You’ve probably walked right past it. If you’re heading toward Central Park from the 72nd Street subway station, 170 W 74th St New York just looks like another stately pre-war facade in a neighborhood full of them. But it isn't. Not really.
There is a specific kind of magic to the Upper West Side that isn't about the glass towers of Billionaires' Row or the chaotic energy of Times Square. It’s about red brick. It’s about those wrought-iron fences. It’s about the The San Remo and The Dakota, sure, but it’s also about these mid-block gems that hold the actual soul of the city. 170 West 74th Street—officially known as The Pythian Condominium—is exactly that. It’s a building with a history so weird and a visual profile so striking that it makes most modern luxury condos look like cardboard boxes.
Honestly, the first time you see the entrance, you might think you’ve stumbled onto a movie set for an Indiana Jones sequel.
The Architectural Fever Dream of 170 W 74th St New York
Most New York buildings pick a lane. They’re either Gothic, or Art Deco, or Modernist. This place? It decided to be everything at once, specifically leaning into an Egyptian Revival style that feels almost psychedelic.
Built in 1927, it wasn't originally meant for people to live in. It was the headquarters for the Knights of Pythias. That's a fraternal organization, kinda like the Masons but with their own specific rituals and secret handshakes. The architect, Thomas W. Lamb, was famous for designing opulent theaters. You can tell. He went absolutely wild with the terracotta. We’re talking seated pharaohs, massive columns, and bright blues and yellows that shouldn't work on a Manhattan street but somehow do.
It’s bold.
💡 You might also like: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
In the 1980s, the building went through a massive transformation. It was converted into luxury apartments by architect David Gura. This is where the story gets interesting for anyone looking at real estate. Gura didn't just slap some drywall over the old lodge rooms. He sliced the massive, double-height ritual halls into multi-level lofts. That’s why, if you ever step inside one of these units, the proportions feel "off" in the best way possible. You might have 15-foot ceilings in a living room and then a cozy, tucked-away sleeping loft. It’s irregular. It’s human.
Why the Floor Plans Are So Weird (and Desirable)
If you're used to the cookie-cutter layouts of New York apartments where the kitchen is always here and the bathroom is always there, 170 W 74th St New York will break your brain.
Because it was a fraternal lodge, the structural bones are massive. Some units feature oversized windows that were originally designed to light up grand ceremonial stages. Others have terraces that feel more like stone parapets from a castle. Living here isn't just about the square footage—though there’s plenty of that—it’s about the volume.
The Upper West Side is notorious for "long and skinny" apartments. You know the ones. You walk in the front door and have to trek down a hallway the size of a bowling alley just to get to the window. The Pythian avoids this. Because of the 1980s conversion, many units are wide. They feel like gallery spaces.
The Cultural Weight of the Neighborhood
You aren't just buying or renting at 170 W 74th St New York; you’re embedding yourself in a very specific ecosystem.
📖 Related: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
- Levain Bakery: You are literally steps away from the world's most famous walnut chocolate chip cookie. The smell on 74th street is basically a permanent caloric intake.
- Central Park: You’re two blocks away. That’s the "I can go for a run in my pajamas and no one will care" distance.
- Beacon Theatre: It’s right around the corner. You'll see tour buses idling on Broadway and know that someone like Bob Dylan or Jerry Seinfeld is just a few hundred feet from your front door.
Living here means you're in the heart of what people call "The Museum District," though locals just call it home. It's the kind of place where you see famous actors at the Fairway Market deli counter arguing about the price of lox. It’s unpretentious despite the high price tags.
Is 170 W 74th St New York a Good Investment?
Let’s talk money. Or at least, the reality of the market.
The Upper West Side (UWS) is generally more stable than the East Side or the trendy pockets of Brooklyn. When the market dips, the UWS usually holds its breath and stays put. 170 W 74th St New York is a condominium, not a co-op. This is a huge distinction in New York. Co-ops are notorious for having "board interviews" that feel like a deposition. Condos are much more flexible. You can sublet. You can buy through an LLC. It makes the building attractive to international buyers and people who don't want a board member asking why they spent $500 on a pair of sneakers in 2019.
The common charges here are relatively reasonable for a full-service building. You have a 24-hour doorman. You have a gym. You have the history. But you don't have the insane "white glove" fluff that drives monthlies into the five-figure range for no reason.
The Reality Check: What to Watch Out For
Nothing is perfect. Even a building with pharaohs on the front.
👉 See also: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
- Light Issues: Because the building is nestled mid-block, some of the lower-floor units that face the back can feel a bit like a well. You’re looking at the brick backs of other 19th-century brownstones. It’s quiet, but it can be dark.
- Renovation Needs: Some of the units haven't been touched since that 1980s conversion. You might find some "interesting" pastel tile or glass blocks that felt very Miami Vice forty years ago but feel a bit dated now.
- The Tourists: People will stop and take pictures of your front door. Often. If you’re the kind of person who wants total anonymity, the bright blue terracotta of 170 W 74th St New York might be a bit too much "look at me."
Living the Upper West Side Life
What's it actually like? You wake up. You walk down to Viand for a coffee. Maybe you hit the Greenmarket at 77th and Columbus on a Sunday. You aren't fighting the crowds of Midtown. You’re in a neighborhood where the dry cleaner knows your name.
The Pythian represents a time when New York wasn't afraid to be slightly eccentric. It’s a middle finger to the glass-and-steel boxes that are slowly turning every city in the world into the same sterile landscape. It’s weird. It’s heavy. It’s colorful.
If you're looking at property at 170 W 74th St New York, you aren't just looking for a bedroom count. You're looking for a conversation piece. You're looking for a place where the lobby looks like a temple and the elevators actually work.
Actionable Insights for Prospective Residents or Investors
- Check the Loft Heights: If you are over six feet tall, pay close attention to the mezzanine heights in the converted units. Some are generous; others are "watch your head" tight.
- Verify the Tax Abatements: Many UWS buildings have complex tax histories. While The Pythian is established, always have your lawyer check the specific tax lot status for any recent assessments.
- Visit at Night: The 74th street corridor changes character after 9:00 PM. It’s remarkably quiet, but the lighting on the building’s facade is something you need to see to appreciate.
- Prioritize South-Facing Units: If you want that iconic New York light, the units facing 74th Street are the gold standard. They clear the brownstones across the street and get incredible sun during the winter months.
- Review the Alteration Agreement: Because of the building's age and unique structure, renovations can be tricky. If you plan on gutting a unit, get the building's handbook early to see what's allowed regarding those massive historical windows.
The Pythian isn't just an address. It’s a landmark that happens to have mailboxes. Whether you're an architecture nerd or just someone who wants to live near the best cookies in the city, it’s a building that demands you pay attention.