Let’s be real for a second. The Ballon d'Or used to be predictable. For about fifteen years, you basically just flipped a coin between Messi and Ronaldo, and unless Luka Modrić did something heroic, you were right. But looking at the Ballon d'Or 2025 favorites, we are officially in the "Wild West" era of football.
The 2024/25 season is weird. It’s the first full cycle where the "Old Guard" is completely out of the European picture. No Messi in Paris or Barcelona. No Ronaldo in Madrid. Instead, we’re watching a frantic, high-speed scramble for the throne. If you think it’s just going to be Vinícius Júnior or Erling Haaland every year, you haven’t been paying attention to how the voting criteria changed. Individual "clutch" moments now outweigh career trophies. That changes everything.
The Real Contenders: Breaking Down the Ballon d'Or 2025 Favorites
Winning the Champions League is still the golden ticket. It just is. But with the new UCL format—more games, more fatigue, more chances for injuries—the players who survive the winter slog are the ones who will stand on that podium in Paris.
Lamine Yamal is the name on everyone's lips, and honestly, it’s for good reason. The kid is 17 and playing like he’s got a mortgage and three kids to provide for. He isn't just a "prospect" anymore. After his Euro 2024 performance, the 2025 cycle is his to lose if Barcelona keeps their current momentum. He’s the spark. When he gets the ball on the right wing, the entire stadium holds its breath. That kind of "vibe" matters to journalists who vote.
Then you have Vinícius Júnior. He’s already experienced the heartbreak of coming close, and that usually fuels a monster season. Real Madrid is a goal-scoring factory, even if the chemistry with Mbappé looked a bit clunky at the start of the campaign. Vini has that rare ability to win a game in a ten-second burst of chaos. If Madrid defends their European title, he’s likely the frontrunner.
But don't ignore Kylian Mbappé. People love to criticize his defensive work rate, but the man is a statistical anomaly. He puts up numbers that would make prime Thierry Henry blush. Transitioning to life at the Bernabéu is hard, but he’s Kylian Mbappé. He’s going to score 30+ goals just by waking up in the morning.
The Erling Haaland Problem
Haaland is a cyborg. We know this. He breaks records like they’re cheap toys. But he has a "narrative" problem. Because he doesn’t always "look" like a magician on the ball—he’s more of a physical force of nature—some voters find him less "romantic" than a player like Yamal or Bellingham.
💡 You might also like: Cómo entender la tabla de Copa Oro y por qué los puntos no siempre cuentan la historia completa
To win the 2025 Ballon d'Or, Haaland doesn't just need to score. He needs to win the Premier League AND the Champions League while being the decisive factor in the semi-finals and finals. Fair? Maybe not. But that’s the reality of the award.
Jude Bellingham’s Diminishing Returns?
Last year, Jude was the undisputed king for the first six months. Then injuries happened. Fatigue set in. For the 2025 cycle, he’s playing a slightly deeper role to accommodate the "Galactico" frontline at Madrid. Can a box-to-box midfielder win the Ballon d'Or in 2025? It’s tough. You usually need those "Screamer from 30 yards" moments to stay in the headlines.
Why the New Format Changes the Math
The Champions League changed. More games. More "big vs big" matches in the early stages. This is huge for the Ballon d'Or 2025 favorites because it gives them more opportunities to perform in high-stakes environments before the knockout rounds even start.
In the old days, a star player could stat-pad against a random team from a smaller league. Now? They have to face Bayern, Liverpool, or Inter Milan in the "League Phase." If Mohamed Salah goes on a tear and drags Liverpool to the top of that massive table, his stock rises significantly. Salah is the dark horse here. He’s in the final year of his contract (potentially), playing with a "nothing to lose" attitude under Arne Slot. Never count out a hungry Mo Salah.
The Midfield Maestros: Rodri and the "Unsung Hero" Tax
Rodri won in 2024, which was a massive shock to some, but a relief to football purists. It proved that you don’t have to be a striker to win. However, lightning rarely strikes twice for defensive midfielders. Unless Manchester City wins a literal quadruple and Rodri scores another Champions League final winner, the voters will likely pivot back to the flashy attackers.
