When the white smoke finally drifted from the chimney of the Sistine Chapel on April 19, 2005, the world held its breath. It felt like an era had ended—because it had. Pope John Paul II had been the only pope many people had ever known. He was a global superstar. A powerhouse. So, when people ask who was pope after John Paul II, they aren't just looking for a name. They're asking about the man who had to step into those massive, red papal shoes.
That man was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. He took the name Benedict XVI.
Honestly, it wasn't a huge surprise to Vatican insiders. Ratzinger had been John Paul II’s right-hand man for decades. He was the "Enforcer." The "Panzerkardinal." He was the guy who handled the tough theological crackdowns. But being the behind-the-scenes brain is very different from being the face of a billion people. Benedict XVI didn't have the effortless charisma of his predecessor. He was a scholar. A quiet, somewhat shy German intellectual who would rather be playing Mozart on his piano than waving to millions from a "popemobile."
The Conclave of 2005: Why it was always Ratzinger
You have to understand the mood in Rome that April. Over four million people had flooded the city for John Paul II's funeral. The "Santo Subito!" (Sainthood Now!) cries were deafening. The Cardinals were under immense pressure to find someone who could maintain that momentum while steering a church that was starting to fracture under the weight of modern scandals and internal bureaucracy.
The Conclave was one of the fastest in history.
Ratzinger entered the Conclave as the Dean of the College of Cardinals. He gave the homily at the pre-conclave Mass, and he didn't hold back. He warned against the "dictatorship of relativism." It was a bold, "this is who I am" moment. While some Cardinals wanted a more progressive path—names like Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini were tossed around—the momentum stayed with the status quo. They wanted a steady hand.
📖 Related: Trump Approval Rating State Map: Why the Red-Blue Divide is Moving
By the fourth ballot, it was over. Joseph Ratzinger was the new Pope.
Understanding Benedict XVI: More than just a successor
If John Paul II was the Pope of the People, Benedict XVI was the Pope of the Word. He wasn't trying to be a rockstar. He was trying to be a teacher.
His first encyclical, Deus Caritas Est (God is Love), surprised a lot of people. Critics expected a fire-and-brimstone lecture on morality. Instead, they got a deep, beautiful meditation on the nature of love. He was trying to strip the faith back to its essentials. He felt the West was losing its soul, forgetting its Christian roots, and he wanted to remind everyone why the faith mattered in the first place.
But his papacy was far from smooth sailing.
He inherited the burgeoning clergy sexual abuse scandal, a crisis that had been simmering for years. While he was actually one of the first in the Vatican to start pushing for stricter rules—he defrocked the notorious Marcial Maciel, something John Paul II hadn't done—the public perception was often that he wasn't doing enough, or fast enough. Then there was the Regensburg speech in 2006. He quoted a 14th-century Byzantine emperor regarding Islam, and it sparked protests worldwide. It was a classic "Ratzinger moment"—a highly academic point that didn't translate well to a 24-hour news cycle.
👉 See also: Ukraine War Map May 2025: Why the Frontlines Aren't Moving Like You Think
The "Vatileaks" Drama and the Shadows
The later years of his reign felt heavy. You had the "Vatileaks" scandal, where his own butler, Paolo Gabriele, leaked private documents to the press. These papers showed a Vatican riddled with infighting and corruption. It was messy. It was exhausting. Benedict looked increasingly frail.
He was a man of books living in a world of tweets.
The Shock That Changed the Papacy Forever
On February 11, 2013, Benedict did something no pope had done in 600 years. He quit.
He announced his resignation in Latin. It was so unexpected that some journalists in the room didn't even realize what he'd said until they processed the translation. He cited "lack of strength of mind and body." He was 85. He knew he couldn't do the job the way it needed to be done in a digital, fast-paced world.
This move was revolutionary. By stepping down, he humanized the papacy. He showed that the office was a service, not a life sentence. It cleared the way for the election of Pope Francis, who brought a completely different energy to the Vatican.
✨ Don't miss: Percentage of Women That Voted for Trump: What Really Happened
Key differences between John Paul II and Benedict XVI
It’s tempting to group them together because they were friends and collaborators. But their styles were worlds apart:
- Communication: John Paul II used his body, his voice, and his travels. Benedict used his pen. He wrote trilogies on the life of Jesus that became bestsellers.
- Theology: John Paul II was more focused on human rights and political freedom. Benedict was focused on the internal logic of the faith and liturgy. He even brought back the old Latin Mass in a more prominent way.
- Presence: John Paul II loved the crowds. Benedict seemed to tolerate them, but he always looked a bit more comfortable in a library.
What should you take away from this?
Asking who was pope after John Paul II leads you to a man who is often misunderstood. Benedict XVI wasn't just a "placeholder." He was an intellectual giant who tried to recalibrate the Catholic Church’s thinking before realizing he no longer had the physical stamina to lead it.
If you want to understand the modern Church, you have to look at the "Three Popes" era. John Paul II built the stage, Benedict XVI tried to write the script, and Francis is now trying to move the audience.
Actionable Insights for the Curious:
- Read his non-political work: If you want to see the "real" Benedict, skip the news headlines and read Introduction to Christianity. It’s a masterclass in theology regardless of your faith.
- Visit the Vatican Gardens: If you're ever in Rome, remember that Benedict lived in the Mater Ecclesiae monastery within those gardens for nearly a decade after he resigned—a "Pope Emeritus" living in the shadow of his successor.
- Watch "The Two Popes": While it takes some creative liberties for drama, the film gives a fantastic sense of the personality clash and eventual respect between Benedict and Francis.
- Look at the Resignation Precedent: Understand that every future pope now has the "Benedict Option." If they get too sick or too tired, they can leave. He changed the rules of the game forever.
The transition from John Paul II to Benedict XVI wasn't just a change in personnel. It was a shift from the "celebrity papacy" back to the "teaching papacy," and finally, to the "resigning papacy" that we live with today.