Tom Hansen is not the hero. Honestly, if you haven’t watched (500) Days of Summer in a decade, you might remember it as this quirky, tragic indie romance where a "manic pixie dream girl" breaks a nice guy’s heart. You're wrong. We were all kinda wrong back in 2009.
Director Marc Webb and writers Scott Neustadter and Michael H. Weber didn't set out to make a romantic comedy. They made a movie about the dangers of projection. It’s a story about a guy who doesn't listen. Joseph Gordon-Levitt has even said as much in interviews over the years, basically telling fans that Tom is actually pretty selfish. He’s obsessed with an idea, not a person.
The Summer Finn Revisionist History
Summer Finn, played by Zooey Deschanel, is introduced through Tom’s eyes. That’s the trick. Since the narrator tells us right away that "this is not a love story," we should have been on guard. But we weren't. We fell for the The Smiths lyrics and the shared affinity for Magritte paintings.
People love to hate Summer. They call her cold. They say she led him on. But if you actually watch the scenes—really watch them—she is incredibly clear from day one. She tells him in the office, "I’m not looking for anything serious." She tells him in the shower. She tells him at the record store.
Tom hears her, but he doesn't believe her. He thinks he’s the protagonist in a movie where his love is so powerful it will change her mind. That’s not romance; it’s narcissism.
💡 You might also like: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
Why the Nonlinear Structure Matters
The movie jumps around. Day 488, then Day 1, then Day 250. This isn't just a gimmick to look cool like a Tarantino flick. It mimics how memory actually works when you’re going through a breakup. You don't remember a relationship chronologically. You remember the high of a first kiss followed immediately by the soul-crushing weight of seeing them with someone else.
By contrasting the "Expectations vs. Reality" sequence—which remains one of the most technically brilliant scenes in modern cinema—Webb shows us the gap between what Tom wants to happen and what is actually happening. The screen splits. On the left, Tom enters a party and is greeted warmly by Summer. On the right, he’s just another guest.
The "Manic Pixie Dream Girl" Trap
Nathan Rabin coined the term "Manic Pixie Dream Girl" to describe characters like Claire in Elizabethtown. For years, Summer Finn was the poster child for this trope. It’s an easy label. She’s quirky, she likes indie music, she has a vintage style.
But the movie is actually a critique of that trope.
📖 Related: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
Summer has a life. She has a history. She has a terrifying dream about a giant cockroach that she shares with Tom, and he... just stares at her. He doesn't engage with her inner world. He just likes how she makes him feel. When they break up, Tom is devastated because his "dream" is over, not necessarily because he lost a partner he truly understood.
Look at the scene in the gallery. Summer is moved to tears by The Graduate. Tom thinks it’s just a movie. He misses the emotional depth of the woman sitting right next to him because he's too busy being "in love."
The Reality of the Ending
Then there’s Autumn.
People think the ending is a "happily ever after" reset. It’s not. It’s actually a bit of a warning. Tom meets a new girl at a job interview, and her name is Autumn. The counter resets to Day 1.
👉 See also: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
Is he going to repeat the same mistakes? The film leaves that hanging. If Tom hasn't learned that a woman isn't a supporting character in his life story, he’s just going to put Autumn through the same ringer he put Summer through. It’s a cycle.
Lessons From the 500 Days of Summer Discourse
We have to talk about the "nice guy" complex. Tom Hansen is the blueprint for the modern "nice guy" who feels entitled to a woman's affection because they share the same hobbies.
- Hobbies aren't a personality. Just because you both like The Smiths doesn't mean you're soulmates.
- Consent to a relationship matters. Summer was honest about her boundaries. Tom’s refusal to respect those boundaries is the primary conflict of the film.
- The soundtrack is a character. From "You Make My Dreams" to "Hero," the music reflects Tom's internal state, not reality.
If you want to truly understand 500 Days of Summer, you have to stop identifying with Tom’s pain and start looking at his actions. He’s a guy who works in greeting cards—a business built on selling manufactured emotions. He tries to apply that same logic to a real human being, and it fails.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Rewatch
Don't just put the movie on in the background. If you want to see the "real" movie, try these steps:
- Ignore the Narrator: The narrator is biased toward Tom. Watch Summer’s facial expressions during their "good" moments. You’ll see the hesitation Tom chooses to ignore.
- Focus on the Background: Look at how the color blue follows Summer. It’s the color of Tom’s obsession. When she leaves his life, the blue fades out of the frame.
- Listen to the Sidebar Interviews: The random people talking about love throughout the film provide the objective reality that Tom ignores.
- Read the Script: Scott Neustadter wrote this after a real breakup. He has admitted it was a way to process his own "Tom-like" behavior.
500 Days of Summer isn't a guide on how to find love. It’s a cautionary tale about how to lose yourself in a fantasy. If you’re still blaming Summer for the ending, it might be time to look in the mirror and ask if you're playing the lead role in a movie that nobody else is filming.
Stop looking for a "Summer" and start looking for a partner. Someone who is a whole person, not just a collection of cool interests and a pretty face. That's the only way to make sure Day 1 of Autumn actually leads somewhere different.