If you grew up a football fan in the early nineties, the Buffalo Bills were basically the final boss of the AFC that could never quite win the game's actual final boss battle. It’s a statistical anomaly that feels fake when you say it out loud today. Four straight years. Four straight Super Bowls. Four straight losses. When ESPN released the 30 for 30 Four Falls of Buffalo, they didn't just recap a bunch of old box scores; they ripped the scab off a wound that an entire city had been nursing for twenty-five years. Honestly, most sports documentaries are about the glory of winning, but this one? It’s a masterclass in the dignity of losing.
You’ve got to understand the climate of 1990 to 1993. The Bills weren't just "good." They were a high-octane, "K-Gun" no-huddle machine led by Jim Kelly, Thurman Thomas, and Andre Reed. They were terrifying. But history only remembers the rings, or in Buffalo's case, the lack thereof. People call them the biggest "chokers" in sports history. However, the film argues—quite successfully—that getting there four times in a row is actually a greater feat of endurance than winning a single fluke title and disappearing into late-night trivia.
The Wide Right Ghost that Still Haunts Orchard Park
It all started with a kick. Scott Norwood. 47 yards. Super Bowl XXV. If that ball sails two feet to the left, the entire narrative of the Buffalo Bills changes forever. They aren't the team that lost four; they're the team that won the first one and maybe relaxed.
The documentary does something incredible here by focusing on Norwood’s humanity. Usually, the guy who misses the "big one" gets the Bill Buckner treatment—exile and shame. But Buffalo is a weird, fiercely loyal place. There’s this footage in the film from a rally at Niagara Square right after the team returned from that first loss. You expect boos. You expect anger. Instead, thousands of people started chanting "Scotty! Scotty!" It’s enough to make a grown man cry, even if you aren't a Bills fan. It showed that the city didn't see him as a failure, but as one of their own who just had a bad day at the office.
💡 You might also like: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
But then came the Washington Redskins. Then the Dallas Cowboys. Twice.
By the time the fourth loss happened, the Bills had become a national punchline. Late-night hosts were making jokes. People said "BILLS" stood for "Boy I Love Losing Super Bowls." It was cruel. The 30 for 30 Four Falls of Buffalo captures that mounting pressure—the way the locker room started to feel like a pressure cooker. You see Jim Kelly’s bravado slowly turn into a sort of grim determination. You see Thurman Thomas's frustration when he couldn't find his helmet in Super Bowl XXVI. These aren't just stats; they're tiny, jagged pieces of a larger heartbreak.
Why Nobody Talked About the Comeback
Everyone remembers the Super Bowl losses, but the documentary spends a good chunk of time on "The Comeback." January 3, 1993. Wild Card round against the Oilers. Jim Kelly is out with a knee injury. Frank Reich is under center. They’re down 35-3 in the third quarter.
📖 Related: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
The stadium was half-empty because people actually left. They gave up! And then, the impossible happened. 38-35. It remains one of the most insane things to ever happen on a football field. This is the nuance that the 30 for 30 Four Falls of Buffalo gets right. It reminds us that this team had the heart of a lion. You don't come back from 32 points down if you’re a "loser." You don't win four straight AFC Championships if you’re "soft." They were the best team in the world for 16 weeks a year, they just couldn't close the deal on week 17.
The Dallas Buzzsaw and the End of an Era
The film's treatment of the Cowboys era is almost painful to watch. Dallas was just better. They were younger, faster, and had that obnoxious 90s swagger. Watching the Bills try to climb that mountain for the fourth time in Super Bowl XXVIII felt less like a football game and more like a tragedy where you already knew the ending.
Don Beebe’s hustle play—chasing down Leon Lett to strip the ball when the game was already lost—is framed perfectly here. It’s the ultimate metaphor for that era of Buffalo football. They were getting blown out, they were humiliated, but they never stopped running. That play didn't change the score, but it saved their dignity.
👉 See also: Scores of the NBA games tonight: Why the London Game changed everything
The Emotional Payoff Most Fans Missed
Director Ken Rodgers made a specific choice to center the narrative around the 2014 fan rally, where the players returned to Buffalo decades later. Seeing a 50-something Jim Kelly, who had survived cancer and the loss of his son, standing next to Thurman Thomas and Bruce Smith in front of a screaming Buffalo crowd? That’s the real "win."
The documentary argues that Buffalo's identity is forged in that struggle. If they had won one and faded away, they might just be another team. But by losing four, they became legendary in a way that’s almost more durable than a championship. They are the patron saints of "showing up anyway."
What we can learn from the 90s Bills
If you’re looking for a silver lining, it’s in the resilience. Most teams would have imploded after the second loss. The locker room would have turned on each other. Marv Levy, the Harvard-educated coach with the poetic soul, kept them together. He didn't use "rah-rah" speeches; he used history and literature. He treated them like men, not just athletes.
- Resilience is a Choice: They chose to come back every year knowing the risk of public humiliation.
- Community Matters: The bond between the city of Buffalo and this team is deeper because they suffered together.
- Context is King: A loss in the Super Bowl still means you were the second-best team on the planet.
Actionable Takeaways for Sports Historians and Fans
If you're going to dive back into the 30 for 30 Four Falls of Buffalo, don't just watch it as a highlight reel. Watch it as a character study.
- Watch the body language of the players in the Super Bowl XXVIII locker room footage. You can see the exact moment the weight of history becomes too heavy to carry.
- Research the "K-Gun" offense. Modern NFL offenses owe a massive debt to what Sam Wyche and Marv Levy were doing in Buffalo. They were decades ahead of their time.
- Check out the "30 for 30" companion podcasts. There are deeper interviews with Bill Polian (the GM) that explain how they built that roster through the draft with surgical precision.
- Visit the Buffalo Heritage Press archives. If you want the raw, unedited feeling of that era, look at the local newspaper headlines from the week after Super Bowl XXV. The support was immediate, not retrospective.
The Bills of the 90s didn't "fall" in the way most people think. They climbed higher than almost anyone else ever has, four times in a row, and simply ran out of mountain. That’s not a failure. That’s an epic.