Why a Kayak Gets Swallowed by a Whale More Often Than You’d Think

It looks like a scene ripped straight from a high-budget horror flick or a biblical fever dream. You’re paddling in the glassy waters of San Luis Obispo Bay, the sun is hitting the California coast just right, and suddenly, the ocean floor rises up to meet you. Except it isn’t the floor. It’s a mouth.

When a kayak gets swallowed by whale activity, it isn't actually a predatorial act. Whales don't want to eat you. They can't, anyway. Their throats are roughly the size of a grapefruit. But tell that to Julie McSorley and Liz Cottriel, who found themselves staring into the pleated, barnacle-crusted gullet of a Humpback back in 2020. They were just watching the birds. They were just sitting there. Then, everything went black.

The Physics of a Humpback Lunge

Humpbacks are what we call "gulp feeders." They don't chase down individual fish with surgical precision. Instead, they use a technique called lunge feeding. They dive deep, spot a massive ball of silver baitfish—usually anchovies or sardines—and rocket toward the surface with their mouths open at a 90-degree angle.

Imagine a massive living cargo net moving at high speed.

The ventral pleats on their chin expand, allowing them to take in thousands of gallons of water in a single go. If your kayak gets swallowed by whale lunges, it’s because you happen to be floating directly on top of the "bait ball" the whale is targeting. The whale isn't looking at the surface; it’s looking at the shimmer of fish from below. By the time it breaks the surface, it’s committed. It’s a freight train with no brakes.

Honestly, it’s a miracle it doesn’t happen more often.

That Famous Avila Beach Incident

Let's talk about Julie and Liz. Their story is the gold standard for this terrifying phenomenon. They were about 30 feet away from other kayakers off Avila Beach. They saw the bait balls. They saw the birds diving. Then, the water exploded.

A Humpback whale breached directly underneath their yellow kayak. Video footage from onlookers shows the kayak literally disappearing into the whale's mouth. For a few seconds, they were gone.

"I thought, 'I'm gonna die,'" Cottriel later told reporters. She wasn't being dramatic. You’re dealing with an animal that weighs 40 tons. If that jaw slams shut or the whale dives with you tucked inside its mouth, the pressure alone could be lethal. Luckily, the whale realized its mistake almost instantly. Humpbacks aren't fans of plastic and human sunblock. It spat them out—or rather, it surfaced and let them fall out—and they popped back up to the surface, shaken but physically fine.

💡 You might also like: Main Street Ellicott City Maryland: Why People Keep Coming Back After Everything

They lost their car keys, though. A small price to pay for the world's most intense "you won't believe what happened" story.

Why the "Swallow" is Actually Impossible

Technically, a kayak gets swallowed by whale is a bit of a misnomer. While the kayak enters the mouth, it can never enter the stomach.

1. The Throat Barrier: Most large whales (except the Sperm Whale) have narrow esophagi. A Humpback’s throat is tiny. It’s designed to pass krill and small fish. A human, let alone a 12-foot polyethylene vessel, isn't getting past the front door.
2. Baleen Filters: Humpbacks don't have teeth. They have baleen plates. These act like a giant comb. When the whale closes its mouth, it pushes the water out through the baleen, trapping the food inside. You’re basically stuck in a giant, fleshy room made of hair-like keratin.
3. The Reflex: Whales are incredibly sensitive. They have a massive "gag reflex" when something foreign enters their mouth. They want you out as much as you want to be out.

The 2026 Reality of Whale Watching

We are seeing more of these encounters lately. Why? It isn't because whales are getting aggressive. It’s actually a mix of conservation success and climate shifts.

The whale populations in the North Pacific have rebounded significantly since the whaling bans of the 20th century. At the same time, warming ocean temperatures are pushing baitfish closer to the shore. When the food moves to the shallows, the whales follow. And where do people like to kayak? The shallows.

👉 See also: Casa Loma Beach Hotel: What Most People Get Wrong About Laguna's Iconic Stay

It’s a literal collision course.

Experts like those at the Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute (MBARI) emphasize that the responsibility lies with the humans. In the United States, the Marine Mammal Protection Act basically says you need to stay at least 100 yards away. But whales don't read law books. They move fast. You might start 100 yards away, but if a bait ball drifts under your hull, you’re suddenly in the strike zone.

What to do if You’re Caught in the Middle

If you see the water "boiling" with small fish, you are in danger.

Don't wait. Don't grab your phone for a TikTok. Paddle. * Look for the Birds: If hundreds of gulls are diving in one spot, that’s where the whale is coming up.

• Move Perpendicular: Don't try to outrun a whale in a straight line. Move toward the shore or away from the center of the fish activity.
• Vibrate the Water: Some guides suggest tapping your paddle against the side of the kayak. Whales use sound to navigate. While they are focused on the fish, a sharp metallic or plastic "clack" might help them realize something solid is above them. This is debated, but it’s better than sitting silently.

The Psychological Aftermath

It’s not just about the physical danger. People who have had their kayak gets swallowed by whale encounters often report long-term trauma. It’s the sheer scale of it. Being "consumed" by the natural world is a primal fear.

Liz Cottriel mentioned that she couldn't look at the ocean the same way for a long time. It’s the realization that we are tiny. We are guests. And sometimes, the host doesn't see us standing on the rug before they go to shake it out.

Staying Safe While Paddling in Whale Territory

The best way to avoid being the next viral video is situational awareness.

Humpbacks are the most common "accidental swallowers" because of their feeding style. Blue whales are generally too deep, and Gray whales are bottom-feeders. But Humpbacks are the acrobats. They are unpredictable.

Check local sightings before you head out. If there have been "active" lunging sightings in a bay, maybe stick to the kelp forests where whales rarely venture. If you do find yourself in the middle of a feeding frenzy, stay low in your boat to lower your center of gravity. If the kayak flips, stay away from the vessel—the whale might bump it, and you don't want to be pinned between the boat and a multi-ton animal.

Essential Safety Protocols for Coastal Kayakers

• Wear a bright PFD: If you get dumped, you need to be visible to other boaters and rescuers immediately.
• Whistle is Mandatory: A pea-less whistle can be heard over the sound of splashing and wind.
• Distance is your Friend: 100 yards is the legal limit, but 200 yards is the smart limit.
• Observe the "Bubble Net": If you see a ring of bubbles rising to the surface, a Humpback is about to spiral up through the middle of it. Get out of the circle immediately.

Managing the risk is about respecting the power of the ocean. A whale encounter is a gift, provided it stays at a distance. When that distance closes, it’s no longer a nature documentary—it’s a survival situation. Stay alert, watch the baitfish, and remember that you're paddling in a giant's dining room.

Immediate Action Steps

1. Check Local Marine Reports: Before launching, visit sites like NOAA or local whale-watching logs to see where recent feeding activity has been concentrated.
2. Verify Your Gear: Ensure your life jacket is securely fastened and you have a signaling device (mirror or whistle) attached to your person, not just the boat.
3. Learn to Spot Bait Balls: Practice identifying the "shimmer" or "boiling" water effect caused by tightly packed schools of fish; if you see this, paddle away immediately.
4. Maintain Legal Distance: Familiarize yourself with the Marine Mammal Protection Act guidelines to ensure you aren't inadvertently harassing wildlife or putting yourself in a "strike zone."