You’ve seen the meme. It pops up every few months on social media like clockwork. Someone posts a grainy image of a magazine cover and says, "Can you believe Time Magazine honored Hitler?"
It’s a massive "gotcha" moment for people who want to prove that the media is—and always has been—biased or out of touch. Honestly, it's one of those historical facts that sounds totally fake until you look it up. But here’s the thing: Adolf Hitler was indeed named the 1938 Man of the Year (the title used before it became the gender-neutral Person of the Year).
If you think this was a glowing endorsement or some kind of lifetime achievement award, you’ve got it all wrong. Basically, the story is a lot darker, and frankly, more interesting than a simple "award."
What Really Happened With Time Magazine Person of the Year Adolf Hitler
First, let's clear the air. Time Magazine doesn't pick their Person of the Year based on who is the "best" or "nicest." They’ve been saying this for decades. The criteria is simple: the person, group, or concept that had the biggest impact on the news—for better or for worse.
Impact is the keyword there.
By the end of 1938, Hitler had basically held the world’s heart in a cold, iron grip. He had just orchestrated the Munich Agreement, effectively carving up Czechoslovakia without firing a single shot. He’d already annexed Austria. The "Munich betrayal" had left the democratic world trembling, and whether people liked him or loathed him (and most loathed him), they couldn't stop talking about him.
He was the news.
👉 See also: Who's the Next Pope: Why Most Predictions Are Basically Guesswork
The Cover You Weren't Expecting
When you think of a Time cover, you usually imagine a dignified portrait. Maybe a glossy photo of a tech mogul or a smiling world leader. But for the January 2, 1939 issue—the one naming Time magazine person of the year Adolf Hitler—the editors did something completely different.
They didn't use a photograph.
Instead, they commissioned an illustration by a Baron named Rudolph Charles von Ripper. He was a German Catholic who had actually been imprisoned by the Nazis and later fled to the US. His artwork was brutal. It showed Hitler as a tiny, hunched-over figure sitting at a massive, hellish pipe organ. Above him, a "Catherine wheel" (a medieval torture device) spun with bodies hanging from it.
The caption read: "From the unholy organist, a hymn of hate."
Hardly the stuff of a fan club. The magazine wasn't celebrating him; they were sounding a massive, frantic alarm.
Breaking Down the 1938 Choice
Why then? Why not 1933 when he took power? Well, 1938 was the year the "miracle" of Nazi economic recovery met the reality of territorial expansion. To the rest of the world, Hitler had become a "greatest threatening force."
✨ Don't miss: Recent Obituaries in Charlottesville VA: What Most People Get Wrong
- The Munich Crisis: This was the tipping point. Hitler outmaneuvered British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain and French Premier Édouard Daladier.
- The Annexation of Austria: The "Anschluss" happened in March 1938, bringing millions more under Nazi rule.
- Kristallnacht: Just weeks before the issue was published, the "Night of Broken Glass" occurred, making the regime's violent antisemitism impossible to ignore on the world stage.
The editors at Time, led by founder Henry Luce, weren't trying to be edgy. They were trying to be accurate. They argued that you couldn't tell the story of 1938 without putting Hitler at the center of it. He had "torn the Treaty of Versailles to shreds" and "rearmed Germany to the teeth."
The "Good vs. Evil" Misconception
People often confuse "Person of the Year" with the Nobel Peace Prize. That’s a mistake. If it were a popularity contest, the list would look very different.
Think about it. Joseph Stalin made the list twice (1939 and 1942). The Ayatollah Khomeini was picked in 1979 after the Iranian Revolution. Even more recently, Vladimir Putin was the choice in 2007.
The magazine has spent the better part of a century trying to explain this to an angry public. They even released a formal statement years ago saying: "TIME’s Person of the Year is not and never has been an honor. It is not an endorsement. It is not a popularity contest."
Still, the backlash in 1939 was real. Many readers were disgusted. They didn't want to see that face on their coffee table, regardless of the "unholy organist" context. It’s a tension that exists even today whenever a controversial figure is chosen.
Why This History Still Matters Today
Understanding the Time magazine person of the year Adolf Hitler selection helps us understand how we consume news. We often want our media to only "elevate" the good. But history is messy. If a journalist ignores a rising dictator because he’s "bad," they aren't doing their job.
🔗 Read more: Trump New Gun Laws: What Most People Get Wrong
They’re supposed to show us the world as it is, not as we wish it were.
The 1938 issue was actually quite prescient. It predicted that 1939 would be "a year to be remembered" for even darker reasons. Eight months after the issue hit stands, Hitler invaded Poland and the world went to war.
Moving Past the Headlines
If you're looking into this, don't just look at the title. Read the actual text of the 1938 article. It’s chilling. It describes a "moody, brooding, unprepossessing" man who managed to trick the world's most powerful democracies.
It’s a lesson in how power works and how quickly things can fall apart.
To get the full picture of this era, you should look into the history of the Munich Agreement or read the original Time 1938 Man of the Year essay (it’s available in their digital archives). Seeing the actual language they used—calling him a "peddler of hate"—completely changes how you see that famous, or infamous, cover.
The next step is to look at the list of recipients since then. You’ll notice a pattern of "Newsmakers" rather than "Heroes." This distinction is the only way the 1938 choice makes any sense at all. It wasn't a prize; it was a warning.
One that, unfortunately, the world didn't heed in time.