza isn't even from here.
People think it’s heavy meat sauces. Nope.
Authentic Venetian food is about the lagoon. It’s about salt, swamp, and tide. When you eat at Al Covo restaurant Venice, you’re eating the history of a city that was built on mud. The flavors are subtle. Sometimes they’re even a bit bitter. If you go in expecting "Italian-American" comfort food, you’ll be disappointed. If you go in wanting to understand why this city has survived for a thousand years, you’ll get it.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
- Book through their website or call them directly (+39 041 522 3812). Avoid third-party booking sites that take a cut or don't sync with their real book.
- Ask about the "Catch of the Day." The menu changes based on what the Rialto market has that morning. If Cesare found something weird and prickly at the market, that’s the thing you want to eat.
- Dress "Smart Casual." You don’t need a tuxedo, but don't show up in zip-off cargo shorts and a tank top. It’s a respect thing. Venetians appreciate it when you look like you tried.
- Plan for a long meal. This isn't a "fast-casual" spot. Expect to be there for at least two hours. Turn off your phone, look at the art on the walls, and actually talk to the people you’re with.
- Check the closing dates. They usually take a break in the winter (January/February) and sometimes a bit in August. Always check their official calendar before planning your entire trip around a meal there.
Venice is a city that is slowly sinking, both literally and under the weight of tourism. Supporting places like Al Covo is one of the few ways to ensure the "real" version of the city doesn't disappear entirely. You get a great meal, and the city gets to keep a piece of its soul. It's a fair trade.