It sounds like a paradox. How does stopping the government from spending money actually end up burning a hole in the taxpayer's pocket? Most people assume that if the lights go out in D.C., we’re at least saving a few bucks on the electric bill.
Nope.
In reality, a government shutdown is an incredibly expensive way to do absolutely nothing. It’s like paying for a hotel room, locking yourself out, and then being forced to pay for the cleaning crew anyway once you finally get back in. When Congress fails to pass the twelve appropriation bills that fund federal agencies, the entire system grinds to a halt. But "halt" doesn't mean "free."
Actually, it's quite the opposite.
The Massive Bill for Doing Nothing
Let’s look at the 35-day shutdown that spanned late 2018 and early 2019. It’s the longest one we’ve ever had. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) later crunched the numbers and found it lowered GDP by about $11 billion.
$3 billion of that? Permanently gone.
The main reason it gets so pricey is back pay. In 2019, the Government Employee Fair Treatment Act became law. This basically mandates that federal employees get paid for the time they were furloughed once the government reopens. So, the government pays billions in wages for hundreds of thousands of employees who were legally barred from doing their jobs.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
It’s inefficient. It’s frustrating. And honestly, it’s a logistical nightmare for every department involved.
Think about the IRS or the Small Business Administration. When they shut down, they aren't processing applications or catching fraud. They're just sitting on a growing mountain of paperwork. When they return, they have to work overtime—which costs even more—just to dig out of the hole they were forced to dig in the first place.
Why the Government Shutdown Happens in the First Place
Technically, it all goes back to the Antideficiency Act. This is an old law, dating back to 1884, that says the government cannot spend money that hasn’t been appropriated by Congress. It’s a "power of the purse" thing. If there’s no signed budget or "Continuing Resolution" (CR), the money stops.
Usually, the fight is over something totally unrelated to the actual budget.
Maybe it’s border security. Maybe it's healthcare. Or maybe it’s just pure political posturing because an election is coming up and someone wants to look "tough" on spending. But while the politicians argue on television, the real-world effects start trickling down to people who have nothing to do with the beltway drama.
Who Actually Stops Getting Paid?
There is a huge distinction between "essential" and "non-essential" employees.
👉 See also: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
If you’re an air traffic controller or a TSA agent, you’re essential. You keep working. But here’s the kicker: you don’t get your paycheck on time. You work for free with the promise that you’ll get paid later. Imagine trying to pay your mortgage or buy groceries when your employer just says, "Trust us, the check is coming... eventually."
- National Park rangers? Furloughed.
- FDA food inspectors? Many are sidelined, slowing down safety checks.
- Passport processors? Expect a massive delay.
- Mortgage lenders? If they need IRS verification, your home closing might just stall indefinitely.
The Invisible Toll on Private Business
It isn't just federal workers. Private contractors get hit the hardest because, unlike federal employees, they often don't get back pay.
If you run a cafeteria in a federal building or a cleaning service for a government agency, that income is just vaporized. The US Travel Association estimated that during previous shutdowns, the travel economy lost tens of millions of dollars every single day because people stopped visiting parks or cancelled business trips due to travel uncertainty.
Museums close. Local diners near federal hubs go quiet. The ripple effect is massive.
Small businesses waiting for SBA loans find themselves in limbo. If you were planning to open a new shop and needed that loan to sign your lease, a government shutdown can literally kill your business before it starts. The uncertainty is a silent killer for economic growth.
Investors hate it, too. While the stock market usually recovers quickly, the initial volatility can be enough to make people pull back on major capital investments.
✨ Don't miss: 39 Carl St and Kevin Lau: What Actually Happened at the Cole Valley Property
How We Get Out of the Loop
The cycle is predictable.
- A deadline approaches (usually September 30th).
- Both sides refuse to budge on a specific policy rider.
- A "CR" is passed at the last minute to kick the can down the road.
- Eventually, the can can't be kicked anymore.
- Shutdown.
To stop this, some experts like those at the Brookings Institution have suggested "automatic" continuing resolutions. This would mean if Congress can't agree on a budget, the previous year's funding just rolls over automatically. It takes away the "hostage-taking" element of the budget process. But, so far, neither party has shown much interest in giving up that particular piece of leverage.
Survival Steps for the Next One
If you are a federal employee, a contractor, or someone whose business relies on government services, you can't wait for Congress to get its act together. You have to be proactive.
Audit your liquid savings immediately. Most financial advisors suggest a three-month emergency fund, but for federal workers, having at least one month of "interruption insurance" in a high-yield savings account is a necessity.
Talk to your lenders early. During the last major shutdown, many banks and credit unions (like Navy Federal or USAA) offered 0% interest loans to affected workers. They know the money is coming eventually, so they are often willing to work with you—but only if you call them before you miss a payment.
Watch the "CR" expiration dates. Don't just listen to the headlines. Look for the specific date the current funding expires. If you have a passport that needs renewing or a government permit you need for work, get those applications in at least 60 days before a potential shutdown date.
The chaos is avoidable, but since the political climate remains volatile, the "halt" is always a looming possibility. Stay informed on the specific sub-committees handling the twelve appropriation bills. That's where the real work—or lack thereof—is actually happening.
Keep an eye on the "Big Four" leaders in the House and Senate. When they stop talking to each other, that’s your cue to start moving your savings into a more accessible spot.