It is one of those trivia questions that feels like a trick. People usually start thinking about Irish-American cardinals in New York or maybe a quiet bishop from the Midwest who made it big in the Vatican. But the answer isn't what most people expect because they are looking at the wrong map. When you ask who was the first American Pope, you aren't talking about a citizen of the United States. You are talking about Jorge Mario Bergoglio.
He's from Argentina.
That counts. In the eyes of the Roman Catholic Church and the rest of the world outside the U.S. border, "American" covers the entire hemisphere. It was March 13, 2013, when the white smoke drifted over St. Peter’s Square, signaling that the 266th Bishop of Rome had been chosen. When he stepped onto the balcony, the world met Pope Francis. He didn't just break the European streak that had lasted for over 1,200 years; he became the first person from the Americas to ever hold the keys of St. Peter.
Why the "First American Pope" title causes so much confusion
Language is funny. In Philadelphia or Chicago, if you say "American," people assume you mean someone who pays taxes to the IRS. But in the context of global history, the Church sees the "Americas" as a unified New World. Bergoglio’s election was a massive seismic shift. Before him, you have to go all the way back to the 8th century to find a non-European pope—Gregory III, who was Syrian.
For centuries, the papacy was basically an Italian country club. Then it expanded to include Europeans like the Polish John Paul II and the German Benedict XVI. But the "New World" was always the mission field, not the leadership hub.
Francis changed that.
He grew up in Flores, a neighborhood in Buenos Aires. His father was an Italian immigrant, a railway worker who fled Mussolini’s fascism. His mother was born in Argentina to a family of Italian heritage. This mixture is actually the perfect metaphor for why he became the first American Pope. He represents the bridge between the old European roots of the Church and the exploding Catholic population in the Global South.
💡 You might also like: 39 Carl St and Kevin Lau: What Actually Happened at the Cole Valley Property
The path from a chemical technician to the Vatican
Bergoglio didn’t start out in a cathedral. Far from it. As a young man, he worked as a bouncer at a bar to help pay for his studies. Think about that for a second. The leader of over a billion Catholics once had to kick rowdy drunks out of a nightclub. He also worked as a chemical technician in a laboratory.
He didn't enter the seminary until he was 21.
His rise within the Jesuit order was fast but fraught with tension. He became the Provincial Superior of the Jesuits in Argentina in 1973, right as the country was sliding into the "Dirty War," a brutal period of military dictatorship. This era is where the "expert" nuance comes in. Critics and supporters still debate his role during those years. Some accused him of not doing enough to protect priests from the junta, while others—including many he secretly hid and saved—insisted he was working behind the scenes to keep people alive.
By the time he became the Archbishop of Buenos Aires, he had earned a reputation for extreme humility. He gave up the fancy palace. He cooked his own meals. He took the bus to work. That "man of the people" vibe wasn't a PR stunt; it was who he had been for decades.
Breaking the 1,200-year European streak
When Benedict XVI shocked the world by resigning in 2013, the College of Cardinals was looking for something different. The Church was facing scandals, declining numbers in the West, and a feeling that the Vatican had become too insular.
The conclave was fast.
📖 Related: Effingham County Jail Bookings 72 Hours: What Really Happened
On the fifth ballot, Bergoglio got the votes. He chose the name Francis, after St. Francis of Assisi, the saint of the poor. No pope had ever used that name before. It was a signal. He wasn't going to be a "prince" of the Church; he was going to be a pastor.
Key milestones of the first American papacy:
- Laudato si’: His 2015 encyclical on the environment. He basically told the world that caring for the planet is a moral, religious obligation, not just a political one.
- Curia Reform: He has spent years trying to clean up the Vatican Bank and the messy bureaucracy of the Roman Curia, though results have been mixed.
- Inclusivity: His famous "Who am I to judge?" comment regarding gay priests signaled a massive shift in tone, even if the underlying doctrine stayed the same.
- Global South Focus: He has consistently bypassed "powerful" cities to name cardinals from tiny, poor countries like Tonga, Laos, and Ethiopia.
Is there ever going to be a "U.S. American" Pope?
This is what people are usually actually asking. Will a citizen of the United States ever be Pope? Honestly, for a long time, the answer was a hard "no." The Vatican is a diplomatic entity as much as a religious one. If a Pope were from a global superpower like the U.S., the Church might look like an arm of American foreign policy. That’s a bad look for a global institution.
However, the "never" is starting to fade.
Names like Cardinal Sean O'Malley of Boston or Cardinal Raymond Burke have been floated in previous years. But the real shift is that the U.S. Church is now one of the primary "bankrolls" of the Vatican. As the Church in Europe shrinks, the influence of American (U.S.) cardinals grows.
Still, Francis remains the first American Pope because he proved the center of gravity has shifted away from Rome. The Church is now African, Asian, and Latin American.
What most people get wrong about his theology
There is a huge misconception that Francis is a "liberal" in the way we use the word in politics. He isn't. On issues like abortion or the priesthood being male-only, he hasn't moved the needle an inch. He is a traditional Jesuit.
👉 See also: Joseph Stalin Political Party: What Most People Get Wrong
The difference is his emphasis.
Where previous popes might have led with "here are the rules you are breaking," Francis leads with "here is a person who needs mercy." This "Mercy First" approach is why he is so polarizing. Conservative Catholics in the U.S. often find him frustratingly vague. Progressive Catholics often find him disappointingly traditional when it comes to hard-line doctrine.
The reality of being "First"
Being the first from the Americas meant Francis brought a different "theology of the people" to the Vatican. In Latin America, the Church is often on the front lines of poverty and social justice. It’s gritty. It’s loud. It’s messy.
He brought that mess to Rome.
He famously told young people to "make a mess" (hagan lío). He has spent his papacy trying to decentralize power, giving more authority to local bishops' conferences rather than having every single decision made by a guy in a red hat in Italy.
Actionable insights for understanding the Papacy today
If you want to understand the impact of the first American Pope, you should look at how the Church is changing in your own backyard.
- Watch the Cardinal Appointments: Don't look at the big names. Look at where the new Cardinals are coming from. Francis is stacking the deck with people from the "peripheries." This ensures that the next Pope—and the one after that—is likely to continue this non-European trend.
- Read the Original Sources: Don't just trust a 15-second news clip about what the Pope said. He often speaks in long, rambling interviews. If you read the full transcripts of his press conferences on airplanes, you get a much better sense of his "American" pragmatic style.
- Follow the Synodality Movement: This is the "big project" of his later years. It's basically a global listening session. He's trying to change the Church from a top-down monarchy into a more collaborative body.
The story of the first American Pope is still being written. At his age, and with his health struggles, the talk of the "next" conclave is constant. But whether the next guy is from Italy, Africa, or Chicago, the door that Jorge Mario Bergoglio kicked open isn't going to close anytime soon. The papacy is no longer a European inheritance. It belongs to the world.
To dive deeper into the history of the papacy, you can explore the official Vatican archives or look into the specific biographies of the 20th-century popes who paved the way for a global leader. Understanding the shift from the traditional "Old World" mentality to the "New World" perspective is key to grasping where the Church is headed in the 21st century.