Paul Haggis is a name that usually brings up two very different reactions. You either think of his Oscar-winning success with Crash or the massive legal clouds that have followed him lately. But if we’re just looking at the work, his 2013 flick Third Person is probably one of the most polarizing "puzzle movies" of the last two decades. People still search for the Third Person film cast because, honestly, the lineup is kind of insane for a movie that mostly got panned by critics.
It’s got Liam Neeson. It’s got Mila Kunis. It’s got Adrien Brody.
You’ve got three different cities—Paris, Rome, and New York—and three different stories that seem totally disconnected until they aren't. It’s a lot to keep track of. When you look at the Third Person film cast, you aren't just looking at a list of actors; you’re looking at a group of people playing characters who might not even "exist" in the traditional sense within the logic of the film’s universe. It’s meta. It’s messy. It’s very Haggis.
The Heavy Hitters: Liam Neeson and Olivia Wilde in Paris
Liam Neeson plays Michael. Forget the Taken version of Neeson where he’s punching everyone in the throat. In this one, he’s a writer. He’s holed up in a Parisian hotel trying to finish his latest book, and he’s clearly miserable. Michael is the "anchor" of the Third Person film cast because he basically functions as the god-complex creator of everything else we see.
Then you have Olivia Wilde playing Anna. She’s Michael’s mistress. Their relationship is toxic, kind of exhausting to watch, and filled with these weird "gotcha" games. Wilde brings this frantic, unpredictable energy to the role that makes you wonder if Anna is a real person or just a projection of Michael’s guilt over his own daughter’s death. That’s the big twist, right? Michael is writing a story to process his trauma, and the cast we see on screen are the characters in his manuscript.
The Rome Connection: Adrien Brody and Moran Atias
Moving over to Italy, we get Adrien Brody as Scott. He’s an American fashion businessman—basically a guy who steals designs—who ends up in a bar and meets Monika, played by Moran Atias.
Atias is actually a huge part of why this movie exists. She worked with Haggis on the Crash TV series and was the one who pitched him the idea of a multi-strand story about the "third person" in a relationship—the one who isn't physically there but dominates the headspace.
✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Their plotline feels like a thriller. Monika is trying to rescue her daughter from traffickers, and Scott keeps throwing money at the problem. Is she a con artist? Is she telling the truth? Brody plays the "sad, lonely American" perfectly, but again, because of how the movie is structured, you have to ask if Scott is just Michael’s way of exploring his own need for redemption.
The New York Heartbreak: Mila Kunis and James Franco
This is the part of the Third Person film cast that actually feels the most grounded, which makes it the most painful to watch. Mila Kunis plays Julia, a former soap opera actress who is now working as a maid in a high-end hotel. She’s lost custody of her son because she’s accused of trying to kill him.
James Franco plays Rick, the famous artist ex-husband. He’s cold. He’s smug. He’s convinced Julia is a monster.
Kunis is genuinely great here. She’s stripped back, no makeup, mostly just crying or looking desperate. It’s a far cry from That '70s Show. The New York segments focus on the "third person" being the lawyer or the social worker—the people who stand between a mother and her child.
Breaking Down the Full Ensemble
If you’re looking for the complete list of who showed up for this production, it’s a deep bench:
- Liam Neeson as Michael Leary
- Mila Kunis as Julia Weiss
- Adrien Brody as Scott Lowry
- Olivia Wilde as Anna Barr
- James Franco as Richard "Rick" Weiss
- Moran Atias as Monika
- Maria Bello as Theresa
- Kim Basinger as Elaine Leary
- Loan Chabanol as Sam
- Riccardo Scamarcio as Marco
Maria Bello plays the lawyer, Theresa, who links the stories. Kim Basinger has a very small, very quiet role as Michael’s wife back home. Her presence is meant to be the weight of reality crashing down on Michael’s fictional world.
🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Why the Cast Couldn't Save the Reviews
On paper, this movie should have been a massive hit. You have multiple Oscar winners and some of the biggest stars of the 2010s. But when it premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival, it got shredded.
Why?
Mostly because people felt the "twist" was too clever for its own good. When you realize that the Third Person film cast is essentially a collection of figments from a grieving writer's imagination, it can make the previous two hours feel a bit like a cheat. If Scott isn't real, why did I care about his money being stolen? If Julia isn't real, why did I care about her kid?
Haggis was trying to do something sophisticated regarding the nature of creation. He wanted to show how a writer steals pieces of real people to build a narrative. The problem is that the audience usually wants to feel like the stakes are real, not just "ink on a page."
Behind the Scenes and Production Facts
The movie wasn't a big-budget studio affair. It was an independent production that filmed across three countries. Haggis has talked about how difficult it was to manage the schedules of a Third Person film cast this famous. You have to get James Franco in between his twelve other projects and Mila Kunis while she’s at the height of her film career.
Interestingly, Moran Atias didn't just act in the film; she’s a co-producer. She spent years developing the themes with Haggis. She wanted to explore the idea of how we are all "third persons" in someone else's life—the observers who don't have the full story.
💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
The film’s cinematography, handled by Gianfilippo Corticelli, is actually one of its strongest suits. Each city has a distinct color palette. Paris is cool and blue. Rome is warm, golden, and slightly dirty. New York is sterile and grey. It helps the viewer keep track of which storyline they’re in, even when the script starts jumping around.
The Confusion Around the "Third Person" Title
People often get confused about what the title actually refers to. It’s not about "Third Person" as in a video game camera angle. It’s a grammatical and psychological reference.
In writing, "third person" is the perspective of an outsider looking in. In relationships, the "third person" is often the ghost of a past lover or a child that was lost. For the Third Person film cast, every single character is haunted by someone who isn't there. Michael is haunted by his son who drowned. Julia is haunted by the son she can't see. Scott is haunted by the daughter he’s trying to save (who might not even be in danger).
Key Takeaways for Viewers
If you’re planning on watching or re-watching Third Person, keep a few things in mind to make sense of the chaos:
- Watch the backgrounds. There are "glitches" where characters from one city appear in the background of another. This is the first hint that the timelines aren't real.
- Focus on the note. A recurring note that says "Watch me" or "Look at me" appears in different storylines. It’s the tether between the fictional world and Michael’s reality.
- Pay attention to the names. Sometimes names are swapped or reused, signaling that Michael is recycling his real life for his fiction.
- Don't expect a linear payoff. This isn't a mystery where everything gets tied up with a neat bow. It’s an emotional character study disguised as a puzzle.
Actionable Steps for Film Buffs
If you’re interested in the work of the Third Person film cast or the style of Paul Haggis, here is how you can dive deeper:
- Compare to 'Crash': Watch Haggis’s Crash (2004) right after Third Person. You’ll see the exact same DNA—the overlapping stories and the heavy focus on coincidence—but Third Person is much more experimental.
- Check out 'The Next Three Days': If you want to see Neeson and Haggis working together in a more straightforward, high-stakes thriller, this is a better entry point.
- Research Moran Atias's Producer Credits: Since she was a driving force behind the story, looking at her other work in international cinema provides context for the themes of displacement and the "outsider" perspective seen in the Rome storyline.
- Look for the Director's Cut: If you can find it, Haggis has discussed the editing process extensively. The way the movie was sliced together changed significantly from the initial script to the final theatrical release.
Ultimately, the Third Person film cast did the best they could with a script that was trying to be five different things at once. Whether you think it’s a brilliant masterpiece about the pain of writing or a self-indulgent mess, you can’t deny that seeing this many A-listers in one weird, experimental drama is a fascinating watch. It represents a specific era of "mid-budget" filmmaking that we don't see much of anymore in the age of superhero dominance.