Netflix essentially handed the keys of the holiday season to the internet’s favorite pop star, and she didn’t just open the door—she blew it off the hinges. When A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter hit the platform, it wasn't just another variety show. It felt like a fever dream curated by someone who understands exactly how to mix Gen Z camp with old-school variety show charm. Honestly, the cast of A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter is what makes the whole thing work. Without that specific blend of high-fashion irony and genuine musical talent, it might have just been another glossy corporate holiday special. Instead, we got something that feels a bit like a chaotic dinner party where everyone is incredibly talented and slightly unhinged.
The special works because it doesn't take itself too seriously. You have Sabrina, fresh off a year of absolute global dominance with "Espresso" and "Please Please Please," acting as the ringleader. But she isn’t alone. The cameos range from legendary icons to the newest faces of indie pop, creating a weirdly perfect cross-section of modern celebrity culture.
The Musical Heavyweights Joining Sabrina
The music is the backbone, obviously. You can't have a Sabrina Carpenter special without some seriously high-level vocals. Chappell Roan showing up was probably the moment that broke the internet. Their duet on "Please Please Please" (reimagined for the season) felt like a victory lap for the two women who arguably owned the summer of 2024. Chappell’s theatricality perfectly matches Sabrina’s deadpan humor. It wasn’t just a performance; it was a cultural "moment."
Then there’s Tyla. The South African star brings a completely different energy to the stage. While Sabrina leans into that 1960s Nancy Sinatra aesthetic, Tyla brings a sleek, modern R&B vibe that keeps the special from feeling too much like a retro parody. Their chemistry is effortless. It’s cool. It’s smooth. It makes you wish they had a full collaborative album.
We also have to talk about Shania Twain. Having the queen of "Man! I Feel Like a Woman!" involved is a massive flex. Shania represents the bridge between the classic variety shows of the 70s and 80s and what Sabrina is doing now. When they performed together, it wasn't just a passing of the torch—it was a full-on bonfire. Shania still has that magnetic presence that reminds you why she’s a legend.
The Comedic Chaos and Unexpected Cameos
Music is only half the story. The cast of A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter includes a roster of comedians and actors who handle the "nonsense" part of the title. Quinta Brunson is a standout. The Abbott Elementary creator has this incredible ability to play the "straight man" in a room full of absurdity. Her sketches with Sabrina are highlights because they feel improvised, even if they aren't.
And then there's Nico Hiraga. If you’ve seen him in Bottoms or Booksmart, you know he has this specific, laid-back energy that works so well against Sabrina’s high-energy persona. He’s basically the cool younger brother of the special.
👉 See also: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
- Cara Delevingne pops up, leaning into her more eccentric side.
- Kyle Mooney, formerly of SNL, brings that specific brand of awkward, lo-fi humor that he’s known for.
- Megan Stalter is, as always, a chaotic force of nature. If you aren't familiar with her work on Hacks, her performance here is a perfect introduction to her "confidently wrong" comedic style.
The inclusion of these specific names tells you a lot about Sabrina’s taste. She isn't just picking the biggest names for the sake of it. She’s picking people who "get" the joke.
Why This Specific Cast Works for 2024 and 2025
The variety show format used to be a staple of television, think Judy Garland or Sonny & Cher. For a long time, it felt dead. Corny. Outdated. But the cast of A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter revitalizes it by leaning into the irony. We live in an era of "post-irony," where we can love something while also acknowledging how silly it is.
Sabrina knows she’s a "Short n' Sweet" pop star playing a role. By bringing in someone like Kali Uchis, she adds a layer of dream-pop sophistication. When you mix Kali’s ethereal vocals with the campy, over-the-top sets, the whole thing starts to feel like a high-budget A24 film that happens to be about Christmas.
Actually, the guest list feels like a curated Instagram feed come to life. It’s aspirational but accessible. You’ve got the fashion world represented, the prestige TV world, and the top of the Billboard charts.
The Mystery of the Uncredited Faces
There are always those brief moments in these specials where a background dancer or a "blink-and-you'll-miss-it" cameo catches your eye. The production value on this special is massive. The dancers aren't just props; they are often high-level professionals who have toured with the likes of Beyoncé or Taylor Swift. While they might not be the "headliners," they are the ones doing the heavy lifting during the big "Nonsense" dance breaks.
The interplay between the scripted bits and the musical numbers is surprisingly tight. Often, these specials feel disjointed. Like a collection of music videos held together by Scotch tape. But the cast here feels like a cohesive unit. Even when Sean Astin shows up (yes, Samwise Gamgee himself), it somehow makes sense within the logic of the "Sabrina-verse."
✨ Don't miss: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Breaking Down the Visual Aesthetic
The cast isn't just about the people; it's about how they look. The styling for this special is a character in itself. Every guest is dressed in a way that feels like a nod to 1990s Chanel runway shows mixed with 1960s Playboy Club vibes, but modernized.
When you see the cast of A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter all together during the finale, it’s a masterclass in color theory. Pastels, faux fur, and enough sequins to be seen from space. It’s maximalism done right.
Sabrina’s own wardrobe changes are frequent and frantic. She moves from a Mrs. Claus-inspired outfit to something that looks like it was stolen from a 1920s flapper, and then into a modern streetwear-inspired holiday look. It keeps the viewer engaged because you never know what the next "act" is going to look like.
Was anyone missing?
Fans were arguably hoping for a few more of Sabrina's "inner circle" to appear. There were rumors about certain actors from her past or fellow Disney alums. But honestly? The special benefited from not being a nostalgia trip. By focusing on her current peers—the Tyla's and Chappell Roan's of the world—Sabrina solidified her place as the current "it girl." She doesn't need to look back because her present is so bright.
The Cultural Impact of the Guest List
This special will likely be looked back on as a time capsule. It captures a very specific moment in pop culture where the lines between "influencer," "actor," and "musician" have completely blurred.
Take Quinta Brunson. She started on Buzzfeed, moved to Instagram sketches, and now runs one of the most successful sitcoms on network TV. Her presence next to a pop star like Sabrina makes perfect sense in 2025. It’s all one big ecosystem now.
🔗 Read more: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
The audience for this isn't just the kids who grew up watching Girl Meets World. It’s also the fashion crowd, the comedy nerds, and the casual Netflix scroller who just wants something pretty to look at while they wrap presents.
How to Experience the "Nonsense" Yourself
If you haven't watched it yet, don't go in expecting a traditional Christmas story. There is no plot. There is no "lesson" learned at the end, other than perhaps that being a global pop star looks like a lot of fun if you have the right friends.
To get the most out of the cast of A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter, you should:
- Watch for the Background Details: Many of the funniest jokes are hidden in the set design or the brief reactions of the guests in the background of sketches.
- Listen to the Arrangements: The musical guests aren't just singing their radio hits. They’ve reworked these songs to fit the holiday theme, often with surprising results.
- Check the Credits: Seriously. Some of the writers and producers involved in this are the same people behind some of the best comedy specials of the last decade.
The takeaway here is pretty simple. Sabrina Carpenter is a mogul in the making. She has the "it" factor, sure, but she also has the taste to surround herself with people who elevate her brand. The cast isn't just a list of names; it's a statement of intent. She's here to stay, and she's bringing the coolest people in the industry along for the ride.
If you want to dive deeper into the specific performances, your next step should be heading over to Netflix to catch the "Nonsense" medley, which features some of the best choreography of the entire special. Then, check out the official soundtrack on Spotify, as several of the live duets have been released as high-quality studio versions that sound even better than the broadcast. This special isn't just a one-time watch; it's a blueprint for what modern entertainment looks like when you stop following the old rules.