Jim Belushi is a force of nature. Honestly, if you grew up in the early 2000s, you couldn't escape his face on ABC. He was the quintessential suburban dad, often seen clutching a beer or a blues harmonica, navigating a world that seemed designed to annoy him. According to Jim wasn't trying to reinvent the wheel. It wasn't The Sopranos or The West Wing. It was comfortable. It was loud. It was exactly what network television needed to survive the transition into the digital age.
The show premiered in 2001 and somehow, against all odds and critical drubbings, stayed on the air for eight seasons. Critics hated it. They really did. They called it derivative and regressive. Yet, the audience stayed. Why? Because the chemistry between Jim Belushi and Courtney Thorne-Smith felt like a real, albeit exaggerated, marriage. They fought about stupid things. They lied to each other about small stuff. They loved each other through the chaos of three (and eventually five) kids. It was the last gasp of the "traditional" sitcom before everything went single-camera and cynical.
👉 See also: Our Little Secret Rating: Why This 2024 Psychological Thriller Polarized Audiences
The Secret Sauce of According to Jim
Success in the sitcom world isn't about being the smartest person in the room. It's about being the most relatable. Jim Belushi played Jim Orenthal, a man-child who owned a construction design firm but mostly wanted to hang out in his garage with his blues band. It’s a trope we’ve seen a million times. However, the show added a layer of suburban reality that resonated with the Midwest. It wasn't a New York show. It wasn't a Los Angeles show. It was a Chicago show.
That Chicago identity was massive.
Jim wasn't just a dad; he was a Bears fan. He was a Cubs fan. He lived in the suburbs, probably somewhere like Glen Ellyn or Park Ridge, dealing with the cold and the yard work. The show captured that specific brand of "guy-ness" that was disappearing from the culture. He had a basement. He had a "man cave" before that term became a marketing cliché.
Larry and Cheryl: The Perfect Foils
You can't talk about the show without mentioning Larry Joe Campbell. As Andy, Jim’s brother-in-law and business partner, he was the literal and figurative punching bag. Their dynamic was pure vaudeville. They were a modern-day Laurel and Hardy. Andy was sensitive, Jim was blunt. Andy was knowledgeable, Jim was... Jim.
Then you had the sisters. Courtney Thorne-Smith’s Cheryl was the "straight man," the voice of reason that Jim constantly tried to circumvent. Kimberley Williams-Paisley played Dana, the sister who looked down on Jim’s lifestyle. This four-way dynamic fueled almost every plot. Jim would do something dishonest—like faking an injury to get out of a chore or hiding a secret purchase—and the women would inevitably find out. It was a formula. But formulas work for a reason.
Why the Critics Were Wrong
If you look at Metacritic or Rotten Tomatoes, the scores for According to Jim are dismal. It’s fascinating. Critics looked at the show and saw a relic of the 1950s. They saw a "stupid" husband and a "nagging" wife. But that’s a surface-level reading that ignores the actual craftsmanship of the multi-cam sitcom.
💡 You might also like: What Is the Order of the Madea Movies: The Ultimate Way to Watch Tyler Perry’s Chaos
Sitcoms are filmed in front of a live studio audience. It’s theater.
The timing required for a physical gag to land is immense. When Jim Belushi would do a double-take or a physical stunt, he was leaning into his Second City roots. People forget he’s a trained improviser. He knows how to work a room. The show’s longevity—200 episodes—wasn't a fluke of scheduling. It was a result of a cast that knew exactly how to play to the rafters.
- Ratings Stability: Even in its later years, the show was a "utility player" for ABC. When a new high-concept show failed, they put Jim back in the Tuesday night slot. It always delivered.
- International Appeal: The show is massive in syndication globally. From Germany to Brazil, the "husband vs. wife" tropes translate perfectly because they are universal human experiences.
The Harmonica and the Blues
Music was the heartbeat of the series. Jim Belushi’s real-life passion for the blues was baked into the character. His band on the show, the Sacred Hearts, was his actual band. This added an element of authenticity that most sitcoms lack. When they played, they actually played.
