You're sitting there with the 1.01. Your heart is racing a little, which is honestly kind of pathetic for a hobby involving spreadsheets, but here we are. You have roughly sixty seconds to decide who to draft 1st in fantasy football, and if you blow it, your buddies will bring it up in the group chat until 2028. It’s a lot of pressure. Usually, everyone just defaults to whatever the consensus "Expert Rank" says on the screen. Don’t do that.
Look, the 1.01 isn't just about picking the guy who will score the most points. It's about risk mitigation. You can't win your league in the first round, but you can absolutely lose it if your top pick ends up in a walking boot by Week 4. History is littered with "sure things" like 2023 Justin Jefferson or 2020 Christian McCaffrey who missed massive chunks of time.
Picking first is actually a burden. You grab your superstar, and then you sit there for forty-five minutes while everyone else snags the elite talent, leaving you to sift through the leftovers at the turn. If your first pick isn't a literal vacuum for touches and touchdowns, you’re playing from behind before the Sunday night kickoff even happens.
The Case for the Workhorse RB (If They Still Exist)
For a decade, the answer to who to draft 1st in fantasy football was always a running back. Simple. Easy. You wanted the guy getting 300 touches. But the NFL changed. Teams hate their RBs now. They rotate them like tires. However, Christian McCaffrey remains the exception that proves the rule.
When he’s healthy, CMC is basically a cheat code. In Kyle Shanahan’s offense, he isn't just a runner; he’s the primary safety valve and a red-zone nightmare. In 2023, he finished with over 2,000 yards from scrimmage and 21 total touchdowns. That is absurd. If you’re in a Half-PPR or Full-PPR league, his floor is so much higher than anyone else's because of the targets. Honestly, if you don't take him first, you better have a very specific reason why, or you're just overthinking it to look smart.
But there’s a catch. There's always a catch.
McCaffrey is getting older. In RB years, he’s basically a senior citizen. The "Age 28 Wall" is a real thing backed by decades of data from guys like Shaun Alexander and LaDainian Tomlinson. Once the wheels come off, they come off fast. If you’re terrified of a mid-season hamstring tweak, you might look elsewhere. Bijan Robinson is the name everyone whispers about in dark corners of the internet. With Arthur Smith gone and a competent quarterback in Atlanta, Bijan might finally get the "workhorse" usage we all expected last year. He’s younger, fresher, and arguably just as talented in space.
👉 See also: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
Is Wide Receiver Actually the Safer Bet?
Lately, the trend has shifted toward "Zero RB" or "Hero RB" builds. This makes sense. Receivers just don't get hit as hard or as often as guys running between the tackles. If you’re asking who to draft 1st in fantasy football and you want to sleep better at night, you look at Tyreek Hill or CeeDee Lamb.
Tyreek is a freak. There’s no other way to put it. Even at 30, his tracking data shows he hasn't lost a step of elite speed. Mike McDaniel finds ways to get him the ball in space that feel like they should be illegal. The floor is 110 catches. The ceiling is the first 2,000-yard receiving season in NFL history.
Then there’s CeeDee Lamb.
Last year, Lamb was a volume monster. Dak Prescott looked his way on nearly 30% of his dropbacks. That kind of market share is what fantasy dreams are made of. In a Full-PPR league, taking a high-volume WR at 1.01 isn't "playing it safe"—it's a tactical strike. You’re locking in 15-20 points a week regardless of the matchup. If the Cowboys' run game continues to look like a disaster, Lamb might see 180 targets. Think about that. 180 targets. That’s a lot of chances for something good to happen.
The Problem With Chasing Last Year's Points
We all do it. It’s human nature. We see the guy who won someone a championship last year and we assume he’ll do it again. But regression is a cruel mistress.
Take a look at the "Top 5" from any year. Rarely do more than two of them repeat that performance the following season. Injuries happen. Coordinators leave for head coaching jobs. Offensive lines crumble because a Pro Bowl left tackle decides he wants more money and holds out. When you decide who to draft 1st in fantasy football, you have to project forward, not look backward.
