You’ve probably heard the term tossed around during every election cycle. A "lame duck" president is basically a leader stuck in political purgatory. They’ve either lost their bid for reelection, reached their term limit, or decided to pack it in, but they’re still sitting in the Oval Office until the new person takes the keys. It’s a weird, awkward window of time where they have all the legal power of the presidency but almost none of the political capital.
But who was the first one? Honestly, the answer depends on whether you're talking about the behavior or the label.
If we’re looking for the very first president to find himself in this position—voted out but still forced to govern for months—the answer is John Adams.
John Adams: the original lame duck (before it was a thing)
Back in 1800, the United States was still trying to figure out how a peaceful transfer of power even worked. John Adams, our second president, lost a bitter, nasty election to Thomas Jefferson. Today, we have a transition period of about 75 days. In 1800? It was a massive four-month gap. Adams lost the election in November, but he didn’t leave office until March 4, 1801.
He didn't just sit around and mope, though. He spent those four months being the most active "lame duck" in American history, even if nobody called him that yet. Adams was terrified that Jefferson’s "radical" Democratic-Republicans would tear down the federal government. So, he and the Federalist-controlled Congress got busy.
They passed the Judiciary Act of 1801, which created a bunch of new judge positions. Adams spent his final nights in office frantically signing commissions for these Federalist judges so they could hold onto the judicial branch even after he lost the executive. These became known as the "Midnight Appointments." It was a classic lame-duck move: using the last bits of authority to frustrate the incoming administration.
Where did the "lame duck" name actually come from?
Surprisingly, the phrase didn't start in Washington D.C. It started in the London Stock Exchange in the 1700s. Back then, if a stockbroker defaulted on their debts, they were called a "lame duck" because they couldn't keep up with the rest of the "flock" of investors. They were basically waddling away in disgrace.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
It took a while for the term to migrate to American politics.
The first recorded time the phrase was used to describe a politician in the U.S. was in 1863 in the Congressional Globe. It wasn't even about a president; it was about "broken-down" congressmen. It wasn't until 1926 that a newspaper—the Grand Rapids Press—specifically used the term for a president, referring to Calvin Coolidge.
So, while Adams was the first president to be a lame duck in practice, Coolidge was arguably the first one to be called it in the press.
Why the "lame duck" period used to be a total disaster
For over a century, the U.S. had a massive problem. The Constitution originally set March 4 as the start date for the new president. Why? Because in the 1700s, it took forever to count votes and even longer for a president-elect to travel by horse and carriage to the capital.
This long delay was dangerous.
The Buchanan Crisis
Take James Buchanan. After Abraham Lincoln won the 1860 election, Buchanan had to sit there for four months while the Southern states started seceding. He basically said, "I don't think they can legally leave, but I also don't think I can legally stop them." He did almost nothing while the country fell apart. That’s the ultimate nightmare scenario of a lame-duck period.
👉 See also: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
The Great Depression Gap
Then there was Herbert Hoover. He lost to FDR in 1932 during the absolute depths of the Great Depression. Between November and March, the economy was in a freefall. Hoover tried to get FDR to agree to his policies before taking office, but FDR refused. The country was essentially leaderless for four months during its worst financial crisis ever.
The 20th Amendment: shrinking the "duck" window
By 1933, the country had finally had enough. Senator George Norris pushed for what we now call the "Lame Duck Amendment"—the 20th Amendment to the Constitution.
It did two main things:
- It moved the presidential inauguration from March 4 to January 20.
- It moved the start of the new Congress to January 3.
This shortened the transition by about six weeks. It didn't kill the lame-duck period entirely, but it made it a lot harder for a defeated president to cause massive damage or for a national crisis to go unaddressed for half a year.
Can a lame duck president actually do anything?
Actually, yeah. A lot.
Because they don't have to worry about being reelected, lame-duck presidents often get... creative. They can issue controversial pardons, sign executive orders that their party loves but the public hates, or make last-minute diplomatic moves.
✨ Don't miss: 39 Carl St and Kevin Lau: What Actually Happened at the Cole Valley Property
- Bill Clinton issued 140 pardons on his last day, including one for billionaire Marc Rich.
- George H.W. Bush pardoned several people involved in the Iran-Contra scandal during his lame-duck weeks.
- Barack Obama used his final months to designate millions of acres as protected national monuments.
It’s a weird paradox. A lame duck has the least political influence but often the most personal freedom to act without consequences at the ballot box.
How to track the next lame duck period
Knowing the history of the first lame-duck president helps you see the patterns today. If you want to keep an eye on how power shifts during these windows, here’s how to do it:
Watch the "Midnight Rulemakings"
In the final months, look at the Federal Register. Outgoing administrations often rush to finish "economically significant" regulations before the new president takes over. These can take years for a new administration to undo.
Check the Pardon List
Most presidents wait until the very end—sometimes literally hours before the inauguration—to release their most controversial pardons. This is the peak of lame-duck behavior.
Monitor the Lame Duck Session of Congress
Sometimes the outgoing Congress meets one last time after the election. This is often where big, messy spending bills get passed because retiring members don't care about the political fallout anymore.
The story of the first lame-duck president isn't just a trivia fact about John Adams. It’s a reminder that the most dangerous or productive time for a leader is often when they have nothing left to lose.
If you want to understand how the next transition will play out, look back at 1800. The players change, but the "midnight" scramble for power stays exactly the same.