Staring at that second pink line is a trip. Your heart thumps. Maybe you're thrilled, maybe you're absolutely terrified, but either way, you trust the plastic stick in your hand. First Response is basically the gold standard of at-home testing, right? It's the one doctors usually mention because it can pick up the pregnancy hormone, hCG, at incredibly low levels. But here is the kicker: a false positive first response pregnancy test is rare, but it isn't impossible.
It happens.
Most people think a positive is a positive, end of story. Science is usually more annoying than that. While these tests are 99% accurate from the day of your expected period, that 1% margin of error is where things get messy. We aren't just talking about "user error" either, though that’s a big part of it. We're talking about chemical nuances, medication interference, and the frustrating reality of how our bodies handle early loss.
The Evaporation Line Trap
Let’s get the most common culprit out of the way. If you’ve spent any time on "TTC" (Trying To Conceive) forums, you’ve heard of the dreaded "evap line."
First Response Manual tests use a pink dye. This is generally better than blue dye tests, which are notorious for leaving faint ghost lines. However, if you leave a First Response sitting on the counter for twenty minutes and then go back to look at it, you might see a faint shadow. That isn't a pregnancy. That’s just the urine drying and leaving a physical indentation or a slight color change where the reactive strip is located.
It looks like a false positive first response pregnancy test, but it’s actually just a result read outside the valid time window. Most instructions tell you to read the result at three minutes and ignore it after ten. Stick to that. If you have to squint, hold it under a flashlight, or take the casing apart to see the line, it’s probably not a true positive.
Chemical Pregnancies: The Truth About Early Detection
First Response is famous for its "Early Result" (ER) marketing. It can detect hCG levels as low as 6.3 mIU/mL. For context, most other brands wait until you hit 20 or 25.
Because it’s so sensitive, it picks up "chemical pregnancies" that other tests would miss. A chemical pregnancy is a very early miscarriage that happens shortly after implantation. In the past, women just thought their period was a day or two late. Now, because we can test five days before a missed period, we see the "positive" and then "lose" it a few days later when the period arrives.
👉 See also: Vitamin E Skin Oil: Why Most People Are Using It Completely Wrong
Is it a false positive? Technically, no. The hormone was there. But for the person holding the test, it feels like a false positive first response pregnancy test because it resulted in no viable pregnancy. It's a cruel side effect of high-sensitivity technology.
When Your Meds Mess with the Results
Your medicine cabinet might be the culprit. It’s not common, but specific drugs can trick the test.
If you are undergoing fertility treatments, you might be taking an "hCG trigger shot" (like Ovidrel or Pregnyl). This is literally the pregnancy hormone injected into your body to trigger ovulation. If you test too soon after the shot—usually within 10 to 14 days—the test will pick up the medication, not a baby.
Other medications that can occasionally cause issues:
- Certain anti-seizure meds.
- Some diuretics.
- Promethazine (used for allergies or nausea).
- Certain anti-anxiety medications like Valium.
Antibiotics or birth control pills won't cause a false positive. That’s a total myth.
Rare Medical Conditions and hCG
Sometimes the call is coming from inside the house. There are rare instances where your body produces hCG even when you aren't pregnant.
Certain types of ovarian cysts or extremely rare germ cell tumors can secrete enough hormone to trigger a false positive first response pregnancy test. Also, as women approach perimenopause, their pituitary gland can sometimes release tiny amounts of hCG. It’s usually not enough to trigger a standard test, but remember—First Response is incredibly sensitive. If your baseline hCG rises slightly due to hormonal shifts in your late 40s, you might see a faint line that leads nowhere.
Then there’s the "hook effect." This actually causes a false negative, not a positive, but it’s worth mentioning because it proves how wonky these tests can be. If your hCG levels are astronomically high (like with twins or a molar pregnancy), the test can get "overwhelmed" and show a negative result.
The "Indent" Issue
Recently, there has been a lot of chatter in the pregnancy community about "indents" on First Response Early Result (FRER) tests.
💡 You might also like: Oral Sex: Why Most People Are Getting it Wrong (and How to Fix it)
An indent is a manufacturing flaw where the "well" that holds the reactive dye is visible before you even use the test. Once the liquid passes over it, the greyish shadow of that indent becomes more pronounced. A true positive on a First Response should always have a pink hue. If the line is white, grey, or colorless, it’s an indent line, not a false positive first response pregnancy test.
Honestly, it’s frustrating. When you’re paying $15 for a box of two tests, you expect clarity. But mass manufacturing isn't perfect.
How to Verify Your Results
If you see a line and you aren't sure, don't panic.
First, wait 48 hours. This is the golden rule. hCG typically doubles every 48 hours in early pregnancy. If the line was a fluke, it will disappear or stay exactly the same. If you’re actually pregnant, that line will get noticeably darker.
Second, try a different brand. If you’re getting a faint line on a First Response, try a digital test. Digital tests have a higher "threshold," meaning they need more hCG to say "Pregnant." If the digital says "No," and the First Response line is barely visible, you might just be very early, or you might be looking at an evap line.
Actionable Steps for a Clear Result
If you find yourself staring at a confusing false positive first response pregnancy test, follow these steps to get a definitive answer:
- Test only with First Morning Urine: Your pee is most concentrated when you first wake up. Diluted urine from drinking too much water during the day can make a real positive look like a faint "maybe."
- Check the expiration date: Expired tests have degraded antibodies. The chemical reaction won't work correctly, which can lead to false results or "running" dye.
- Time it with a stopwatch: Don't eyeball it. Set a timer for 3 minutes. Read it the second the timer goes off.
- Look for the pink: If there is no pink pigment in the second line, it is not a positive.
- Request a quantitative blood test: If you’re getting conflicting results at home, ask your doctor for a "beta" blood test. This measures the exact amount of hCG in your blood, which is the only way to rule out a false positive or confirm a chemical pregnancy.
The technology behind a false positive first response pregnancy test is impressive, but it isn't magic. It’s a chemical reaction prone to the same hiccups as any other lab-in-a-box. If the results don't match what your body is telling you, trust your gut and get a blood draw. It’s the only way to stop the "line jumping" and get some actual peace of mind.