It's kinda unfair. But that's the gala for you.
📖 Related: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
What About the Bundesliga?
Harry Kane is still doing Harry Kane things. He’s scoring at a rate that is frankly ridiculous. But Bayern Munich needs trophies. If Kane wins the Bundesliga and the Golden Boot but exits the UCL early, he won’t win the Ballon d'Or. The "Kane Curse" is a meme, sure, but the Ballon d'Or is built on trophies and "Big Game" reputation.
Then there’s Florian Wirtz. If you aren’t watching Bayer Leverkusen, you’re missing out. He’s the most creative player in Germany, maybe Europe. If he leads Leverkusen to another deep European run or a domestic double, he’ll be in the top five. He’s a "player's player"—smooth, intelligent, and clinical.
The Criteria: What Voters Actually Care About Now
France Football explicitly clarified the rules recently. It’s not about your whole career anymore. It’s about:
- Individual performance and decisive character.
- Team performance and achievements (trophies).
- Class and fair play.
Notice that "Career" isn't there. This is why a teenager like Yamal or a veteran like Lewandowski can realistically compete if they have one insane 10-month stretch.
The weight of the Club World Cup in 2025 is also a massive wildcard. It’s a new, expanded tournament. If someone like Cole Palmer—who has been carrying Chelsea on his back—dominates that tournament in the summer of 2025, it could provide the "recency bias" needed to vault him into the top three. Palmer is a fascinating case. He’s got that "cold" persona that social media loves. Don't underestimate the power of TikTok edits and viral moments in modern voting.
Surprising Names to Watch (The "Wildcards")
Every year, someone comes out of nowhere.
👉 See also: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
- Bukayo Saka: If Arsenal finally breaks their trophy drought and wins the PL or UCL, Saka is their poster boy. He’s consistent, liked by everyone, and plays in the most-watched league in the world.
- Nico Williams: After his Euro 2024 breakout, if he stays healthy and carries Athletic Club (or a future big-money club) to silverware, he’s got the flair that voters crave.
- Lautaro Martínez: He’s been the best player in Italy for a while now. If Inter Milan makes another UCL final run, his name will be right there.
The Narrative Trap
Football is as much about stories as it is about stats. The "Return of Barcelona" is a great story, which helps Yamal. The "Mbappé Completes the Puzzle" is a great story, which helps Kylian. The "Haaland Robot 2.0" is a bit boring now, which actually hurts Erling.
To be one of the Ballon d'Or 2025 favorites, you need a "moment." Think of Messi’s goal against Mexico in the World Cup or Vinícius’s goal in the 2024 UCL final. You need that one image that defines the season. Right now, we’re waiting for that image to happen.
What You Should Do Now
If you’re following the race for the 2025 trophy, stop looking at career goals. Start looking at "Big Chances Created" and "Goals Against Top 6 Opposition." The voters are becoming more analytical, but they still love a hero.
Keep a very close eye on the injury reports coming out of Madrid and Manchester. With the increased game load, the winner might simply be the superstar who manages to stay fit until May. Longevity within a single season is the new "X-factor."
Watch the Champions League knockout stages with a pen and paper. Whoever scores in the quarter-finals and semi-finals is usually the person holding the golden ball in October. It's that simple.
Actionable Insights for Following the Race:
- Track the "Big Game" Stats: Ignore goals against bottom-table teams. Focus on performances in the UCL "League Phase" against top-tier opponents.
- Monitor the Club World Cup: Since this is a new factor for the 2025 season, the winner of this summer tournament will have a massive edge in recency bias.
- Watch the Odds Shifters: Bookmakers often react faster than journalists to "momentum shifts." If a player's odds drop suddenly after a random Tuesday night game, pay attention.
- Focus on the "Main Man" Synergy: In teams like Real Madrid, see who is actually taking the penalties and free kicks. Output is king, and sharing the workload with Mbappé, Vini, and Bellingham might actually lower all their individual chances.