You've seen them. Those massive, glittering boxes that start popping up in Sephora and Space NK as early as September. Honestly, the advent calendar 2024 makeup craze feels different this time around. It isn't just about getting 24 tiny samples anymore. It’s about the math.
People are getting smarter. They’re looking at the "value" versus the "cost" with a much more cynical eye. And they should. Last year, several big-name brands got absolutely roasted on TikTok for filling their calendars with cheap stickers and drawstring bags instead of, you know, actual makeup. In 2024, the pressure was on for brands like Charlotte Tilbury, Cult Beauty, and Liberty London to actually deliver the goods.
The Reality of the Advent Calendar 2024 Makeup Hype
The truth is, most people buy these for the dopamine hit of a daily surprise. But if you're dropping $200 or $600 on a box, that's an expensive hit. Let’s look at what actually landed on shelves this season.
Take the Cult Beauty Advent Calendar 2024. It’s arguably the heavyweight champion. They stuffed over 40 products into that box. Forty. That’s not even one-per-day; that’s a haul. You’re looking at brands like Augustinus Bader and Patrick Ta. When you calculate the "price per ml," it usually beats buying the full-size versions individually, provided you actually use the stuff. If half the box sits in your "junk drawer" until 2027, you haven't saved a dime. You’ve just paid for expensive clutter.
Then there’s the Charlotte Tilbury Treasure Chest of Love. It’s iconic, sure. It looks beautiful on a vanity. But it only has 12 doors. For some, the 12-day format feels like a rip-off compared to the 24 or 25-day giants. However, fans argue it's "all killer, no filler." You get the Magic Cream. You get the Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray. It’s a curation, not a clearance sale.
Why Do Brands Do This?
It’s a customer acquisition strategy. Plain and simple.
A brand like Liberty London includes high-end niche fragrances and skincare in their advent calendar 2024 makeup and beauty lineup because they want you to fall in love with a $300 serum you otherwise never would have touched. It's a gateway drug. They lose money on the individual unit margin to win your loyalty for the next three years.
What You Probably Didn't Notice
One subtle shift in the 2024 market is the move toward "refillable" or "reusable" packaging. Dior and Chanel have faced criticism in the past for their sustainability (or lack thereof). This year, we're seeing more drawers and trunks that are designed to be kept as jewelry boxes. It’s a way to justify the premium price tag.
But be careful. Just because a box is heavy doesn't mean it’s full of gold. Always check the "full-sized" count. A good advent calendar 2024 makeup selection should have at least 5 to 10 full-sized items. If it’s all 5ml samples, you’re basically paying for the cardboard.
Sorting the Gems from the Junk
Let's get specific. If you're looking for value, the ASOS Face + Body Calendar usually sits at a much lower price point, making it accessible. It’s the "entry-level" drug of the beauty world.
On the flip side, the MAC Cosmetics calendar is for the loyalists. If you don't like MAC's specific formula or scent, you'll hate it. It’s very brand-specific.
- Cult Beauty: High value, diverse brands, heavy on skincare.
- Sephora Favorites: Great for trying "viral" products you see on Reels.
- LookFantastic: Solid middle-ground with a mix of hair, skin, and tools.
Honestly, the Benefit Cosmetics "The Gorgeous Grocer" theme for 2024 was a bit polarizing. Some loved the kitschy grocery store vibe; others felt it was a bit "young" for the price. It’s all subjective. That’s the problem with these lists—one person's "holy grail" is another person's "trash bin."
The "Sample Size" Trap
We need to talk about the "Value Worth" claims. When a brand says their advent calendar 2024 makeup box is "Worth Over $1,000," they are calculating that based on the retail price of every tiny sample if it were sold individually.
But you can't usually buy a 2ml vial of perfume for $15. They just assign it that value to inflate the total. It’s a bit of a shell game. To get the true value, only count the products you were actually going to buy this year anyway. If the total of those products exceeds the cost of the box, you win. If not, you're just subsidizing the brand's marketing budget.
How to Actually Score One (Without the Stress)
These things sell out. Fast.
The Space NK calendar is usually gone within weeks of the waitlist opening. If you’re reading this in November and haven't bought one yet, you’re likely looking at eBay markups or the "leftover" brands that didn't sell as well.
- Join Waitlists Early: This usually happens in August. Yes, August.
- Check the "Spoilers": Sites like British Beauty Blogger or Really Ree usually leak the full contents months in advance. Don't be surprised. Know what's in the box.
- Wait for the "After Christmas" Sale: If you don't care about the "advent" part, many of these drop to 50% off on December 26th. It's the best way to get a massive makeup haul for pennies.
The Sustainability Problem
We can't ignore the environmental impact. These boxes are huge. They use a lot of glue, glitter (which is often microplastic), and plastic molded trays. If you’re trying to be eco-conscious, look for the brands using 100% recyclable cardboard or those that offer "refill" kits for boxes you bought in previous years.
Lush is usually pretty good about this, focusing on naked products or reusable tins. Their advent calendar 2024 makeup and bath options are always a hit because they smell like a literal dream, even if the box takes up half your bathroom.
Making the Final Call
Is it worth it? Sorta.
✨ Don't miss: Weather Today in Brisbane Australia: Why the Humidity Is Actually Making Local Headlines
If you are a beauty junkie who loves trying new things, it’s the highlight of the year. If you have sensitive skin or a very specific "look," you’re going to end up with a lot of blue eyeliner and tingly face masks you'll never use.
Actionable Steps for Your 2024 Haul
- Audit your current stash: Do you actually need another mascara? Most calendars include one. If you have three unopened ones, skip the calendar.
- Calculate the "Usable Value": Look at the spoiler list. Cross out anything you won't use. Add up the prices of what's left. If that number is higher than the box price, buy it.
- Split it with a friend: This is the pro move. Buy a high-end box like Liberty or Cult Beauty, and split the contents. You get the 12 things you love; they get the 12 things they love. Everyone wins, and your wallet doesn't scream as loud.
- Check the expiry dates: Some "value" calendars use stock that is closer to its expiration date. Check the PAO (Period After Opening) symbols once you open them to make sure you're using the "active" ingredients while they're actually active.
The advent calendar 2024 makeup scene is more crowded than ever. Don't let the shiny packaging distract you from the actual ingredients and product sizes inside. Shop with your head, not just your festive spirit.