You’re probably here because you're trying to figure out which "Hit and Run" we are even talking about. It’s a mess. Honestly, if you search for the cast of Hit and Run 2009, you’ll likely see Google trying to shove Dax Shepard and Kristen Bell down your throat. But wait. That movie came out in 2012.
The 2009 film is a completely different beast.
It’s a gritty, low-budget British-American thriller that most people have forgotten, yet it keeps popping up in streaming algorithms. We’re talking about a movie directed by Enda McCallion. It’s a dark, "wrong turn" style horror story that feels very much of its era. If you’re looking for the romantic comedy vibes of the 2012 flick, you’ve taken a very wrong turn yourself.
The Core Players: The Cast of Hit and Run 2009 Explained
The heavy lifting in this film falls on Laura Breckenridge. She plays Mary Murdock. You might recognize her from Gossip Girl (she was Rachel Carr) or the TV series Related. In this movie, she’s a college student who thinks she hit a deer on the way home from a party. Spoiler: It wasn't a deer.
Breckenridge carries the whole thing. Most of the movie is just her freaking out in a garage. It’s a tough gig for an actor because if you don't believe her panic, the whole tension snaps like a dry twig. She does a decent job of portraying that spiraling "oh no, my life is over" energy that drives the first act.
Then there’s Kevin Corrigan.
If you don't know the name, you definitely know the face. He is the ultimate "that guy" actor. He’s been in The Departed, Pineapple Express, and Grounded for Life. In the cast of Hit and Run 2009, he plays Timothy Emser. He is essentially the "victim," though the movie plays around with that role quite a bit. Corrigan is great at being unsettling. Even when he’s the one who got hit by a car, he manages to make the audience feel like maybe he’s not the person you’d want to grab a beer with.
👉 See also: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
Why the Supporting Cast Matters
The rest of the cast is pretty lean. You’ve got Christopher Shand as Rick. He’s the boyfriend. Every horror movie from the late 2000s needed a boyfriend character who either makes everything worse or dies trying to help. Shand plays the role exactly as you’d expect for a direct-to-video thriller. He’s the voice of "let's just cover this up," which, as we all know, is the worst possible advice in a movie.
There is also Megan Anderson as Jane.
Her role is smaller, but it adds to the claustrophobic feel of the small-town setting. The film doesn't waste time with a massive ensemble. It focuses on the guilt and the immediate aftermath of a split-second decision. By keeping the cast small, McCallion keeps the focus on Mary’s deteriorating mental state.
Why People Constantly Confuse This Film
It is incredibly easy to mix this up with other projects.
The most common mistake is the Dax Shepard movie. That one is a big-budget, car-chase-heavy action comedy. It’s bright. It’s funny. The cast of Hit and Run 2009 is the exact opposite. It’s shot in muted tones. It’s grim. There are no jokes. If you see Bradley Cooper with dreadlocks, you are watching the 2012 movie. If you see a girl crying in a dark garage while Kevin Corrigan stares at her menacingly, you’ve found the 2009 version.
There’s also a 2021 Netflix series called Hit & Run. Totally different.
✨ Don't miss: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
The 2009 film lives in that weird space of mid-tier horror that went straight to DVD in many territories or had a very limited theatrical run. It’s part of that "After Dark Horrorfest" style of filmmaking. It’s not a masterpiece, but for fans of the "guilt-driven thriller" subgenre, it’s a solid enough watch.
The Dynamics of the Performance
What’s interesting about this specific cast is how they handle the "cat and mouse" element. Once Mary realizes that the man she hit is still alive and trapped in her garage, the movie shifts. It’s no longer about the accident. It’s about the cover-up.
- Laura Breckenridge has to transition from a sympathetic victim of circumstance to someone capable of doing something truly dark.
- Kevin Corrigan has to play a role that is physically restrictive but psychologically dominant.
It’s a weird chemistry. Usually, the "villain" is the one chasing the "hero." Here, the hero has the villain tied up, yet she’s the one who is terrified. Corrigan’s ability to project menace while being incapacitated is really the only reason this movie works as well as it does.
Production Context and Realities
The film was shot largely in New Jersey. You can feel that East Coast chill in the night scenes. The budget was tight. When you have a small budget, you rely on your actors to fill the space that special effects or big action sequences usually occupy.
The director, Enda McCallion, came from a commercial and music video background. This shows in the visuals—there’s a lot of focus on texture and lighting. But without the specific performances from Breckenridge and Corrigan, the movie would have felt like a student film.
Some critics at the time—and honestly, some viewers today—find the plot a bit thin. They aren't wrong. It’s a "what would you do?" scenario stretched to 80 minutes. The cast of Hit and Run 2009 had to work hard to make the stakes feel real when the script sometimes leaned on tropes.
🔗 Read more: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
The Legacy of the 2009 Cast
Where are they now?
Laura Breckenridge hasn't been in the spotlight as much lately, though she had a good run in the early 2010s with various TV guest spots. Kevin Corrigan remains a legend of independent cinema and character acting. He’s one of those guys who will never lack work because he can turn even a three-minute scene into something memorable.
If you’re looking to watch this movie today, it usually pops up on ad-supported streaming services like Tubi or Pluto TV. It’s perfect "late-night, nothing else is on" viewing.
Actionable Takeaways for Movie Buffs
If you are trying to track down this specific film or learn more about the era of thrillers it belongs to, keep these points in mind:
- Verify the Director: If the credits don't say Enda McCallion, you aren't watching the 2009 version.
- Check the Genre: This is a horror/thriller. If you see a romantic subplot involving a witness protection program, that's the Dax Shepard movie.
- Look for Kevin Corrigan: He is the litmus test for this movie. His performance is the standout.
- Contextualize the Era: This was part of a wave of "torture porn" adjacent thrillers that focused on moral dilemmas and extreme situations, similar to movies like P2 or Captivity.
To get the most out of your viewing, watch it back-to-back with other 2009-era indie horrors. It provides a great snapshot of how filmmakers were trying to evolve the slasher genre into something more psychological and grounded at the end of the decade.