It gave the show a texture. It wasn't just a living room and a kitchen. It was a garage filled with smoke, cheap beer, and the wail of a harmonica. It represented the "third space" for men—the place where they could be themselves away from the pressures of parenting and professional life. For a lot of viewers, seeing Jim blow off steam with his buddies was the most honest part of the week.
The Evolution of the Sitcom Dad
We’ve seen the evolution from Father Knows Best to The Simpsons. Jim Orenthal sits somewhere in the middle. He wasn't a bumbling idiot like Homer Simpson, but he certainly didn't have the answers like Ward Cleaver. He was a guy trying to preserve his autonomy while being a good provider.
Sometimes he failed. He was often selfish.
💡 You might also like: Dita Von Teese Burlesque Show: What Most People Get Wrong About Modern Vaudeville
But the show never let him get away with it. The resolution of almost every episode involved Jim admitting he was wrong, usually after a stern talk from Cheryl or a realization that his selfishness hurt his kids. It was a moralistic show dressed up in slapstick clothing. That’s the secret to its "comfort food" status. You knew the world would be put back together by the end of the thirty minutes.
The Family Dynamic
The kids—Ruby, Gracie, and Kyle—actually grew up on screen. This is a rare thing in sitcoms that don't get cancelled after season two. We saw them go from toddlers to teenagers. Unlike many shows where the kids are just props for jokes, According to Jim eventually allowed the children to have their own agency, often teaming up with Jim to trick Cheryl or, more often, helping Cheryl bust Jim.
Production Secrets and Trivia
Behind the scenes, the show was a well-oiled machine. It was filmed at CBS Studio Center in Studio City, California. Despite the Chicago setting, it was purely a Hollywood production.
One thing people often miss is how many episodes Jim Belushi directed himself. He wasn't just the star; he was the shepherd of the show's tone. He knew what worked. He knew when a joke was too mean-spirited or too "sitcom-y." He fought to keep the show grounded in a specific type of blue-collar reality, even as the plots got more outrageous in later seasons.
- The "Lost" Seasons: Many fans don't realize the show was actually cancelled and then brought back. ABC didn't know what to do without it.
- The Guest Stars: From Dan Aykroyd (reuniting with his Blues Brother) to Bo Diddley, the show had incredible musical guests that most other sitcoms couldn't dream of booking.
The Legacy of the 2000s Sitcom
When we look back at the era of According to Jim, we’re looking at the end of an empire. This was the last decade where a family could sit down at 8:00 PM and watch a show together without needing a subscription service.
It represents a simpler time in media.
There was no social media discourse about every episode. There were no "think pieces" dissecting the gender politics of Jim’s latest lie. It was just a show. And honestly? That’s why people still watch it on streaming platforms today. It provides a break from the complexity of modern life. It’s predictable in a way that is deeply soothing.
Why You Should Rewatch It
If you haven't seen an episode in a decade, give it a shot. You might be surprised at how well the physical comedy holds up. Larry Joe Campbell is a master of the craft. His facial expressions alone are worth the price of admission.
You’ll see a version of the American dream that feels nostalgic now. A big house, a steady job, a loyal band of friends, and a family that actually likes each other. It’s aspirational in its ordinariness.
Actionable Steps for Fans and Newcomers
If you want to dive back into the world of Jim Orenthal, here is how to get the most out of the experience:
- Watch the "Guest Stars" Episodes first. Specifically, find the episodes featuring Dan Aykroyd. The chemistry between him and Belushi is electric and reminds you of the deep history of the Blues Brothers.
- Focus on the Physical Comedy. Stop looking for the "message" and just watch the timing. Pay attention to how the actors use the space of the set. It’s a masterclass in multi-cam movement.
- Check out Jim Belushi’s recent work. If you enjoy his persona, his reality show Growing Belushi offers a weirdly fascinating look at his life now, which is a far cry from the suburban dad he played for eight years.
- Look for the Chicago Easter Eggs. If you’re a sports fan, keep an eye on the background props. The show was meticulous about using real Chicago brands and sports memorabilia, which adds a layer of depth for locals.
The show isn't going to change your life. It isn't going to solve the world's problems. But According to Jim will make you laugh at the absurdity of marriage and the struggle of trying to stay a "cool guy" while your kids are drawing on the walls. Sometimes, that's more than enough.