If you mention Ben from The Walking Dead to a die-hard fan, you’re usually met with a heavy sigh or a frustrated groan. He wasn't a villain. He wasn't some calculated mastermind trying to take down Rick Grimes. Honestly, he was just a kid who couldn't handle the end of the world, and that made him one of the most polarizing figures in the entire Telltale Games series.
Wait. Let’s get one thing straight before we dive in. When people search for this, they are almost always talking about Ben Paul from the video game, not the minor TV characters who shared the name. Ben was the tall, awkward high schooler who joined Lee Everett’s group after his teacher and friend were killed. He became the poster child for "the liability."
Survival isn't just about shooting straight. It’s about not making stupid mistakes. Ben made plenty. But if we’re being real, he’s probably the most realistic depiction of how a normal teenager would actually behave during a zombie apocalypse. He was terrified. He was clumsy. He was human.
Why Ben from The Walking Dead became the group’s biggest problem
Most characters in the series find their "thing." Rick becomes a leader. Kenny becomes the hardened survivor. Clementine becomes a warrior. Ben from The Walking Dead just stayed Ben. He never quite adapted, and that lack of growth is exactly what led to some of the most heartbreaking moments in the first season.
The biggest turning point was the deal with the bandits. Ben was secretly giving supplies to the bandits attacking the motor inn. He thought he was protecting everyone. He thought he was keeping them safe by meeting the bandits' demands. Instead, he caused a chain reaction of tragedy. This choice directly led to the raid on the motel, which led to the group fleeing, which eventually led to the death of Carley or Doug. It was a mess. A total, preventable mess.
💡 You might also like: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
You have to wonder what was going through his head. He was a kid who was way out of his depth. He saw a problem and tried to solve it without telling the adults, and it backfired in the worst way possible. It wasn't malice; it was pure, unadulterated incompetence fueled by fear.
The weight of guilt and the Crawford incident
By the time the group reached Savannah, Ben was a shell of a person. The guilt of what happened at the motel—and the fact that he let Lilly take the fall for "finding a traitor"—was eating him alive. He finally confessed to Kenny, which went about as well as you’d expect. Kenny, who had lost his entire family partly because of the chaos Ben's deal started, was ready to kill him.
Then came the bell tower at Crawford.
This is the moment players remember most. As the group is escaping a hoard of walkers, Ben falls. He’s pinned. He tells Lee to leave him. Depending on how you play, Lee can either save him or let him drop. If you save him, he gets a brief moment of standing up to Kenny, shouting about how he never even got to say goodbye to his family. It’s a raw, powerful scene that reminds you he isn't just a "screw-up." He’s a grieving child who lost everything and has been told every single day that he’s worthless.
📖 Related: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
Comparing Ben to other "liability" characters
The Walking Dead loves the "useless character" trope. We saw it with Nicholas in the TV show or Gabe in later seasons of the game. But Ben is different because he actually cared. Nicholas was a coward who would sacrifice others to save himself. Ben didn't want anyone to die; he just didn't know how to keep them alive.
- The Intent: Ben's mistakes came from a place of trying to help.
- The Result: Usually death or disaster.
- The Fan Reaction: Pure Vitriol.
There's a psychological element here called the "Fundamental Attribution Error." We judge Ben's actions based on his character (he's "weak") rather than the extreme situation he was in. If a 17-year-old today were dropped into a world where people are eating each other, would they really be a badass? Probably not. They'd probably be Ben.
The technical impact of Ben's choices on gameplay
From a narrative design perspective, Ben from The Walking Dead served a specific purpose. He was the catalyst. Telltale needed a way to break the status quo of the motor inn, and Ben was the perfect tool for that.
If Ben doesn't steal the supplies, the group stays at the motel longer. If the group stays at the motel, they might not meet Chuck, Omid, or Christa. They might not go to Savannah. The entire plot of Season One hinges on Ben's failure. It’s a brilliant, if frustrating, piece of writing. He is the personification of the "butterfly effect." One small, scared decision by a teenager ended up killing almost everyone in the original group.
👉 See also: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
Was there a way to "fix" Ben?
A lot of players ask if they could have trained him. Could Lee have turned Ben into a soldier? The game doesn't really give you that option. Ben is a fixed point of tragedy. Even if you are the nicest Lee possible, Ben still makes those mistakes. He still leaves Clementine surrounded by walkers in the street because he panics. That’s the most unforgivable thing he did in the eyes of many players. Leaving a child alone to save your own skin is a hard thing to come back from.
But even then, he didn't do it out of cruelty. He froze. Tonic immobility is a real biological response to extreme stress. His brain literally shut down. It doesn't make it right, but it makes it real.
Final thoughts on the boy who couldn't survive
Whether you dropped him in the bell tower or tried to save him until the very end, Ben from The Walking Dead remains one of the most discussed characters in gaming history. He represents the 90% of us who wouldn't be the hero. He represents the mistakes we're terrified of making when the stakes are life and death.
If you are looking to revisit his story, pay close attention to his dialogue in Episode 4. His outburst at Kenny is perhaps the most honest moment in the whole season. He finally stops apologizing and demands to be seen as a human being who is hurting. It doesn't excuse the people who died because of him, but it does explain him.
What to do next if you're diving back into the lore:
- Replay Season 1, Episode 3: Watch Ben's face during the arguments. The developers put a lot of subtle animation in his "shifty" behavior before the reveal.
- Compare Ben to Sarah (Season 2): Notice the parallels in how the group treats "weak" members and how it ultimately affects their survival rate.
- Look for the "Deleted" content: There are several lines of cut dialogue in the game files that show a slightly more capable version of Ben that was ultimately scrapped to make his story more tragic.
- Analyze the "Save Ben" path: If you haven't done a playthrough where you keep him alive as long as possible, do it. His final moments with Kenny provide a much more satisfying (and heartbreaking) conclusion to his arc than the bell tower drop.