You’ve seen the charcuterie boards. They are everywhere. Glossy photos of brie, aged cheddar, and gouda paired with grapes and honey. But for many, that picture-perfect moment leads to a predictable, painful outcome. When you see a black person eating cheese, there’s a statistically high chance their digestive system is currently screaming for help. It’s not just about "having a sensitive stomach." It is genetics.
Biology doesn't care about your cravings. It’s a harsh reality that hits about 75% of African Americans. That is a massive number. Think about it. Three out of every four people in the community lack the enzyme needed to break down lactose. This isn't a "disease." Honestly, it’s actually the biological norm for most of the human population outside of Northern Europe. We’ve just spent decades being told that "Milk does a body good," without anyone mentioning that for a huge portion of the world, it actually does the opposite.
The Lactose Persistence Myth
Most people think being lactose intolerant is a flaw. It’s not. Evolutionarily speaking, humans were meant to stop drinking milk after weaning. Around 10,000 years ago, a mutation occurred in certain European populations. This mutation, called lactose persistence, allowed adults to keep producing lactase. If you don't have that mutation, a black person eating cheese is essentially introducing a foreign invader into their gut.
The result? Bloating. Intense cramping. Let’s be real—it’s a dash to the bathroom. This happens because the undigested lactose sits in the colon and ferments. Bacteria have a field day with it. They produce gas and draw water into the intestines. It’s a mess.
Dr. Milton Mills, a prominent physician and advocate for plant-based nutrition, has spoken extensively about how the USDA’s dietary guidelines often ignore this racial disparity. He argues that pushing dairy on a population that is largely intolerant is a form of institutionalized dietary racism. It’s a heavy take, but the math checks out. Why are we told to eat three servings of dairy a day when it makes the majority of us sick?
🔗 Read more: Baldwin Building Rochester Minnesota: What Most People Get Wrong
Not All Cheese Is Created Equal
If you’re a black person eating cheese, you don't necessarily have to give up the habit entirely. You just have to be smarter than the marketing.
The "fresher" the cheese, the higher the lactose. Ricotta, mozzarella, and cottage cheese are the villains here. They are packed with the sugars that cause the most grief. If you see a liquid-heavy cheese, run. On the flip side, the aging process is your best friend. As cheese ages, bacteria consume the lactose and turn it into lactic acid.
Take Parmigiano-Reggiano. It’s aged for 12 to 36 months. By the time it hits your pasta, the lactose content is practically zero. The same goes for high-quality, extra-sharp cheddar. If it’s crumbly and aged for over a year, you’re likely safe. Swiss and Gruyère are also surprisingly low in lactose. It’s kinda wild how a fancy, expensive cheese is actually "healthier" for a sensitive gut than a cheap slice of American "cheese product."
Then there’s the goat and sheep factor. Many people find that Manchego (sheep) or Chèvre (goat) is much easier to digest. The protein structure is different. It’s not a magic bullet, but for many, it’s the difference between a nice dinner and a ruined evening.
💡 You might also like: How to Use Kegel Balls: What Most People Get Wrong About Pelvic Floor Training
The Hidden Vitamin D Connection
There is a cruel irony here. Many Black people avoid dairy because it makes them sick. However, dairy is one of the primary vehicles for Vitamin D fortification in the United States.
Because darker skin produces Vitamin D more slowly from sunlight—especially in northern climates—deficiency is rampant. A study published in the Journal of Nutrition found that nearly 76% of African Americans are Vitamin D deficient. When a black person eating cheese stops doing so to save their stomach, they might be losing their primary source of a crucial nutrient.
This creates a health gap. Low Vitamin D is linked to hypertension, diabetes, and certain cancers. You can't just "tough it out" with the cheese, but you can't ignore the nutrients either.
Ways to Bridge the Gap
- Fortified Plant Milks: Almond, soy, and oat milks are almost always supplemented with the same levels of Vitamin D and Calcium as cow’s milk.
- Fatty Fish: Salmon and mackerel are powerhouse sources.
- The Sun: Ten to twenty minutes of direct midday sun is often enough, though this varies wildly by location and season.
- Supplements: Honestly, most doctors now recommend Vitamin D3 supplements for Black adults living in the US or UK.
The Cultural Weight of the Mac and Cheese
Let’s talk about the soul food of it all. Macaroni and cheese is more than a side dish in Black culture. It’s a staple. It’s a centerpiece. It’s the "auntie’s famous recipe" that everyone waits for at the cookout.
📖 Related: Fruits that are good to lose weight: What you’re actually missing
When a black person eating cheese is doing so in a cultural context, they are often navigating a minefield. You don't want to be the person at the Thanksgiving table saying, "Actually, my genetics don't support this dairy-heavy casserole." So, people eat it. They suffer in silence. Or they've just grown so used to being bloated that they think it’s a normal part of eating.
It doesn't have to be that way. The "Vegan Soul Food" movement is massive right now. Chefs like Bryant Terry are reimagining these classics using cashew creams and nutritional yeast. It sounds "crunchy" or "hippie," but the flavor profiles are remarkably close. Nutritional yeast provides that "umami" punch that you usually get from a sharp cheddar.
Actionable Steps for the Dairy-Loving Soul
If you are determined to keep cheese in your life, you need a strategy. Don't just dive into a fondue pot.
- The "Hard Only" Rule. Stick to cheeses aged over 12 months. If the label says "0g sugar," it’s a good sign, as lactose is a sugar.
- Lactase Supplements. Take a pill like Lactaid with your first bite. Don't wait until you've finished the meal. It’s an enzyme, not a cure; it needs to be mixed with the food in your stomach to work.
- Small Increments. Tolerance can sometimes be built up, or at least tested, in tiny amounts. A sprinkle of Parmesan is different from a grilled cheese sandwich.
- Fermented Options. Real Greek yogurt or kefir contains live cultures that actually help digest the lactose for you. It’s like a built-in cleanup crew.
The conversation around a black person eating cheese is really a conversation about biological literacy. It’s about knowing how your specific body works and refusing to follow a "standard" diet that wasn't designed for you. You can enjoy the flavors you love without the physical toll. It just takes a little bit of label reading and a willingness to prioritize your gut over the hype.
Check the labels on your favorite snacks. If "whey" or "milk solids" are at the top of the list, that's likely why you're feeling sluggish. Switch to a block of aged Pecorino or a high-quality cashew-based spread. Your energy levels—and your digestive system—will notice the difference within 48 hours. Focus on fermented and aged products to maintain the culinary traditions you love without the inflammatory consequences.