Fantasy football is basically a game of managing chaos, and honestly, Week 12 of the 2025 season is the definition of a mess. You’ve got the heavy hitters like the Denver Broncos, Miami Dolphins, Los Angeles Chargers, and Washington Commanders all sitting on their couches for a bye. That’s a lot of points just vanishing from your roster. If you’re like me, you’re staring at a lineup full of holes and wondering if that random waiver wire pickup is actually going to save your season or just tank it completely.
Let's get real. The "start your studs" mantra is great until your studs are either on a bye or dealing with a mid-season slump. This week, the decision-making process for who to start fantasy football week 12 isn't just about who has the highest projection; it's about who actually has a path to the end zone in a week where the injury report looks more like a CVS receipt.
The Quarterback Quagmire: Trusting the Rookies
It feels weird to say, but Drake Maye is the guy right now. He’s been a bit of an up-and-down roller coaster lately, averaging about 17.6 points per game over his last three, but he’s heading into a "get right" game against a Cincinnati Bengals defense that has been a sieve. They’ve allowed the most fantasy points to quarterbacks over the last month. If you’re looking for a high-floor play, Maye is basically the safest bet among the non-elite tier.
Then there’s the Jacoby Brissett situation in Arizona. I know, starting Brissett in 2025 sounds like a desperation move, but the dude just set an NFL record with 47 completions last week. 47! Even without Marvin Harrison Jr. (who is dealing with an unfortunate appendix issue), Brissett is finding ways to move the chains. The Jaguars' defense is bottom-five against QBs. If you’re in a 2-QB league or just desperate, he’s a legit top-10 play this week.
📖 Related: Jake Paul Mike Tyson Tattoo: What Most People Get Wrong
Quarterbacks to Target
- Lamar Jackson vs. NYJ: The Jets traded away Sauce Gardner and haven't been the same. Expect a massive bounce-back for Lamar.
- Jared Goff vs. NYG: Don't let last week's struggle in Philly scare you. The Giants allow the second-most points to QBs. Goff at home in a dome? Easy money.
- Bryce Young @ SF: Bold move? Maybe. But he just dropped 448 yards and three scores on Atlanta. The 49ers' defense is missing major pieces like Nick Bosa and Fred Warner. Young could feast again.
Running Backs: The "Next Man Up" Nightmare
The RB landscape is currently a battlefield. Josh Jacobs is out for Green Bay with a knee issue, which opens the door for Emanuel Wilson. Wilson looked decent in relief last week—11 carries for 40 yards isn't world-breaking, but in this economy, a starting RB getting 15+ touches is gold.
New England is also a weird one. Rhamondre Stevenson is technically questionable with a toe injury, but rookie TreVeyon Henderson has basically taken over the backfield. Henderson has put up 300 scrimmage yards and five touchdowns in just two weeks. Even if Stevenson plays, Henderson is the one you want in your lineup. He’s got that "it" factor right now.
Running Backs to Bench
Honestly, I’d be wary of Dak Prescott and the Dallas run game this week. They’re facing an Eagles defense that has been absolutely suffocating. Philly hasn't allowed a starting QB more than one touchdown in six straight games. If the passing game stalls, the rushing lanes for Javonte Williams or whoever is back there will disappear.
👉 See also: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
Also, watch out for Rico Dowdle in Carolina. He’s being outplayed by Chuba Hubbard, who finally looks healthy after that calf injury. Hubbard was way more efficient last week (5.3 yards per carry compared to Dowdle's 2.4). If you have both, Hubbard is the sneaky start.
Wide Receivers: Finding Value in the Targets
If you're asking who to start fantasy football week 12 at receiver, look at the volume. Michael Wilson in Arizona is the clear beneficiary of the Marvin Harrison Jr. absence. 15 catches on 18 targets last week? That’s insane. He’s a must-start against a Jacksonville secondary that can’t stop anyone.
Over in Seattle, Jaxon Smith-Njigba is finally becoming the WR1 we expected. With the Titans giving up huge chunks of yardage to outside receivers, JSN and even a deep threat like Rasheed Shaheed (if you're feeling spicy) have massive ceilings.
✨ Don't miss: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
Wide Receiver Matchups to Love
- Jameson Williams vs. NYG: He’s scored 16+ points in four of his last five. The Giants' secondary is vulnerable to deep threats.
- Tee Higgins vs. NE: With Ja'Marr Chase out on suspension, Higgins is the alpha. Christian Gonzalez is a tough matchup, but the target share will be too high to ignore.
- Darnell Mooney @ NO: No Michael Penix Jr. hurts, but Kirk Cousins is back under center. Mooney has a history of producing with Cousins, and with Drake London out, he's the only game in town.
Tight Ends: The Streaming Game
Tight end remains a wasteland, but there are some bright spots. Hunter Henry is the "Triple H" of streaming options this week. The Bengals have given up double-digit points to tight ends in eight straight games. It’s almost a statistical certainty he finds the end zone or at least gets 60 yards.
AJ Barner in Seattle is another name to watch. He saw 11 targets last week. Any tight end getting double-digit targets belongs on a roster, let alone in a starting lineup.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Week 12 Lineup
Don't let the "big names" bait you into a loss. To lock in your win, follow these specific steps before kickoff:
- Check the 11:30 AM ET Inactives: Specifically for Rhamondre Stevenson and Kenneth Walker. If they are out, Henderson and Charbonnet become immediate RB1/RB2 plays.
- Monitor the Weather in Nashville: Seattle @ Tennessee could get windy. If it does, pivot away from the deep-threat receivers and lean into the RB volume.
- Audit Your Bench for "Trap" Players: If you're still holding onto guys like Jordan Love or Kirk Cousins, ask yourself if their ceiling is higher than a red-hot Drake Maye or Jacoby Brissett. Often, the answer this week is no.
- Secure the Waiver Wire Sleepers: If Parker Washington or Mack Hollins are still available, grab them now. They are seeing WR1-level target shares due to injuries above them on the depth chart.
Success in Week 12 isn't about having the best players; it's about having the players who are actually healthy and playing against bad defenses. Good luck, and don't overthink the "name value" when the data is screaming at you to pivot.