It feels like a lifetime ago, doesn’t it? The year was 2005. Low-rise jeans were peak fashion, "Gold Digger" by Kanye West was blasting on every radio station, and a little show about a guy with a yellow umbrella was just a pitch in a boardroom. How I Met Your Mother officially started on September 19, 2005.
That Monday night on CBS wasn't just another sitcom premiere. It was the beginning of a nine-year obsession. Honestly, if you were watching TV back then, the landscape was a bit weird. Friends had ended just a year prior, leaving a massive, coffee-shop-shaped hole in our hearts. Networks were scrambling to find the "next big thing" that captured the magic of twenty-somethings navigating life and love.
Most failed. But Ted Mosby didn't.
📖 Related: Finding The Working Man Showtimes: Why This Indie Gem is Still Worth the Hunt
The Night the Legend Began
When the pilot episode aired that September, nobody knew "Legendary" would become a catchphrase or that we’d spend nearly a decade debating the identity of a woman we hadn't even seen yet. The premiere introduced us to a 27-year-old architect named Ted, his engaged best friends Marshall and Lily, and a suit-wearing enigma named Barney Stinson.
The first episode pulled a massive bait-and-switch. We all thought Robin Scherbatsky was "The Mother." Then, Future Ted (voiced by the late, great Bob Saget) dropped the bomb: "And that, kids, is how I met your Aunt Robin."
It was a brilliant move. It told the audience right away: This isn't the story you think it is.
When Did HIMYM Start? Breaking Down the Timeline
If you're looking for the specifics, here's how the launch of the show actually looked on paper:
- Original Air Date: September 19, 2005.
- Network: CBS.
- Creators: Carter Bays and Craig Thomas.
- The Lead-in: It actually aired at 8:30 PM, following The King of Queens.
- Viewership: About 10.94 million people tuned in for that first episode.
By today's streaming standards, 11 million viewers for a pilot is a massive hit. But back in 2005? It was a solid start, though far from a guaranteed home run. The show actually struggled a bit in the ratings during those early years. It was always on the "bubble," meaning it was constantly at risk of being canceled.
📖 Related: Norman Reedus: What Most People Get Wrong About Daryl Dixon’s Real Identity
Can you imagine? A world where we never met Tracy or saw the Slap Bet? It almost happened.
The Real-Life Inspiration
What most people don't realize is that the show’s beginning was rooted in very real, very messy lives. Carter Bays and Craig Thomas were writers for Late Show with David Letterman in New York. They spent their nights at a bar called McGee’s (the inspiration for MacLaren’s Pub) and decided to write a show about their own friend group.
Ted is basically Carter. Marshall is Craig. Lily is based on Craig’s wife, Rebecca.
They didn't just invent these characters; they lived them. That’s probably why the dialogue felt so snappy and authentic. It wasn't "sitcom talk"; it was how friends actually roasted each other over a beer.
Why the Start of the Show Was Different
Most sitcoms in 2005 used a "multi-cam" setup with a live studio audience. You know the drill—three walls, a couch, and a laugh track that feels a bit forced. How I Met Your Mother was technically a multi-cam show, but it was filmed without an audience.
Why? Because the show was too fast.
📖 Related: Ireland by Garth Brooks: Why This 90s Deep Cut Still Moves the Emerald Isle
The pilot had over 60 scenes. Most sitcoms have maybe 10 or 15. Because of all the flashbacks and "cutaway" gags, they couldn't possibly film it in front of a crowd. They would film the whole episode, edit it together, and then play it for an audience to record the laughter. It gave the show a cinematic, fast-paced energy that nothing else on TV had at the time.
Casting What-Ifs
The start of the show could have looked wildly different. Imagine this: Scott Foley was originally offered the role of Ted Mosby. He turned it down. Jennifer Love Hewitt was offered the role of Robin, but she chose to do Ghost Whisperer instead.
And the biggest shocker? Jim Parsons—yes, Sheldon from The Big Bang Theory—auditioned for Barney Stinson.
He described the character in the script as a "big lug of a guy." Neil Patrick Harris eventually got the part because he did a literal dive-roll during his audition while pretending to play laser tag. That physical comedy sealed the deal. Without NPH, the show probably wouldn't have survived past Season 1.
The "Victoria" Backup Plan
Because the show’s future was so uncertain when it started, the creators had to have a "backup" Mother. If the show had been canceled after its first 13 or 22 episodes, Victoria (the baker) would have been the Mother.
That’s why her arc in Season 1 feels so significant. She was the safety net.
Luckily, the show found its footing. It survived the 2007 writers' strike, it survived a few shifts in time slots, and it eventually became the flagship comedy for CBS.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're looking to revisit the beginning of the show or dive deeper into the lore, here’s how to do it right:
- Watch the Pilot with "The Mother" in Mind: If you go back to the very first episode, pay attention to the dialogue. The creators already had the ending planned out. They even filmed the scenes with the kids (Lyndsy Fonseca and David Henrie) for the finale back in 2006 to ensure they wouldn't age.
- Visit the Real MacLaren's: If you’re ever in New York City, go to McGee’s Pub on West 55th Street. It’s where the creators hung out, and you can see plenty of show memorabilia there. It’s the closest you’ll get to sitting in that iconic red booth.
- Check Out "The Solids": The theme song, "Hey Beautiful," isn't just a snippet created for the show. It's a full song by a band called The Solids, which—you guessed it—features Carter Bays and Craig Thomas.
The show may have started in 2005, but its impact is still everywhere. Whether you love the finale or hate it, there's no denying that that September night in 2005 kicked off one of the most unique storytelling journeys in television history. All it took was a blue French horn and a group of friends who didn't know they were making history.