It started with a book that wasn’t even supposed to be a book. Back in 2008, Deborah Harkness was just a historian browsing a bookstore when she noticed the sheer volume of paranormal romance on the shelves. She wondered: If there really were vampires and witches, what would they do for a living? They probably wouldn't all be high schoolers or leather-clad hunters. They’d be academics. They'd be scientists. They’d be the people sitting right next to you in a library. That tiny "what if" sparked A Discovery of Witches, a novel that basically rewired how we think about urban fantasy.
Honestly, it's the realism that gets people.
Harkness didn't just write a story about magic; she wrote a story about history through the lens of a woman who actually understands how archives work. Diana Bishop isn't some "chosen one" trope who masters her powers in a weekend. She’s a tenured historian at Yale who happens to be a weaver, a rare kind of witch, and she spends a good chunk of the first book just trying to ignore her magic so she can finish her research. When she pulls that bewitched manuscript—Ashmole 782—from the depths of the Bodleian Library, it isn't just a plot device. It’s a catalyst for a massive, multi-century conspiracy that pulls in Matthew Clairmont, a vampire who is also a high-level geneticist.
The Academic Rigor of Deborah Harkness
Most authors do "research." Deborah Harkness lives it. Before she was a New York Times bestselling author, she was—and still is—a respected historian of science. We’re talking about a woman with a Ph.D. from UC Davis who has spent decades studying the history of alchemy and the Scientific Revolution. When you read about the All Souls universe, you aren't just getting "vibes." You're getting the fruit of her work on figures like John Dee and the actual Ashmolean collections.
This expertise is why the world-building feels so dense. It’s crunchy. You can almost smell the old parchment and the tea. In A Discovery of Witches, the magic isn't some sparkly, undefined energy. It's tied to DNA. It's tied to evolution. Matthew’s lab at Oxford isn't there for set dressing; it’s where he’s trying to figure out why supernatural creatures are dying out. He’s looking at the biological reality of being a vampire, which is a far cry from the Victorian gothic tropes we're used to. It turns out that when a real scholar writes fantasy, the stakes feel a lot more permanent.
👉 See also: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
Why Diana and Matthew Broke the Mold
Let’s be real: the "forbidden love" thing is a bit of a cliché. But Harkness grounded the relationship between Diana Bishop and Matthew de Clermont in shared intellectual curiosity. Sure, there's the biological "craving" and the protective instincts, but they actually talk to each other. They argue about history. They debate the merits of wine.
The relationship is also built on a foundation of massive power imbalances that the characters actually have to navigate. Matthew is over 1,500 years old. He’s seen empires fall. He’s been a killer, a spy, and a scientist. Diana is a modern American woman who values her independence above almost everything else. Watching them try to reconcile a 6th-century worldview with 21st-century autonomy is honestly one of the most compelling parts of the trilogy. It’s messy. It's sort of frustrating at times. But it feels human, even if one of them is technically undead.
The Congregation and the Covenant
The political backdrop of the series is where the stakes get truly high. You have the Congregation, a sort of shadow government made up of three witches, three vampires, and three daemons. Their whole job is to keep the species separate. No inter-species dating. No mixing. It’s an old-world law designed to keep them safe from humans, but by the time Diana finds Ashmole 782, the Covenant is suffocating them.
Daemons in this universe are particularly interesting. They aren't monsters with horns. They’re just people with extreme creativity and a tendency toward mental instability. They are the artists, the musicians, and the geniuses. By keeping them isolated, the Congregation is essentially killing the very thing that makes their world vibrant.
✨ Don't miss: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
The Jump to the Small Screen
When the TV adaptation hit AMC and Sky One, fans were understandably nervous. How do you condense a 600-page book filled with internal monologues about wine and alchemy into eight episodes? But with Teresa Palmer as Diana and Matthew Goode as the titular vampire, the show managed to capture the atmosphere perfectly.
What the show did exceptionally well was visual storytelling. The production design for Sept-Tours, the de Clermont family ancestral home in France, was stunning. They managed to make the magic feel grounded—not like a superhero movie, but like a natural extension of the characters' bodies. The casting of Matthew Goode was a masterstroke; he has that specific blend of "I might kill you" and "I want to read you poetry" that the book version of Matthew de Clermont requires.
The Legacy of the All Souls Trilogy
It didn't end with the third book, The Book of Life. Harkness expanded the universe with Time’s Convert, focusing on Marcus MacNeil’s backstory during the American Revolution. It showed that this world has legs. It’s not just about one couple; it’s about a global history of "the other."
People often ask why this series stuck when so many other "vampire books" faded into obscurity after the 2010s craze. It’s because it respects the reader’s intelligence. It assumes you want to know about the history of the Crusades, the intricacies of genetics, and the politics of Elizabethan England. It’s "grown-up" fantasy that doesn't feel the need to be grimdark or edgy just for the sake of it. It’s cozy, but it’s sharp.
🔗 Read more: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
Common Misconceptions About the Series
One thing people get wrong is thinking it's just another Twilight for adults. It’s really not. While both involve a vampire/human (or witch) romance, A Discovery of Witches is much more interested in the "how" and "why" of the world. It’s a mystery first, a historical drama second, and a romance third.
Another misconception? That you need a degree in history to enjoy it. You don't. Harkness is a teacher at heart. She explains the complex stuff through Diana’s eyes, so you learn as she learns. Whether it's the significance of a specific alchemical drawing or the way a 16th-century household was run, it’s all woven into the narrative so it never feels like a dry lecture.
How to Dive Deeper Into the World
If you're just starting, obviously start with the first book. But don't stop there. The "Real-Time Reading" community is huge—fans who read the books on the specific dates mentioned in the text (the story starts on September 18th). It adds a layer of immersion that’s pretty unique to this fandom.
Also, check out the All Souls Real-Time podcast or the various fan wikis that track the historical figures Matthew has "met" over the centuries. It turns out he knew everyone from Charles Darwin to various royals, and the fun is in seeing how Harkness weaves him into real historical events without breaking the timeline.
Practical Next Steps for Fans
If you've finished the show and the books and you're craving more, here’s how to keep the vibe alive:
- Visit the Bodleian: If you're ever in Oxford, you can actually tour the library where Diana first found the manuscript. You can't enter Duke Humfrey’s Library unless you’re a reader, but the exterior and the public areas are exactly as described.
- Explore the History of Science: Look up the real Elias Ashmole. He was a real person, and his collection formed the basis of the Ashmolean Museum. His interest in alchemy and the occult was genuine.
- Check out "The World of All Souls": This is a companion guide Harkness wrote that goes into the "behind-the-scenes" lore, including recipes, character biographies, and detailed maps.
- Read the latest release: As of 2024, The Black Bird Oracle has continued Diana’s story, diving deeper into her family’s dark magic roots. It’s a bit darker than the original trilogy and well worth the time.
The world Deborah Harkness created is massive. It’s a reminder that history isn't just a list of dates; it’s a collection of stories, some of which might just have a little bit of magic hidden in the margins. Whether you're in it for the romance, the history, or the genetic mysteries, there’s always something new to find in the archives.