✨ Don't miss: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Justin Jefferson is the perfect example. He’s arguably the best pure receiver in the league. But who is throwing him the ball? If the QB play is erratic, Jefferson’s ceiling takes a hit. He’ll still be great, but will he be "Number One Overall" great? Maybe not. You’re paying for the absolute ceiling at the 1.01. If there’s any doubt about the environment around the player, you move to the next name on the list.
Strategy: The "Turn" is More Important Than the Pick
Here is something people rarely talk about. When you pick first, you aren't just picking one player. You are choosing a roster construction strategy for the rest of the draft.
Because you won’t pick again for an eternity (picks 24 and 25), you have to be aggressive. If you take a RB at the 1.01, you are almost forced to look at WR/WR at the turn to stay balanced. If you go WR first, you might find yourself staring at a group of "dead zone" running backs like Rachaad White or Isiah Pacheco when your turn finally comes back around.
- The CMC Build: You get the best player in the game, but you miss out on the Tier 1 wideouts. You'll be starting guys like Nico Collins or Jaylen Waddle as your WR1.
- The WR Build: You get a PPR god, but your RB1 might be a guy like Travis Etienne or Saquon Barkley. Is that a bad thing? Not necessarily.
- The "Reach" Build: Some people are taking Breece Hall first. It sounds crazy until you realize he was the RB2 last year while coming off an ACL tear on a team that had a literal disaster at quarterback. If Aaron Rodgers stays upright, Breece might actually be the smartest pick on the board.
The Psychological Trap of the 1.01
Honestly, the biggest mistake people make is trying to be too clever. They try to predict the "breakout" player of the year and take them at the top. Don't do that. The first pick is for the proven commodity. It’s for the guy with the massive touch floor.
I’ve seen people take Josh Allen first overall in 1-QB leagues. Please, for the love of all that is holy, do not do this. Quarterback is deep. You can get elite production from a guy three rounds later. When you're deciding who to draft 1st in fantasy football, you are looking for scarcity. There are only a handful of players who can legitimately give you 20+ points every single week. Most of them are RBs and WRs.
Real-World Nuance: Format Matters More Than You Think
If you're in a Standard league (no points for catches), Christian McCaffrey is the only answer. Period. The value of a yard and a touchdown is so much higher there that WRs just can't keep up.
🔗 Read more: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
In a Full-PPR league, the gap closes. A guy like Tyreek Hill catching 10 passes for 80 yards is 18 points before he even sniffs the end zone. That’s incredibly valuable. You have to know your scoring settings. If your league gives a "tight end premium" (1.5 points per catch), you might even see a lunatic take Travis Kelce or Sam LaPorta. It’s rare, but in those specific formats, it’s not entirely insane. Okay, it’s a little insane. But it’s a strategy.
Final Verdict on the Top Spot
So, who is it? If the draft started right now, the smart money is still on Christian McCaffrey. He’s the most versatile weapon in the most efficient offense in football. He’s the closest thing we have to a guaranteed 18-22 points per week.
However, if you have a "gut feeling" about CeeDee Lamb or Tyreek Hill, trust it. The statistical difference between the top three players is usually negligible by the end of December. The real goal of the first pick is to not draft a "bust."
Actionable Steps for Your Draft Day:
- Check the injury reports one last time: Do not be the person who drafts a guy with a "minor" calf strain that turns into a six-week ordeal.
- Mock draft from the 1st slot: Use a simulator to see what your team looks like at the Round 2/3 turn. If you hate your RBs when you go WR-first, that tells you everything you need to know.
- Ignore the "Expert" consensus if you have a conviction: If you truly believe Breece Hall is the next LaDainian Tomlinson, take him. It’s your team. You have to live with it for four months.
- Have a plan for the turn: Decide now if you are willing to take a high-end QB or TE at picks 24/25. If you take a RB at 1.01, getting a top-tier QB at the turn can give you a massive weekly advantage.
Deciding who to draft 1st in fantasy football is the start of the journey, not the end. Make your pick, live with it, and then get ready to work the waiver wire, because that’s where the real championships are won anyway.