The MGM Grand Garden Arena was loud. Like, uncomfortably loud. On May 25, 2019, the atmosphere in Las Vegas didn't just feel like another wrestling show. It felt like a riot was about to break out, but the good kind. People were tired. For years, if you wanted big-budget, high-production pro wrestling in North America, you had one choice. One. Then Double or Nothing 2019 happened, and suddenly, the monopoly didn't just have a crack in it—it had a gaping hole.
Everything changed that night.
Tony Khan, the son of Jaguars owner Shad Khan, sat in the back with a headset on, probably sweating through his shirt. Beside him were The Young Bucks, Cody Rhodes, and Kenny Omega. They called themselves The Elite. They’d spent months teasing this thing on YouTube, selling out a self-funded show called All In a year prior, but this was different. This was the official birth of All Elite Wrestling. It wasn't just a "super indie" show anymore. This was a direct shot across the bow of WWE.
Honestly, nobody knew if it would actually work. You’ve seen wrestling promotions come and go. Remember WCPW? Remember the early days of TNA? It’s hard to stay afloat. But within the first ten minutes of the Buy-In pre-show, when the 21-man Casino Battle Royale started, you could tell the crowd was desperate for this to succeed. They weren't just fans; they were shareholders in a movement.
The Blood and Tears of the Rhodes Brothers
If you ask anyone what they remember most about Double or Nothing 2019, they aren't going to talk about work rates or "stars." They’re going to talk about blood. Specifically, the terrifying amount of it leaking out of Dustin Rhodes’ forehead.
Cody vs. Dustin was a masterclass. It’s arguably the most emotional match in the history of the company, and it happened on day one. Cody was the young visionary trying to "kill the past." Dustin was the veteran, known for decades as Goldust, trying to prove he wasn't a relic. It was gritty. It was uncomfortable to watch at times. Dustin’s face was a "crimson mask"—a wrestling cliché that felt very real that night.
When the match ended, and Cody didn't leave. He grabbed a mic. He told his brother, "I don't need a partner, I don't need a friend... I need my older brother." There wasn't a dry eye in the building. That moment proved AEW wasn't just about "flippy" wrestling or "work rate." It was about heart. It showed that these guys understood the "theatre" part of the sport better than anyone gave them credit for.
🔗 Read more: UNC Basketball Where to Watch: How to Never Miss a Tip-Off This Season
The Night the Paradigm Shifted
The main event featured Chris Jericho against Kenny Omega. This was a rematch from their legendary encounter in New Japan Pro-Wrestling, but the stakes were higher here. The winner would go on to compete for the inaugural AEW World Championship.
Jericho looked different. He was heavier, meaner, and leaning into his "Painmaker" persona. He was the bridge. Without Jericho’s name value, Double or Nothing 2019 might have just been a niche event for hardcore tape-traders. He brought the "casual" eyes. When he hit the Judas Effect—a spinning back elbow that most people hadn't seen him use as a finish yet—and pinned Omega, the message was clear: the legends were here to play, but they were here to work, too.
Then the lights went out.
The silence lasted maybe five seconds. When they came back on, Jon Moxley—formerly Dean Ambrose in WWE—was standing in the crowd. The roof didn't just pop; it disintegrated. Moxley had walked out of the biggest wrestling company in the world just weeks prior. Seeing him stand in an AEW ring, beating the hell out of Jericho and then F-5ing Omega off the poker chip stage prop, was the "holy crap" moment the industry needed. It was the "Paradigm Shift."
Britt Baker and the Foundation of the Women’s Division
We have to be honest about the women’s triple threat match involving Dr. Britt Baker D.M.D., Kylie Rae, and Nyla Rose. At the time, this was the weakest part of the roster's perception. People didn't know if AEW could build a women's division that rivaled what was happening elsewhere.
Brandie Rhodes came out and added Awesome Kong to the match, making it a Four-Way. It was chaotic. Britt Baker eventually won, and while the match had some clunky moments, it established her as the "face" of that division. It’s wild to look back now and see how far she’s come since that first night in Vegas. Nyla Rose also made history as the first openly transgender wrestler to compete on such a massive stage in the U.S., a detail that AEW handled with surprisingly little fanfare, treating her simply as the "beast" she is.
A Technical Nightmare or a New Standard?
The show wasn't perfect. Let's not rewrite history. There were some production glitches. The audio levels were wonky during a few segments. Some of the camera cuts were a bit jarring compared to the polished, almost sterile look of WWE’s "Kevin Dunn" style of directing.
But those flaws made it feel authentic.
The Young Bucks vs. The Lucha Bros for the AAA World Tag Team Titles was a car crash in the best way possible. It was fast. Maybe too fast for some old-school fans. But for the kids in the front row, it was the future. It was "spotfest" wrestling elevated to an art form. It gave us a glimpse of the tag team-heavy focus that would define AEW for its first three years.
📖 Related: Steph Curry Shoes Blue and Yellow: Why the Dub Nation Colors Still Rule the Court
Why 2019 Still Matters Five Years Later
If you go back and watch Double or Nothing 2019 today, it feels like a time capsule. You see wrestlers who are now top-tier stars—like MJF, who was in the pre-show battle royale—looking like babies. You see a company that was fueled entirely by spite and ambition.
It matters because it broke the cycle. Before May 2019, if a wrestler was unhappy in the big leagues, they basically had to go to Japan or toil away on the indies for peanuts. AEW gave them a third option: a national TV contract, a light schedule, and creative freedom.
The business side of things changed too. WarnerMedia (now Warner Bros. Discovery) saw the buzz. They saw the 11,000+ tickets sold in minutes. They saw the 100,000+ pay-per-view buys, which was unheard of for a brand-new entity. It’s the reason AEW Dynamite exists today. Without the success of this specific night, there is no Wednesday night war. There is no CM Punk comeback. There is no "forbidden door."
How to Revisit the Magic
If you’re looking to dive back into this event, don’t just watch the highlights. You have to see the whole build.
📖 Related: Las Vegas Raiders vs Los Angeles Chargers: Why the Rivalry is Getting Weird
- Watch "Road to Double or Nothing" on YouTube: This series was the blueprint for how AEW tells stories. It’s raw and focuses on the "why" behind the matches.
- Focus on the Dustin vs. Cody post-match: Even if you aren't a wrestling fan, the storytelling in that five-minute promo is some of the best live theatre you'll ever see.
- Check the buy rates: Look at the historical context. At the time, industry experts like Dave Meltzer were shocked by the numbers. It out-performed every non-WWE/WCW show in decades.
- Identify the "Firsts": Pay attention to the first time you see the AEW World Title belt (unveiled by Bret "The Hitman" Hart, which was a huge surprise).
The legacy of Double or Nothing 2019 isn't just about the wins and losses. It’s about the fact that it happened at all. It was the night the wrestling world grew up and realized that fans were ready for something different. It wasn't just a show; it was a proof of concept that ended up becoming a billion-dollar reality.