It happened in a flash. One second, Malcolm X was standing behind a thin wooden podium at the Audubon Ballroom in Washington Heights, preparing to address his Organization of Afro-American Unity. The next, a calculated distraction broke out in the crowd—something about a man reaching for a pocket—and then the air filled with lead. He was dead before he hit the floor.
Honestly, if you ask the average person who shot Malcolm X, they might give you a name they remember from a history book, or maybe they’ll just say "the Nation of Islam." But the reality is a jagged, painful puzzle that took over fifty years to even begin to piece together correctly. It wasn't just one guy with a gun. It was a hit squad. And for decades, the wrong men sat in prison while the actual killers walked free in plain sight.
For years, the official story was neat. Three men—Talmadge Hayer (also known as Thomas Hagan), Norman 3X Butler, and Thomas 15X Johnson—were arrested, tried, and convicted. Case closed, right? Not even close. While Hayer was caught at the scene after being shot in the leg by Malcolm’s bodyguard, he spent years screaming from his prison cell that the other two guys had nothing to do with it. He even signed affidavits naming his actual accomplices. Nobody listened. The system just wanted it over.
The Men Who Didn't Do It
We have to talk about Muhammad Abdul Aziz and Khalil Islam. These were the men formerly known as Norman 3X Butler and Thomas 15X Johnson. They spent a combined 42 years behind bars for a crime they didn't commit. Imagine that. You’re at home, miles away from the ballroom, and suddenly you’re being hauled off for the most high-profile assassination of the decade.
The evidence against them was basically non-existent. No physical evidence tied them to the scene. Their alibis were solid. Aziz had a doctor's appointment for a leg injury; he literally couldn't have been sprinting through a ballroom. Yet, in the heat of 1965, with the NYPD and the FBI under immense pressure to find "the killers," these two Nation of Islam members were convenient scapegoats.
It wasn't until 2021—yes, you read that right, 2021—that their convictions were finally vacated. The late Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. admitted that the FBI and the NYPD withheld evidence that would have likely led to their acquittal. It’s a tragedy. Khalil Islam died in 2009, never seeing his name cleared. Aziz, at 83, finally got to hear a judge say the state was wrong.
💡 You might also like: Daniel Blank New Castle PA: The Tragic Story and the Name Confusion
The Newark Commandos: Who Actually Pulled the Trigger?
So, if Aziz and Islam were innocent, then who shot Malcolm X?
The hit was carried out by a five-man team from the Nation of Islam’s Newark mosque. This wasn't a random act of violence. It was a military-style operation. Talmadge Hayer was the only one caught at the scene, but he eventually named his co-conspirators: William Bradley, Leon Davis, Thomas Moore, and Wilbur McKinley.
The most significant name there is William Bradley.
Bradley was the man with the sawed-off shotgun. In the chaos of the ballroom, he was the one who fired the fatal blast into Malcolm’s chest. After the shooting, he didn't just disappear into the shadows; he lived a very public life in Newark. He was a well-known figure in the community. He even appeared in a campaign commercial for a local politician. Everyone in the neighborhood seemingly knew he was the "shotgun man," yet he was never charged. He died in 2018, taking his full story to the grave, though the 2020 Netflix documentary Who Killed Malcolm X? did a lot of the heavy lifting in exposing his identity to the wider world.
The Role of the FBI and NYPD
You can't talk about the killers without talking about the people who let it happen. The FBI’s COINTELPRO (Counterintelligence Program) was working overtime to "prevent the rise of a 'messiah' who could unify and electrify the militant Black nationalist movement." Those are J. Edgar Hoover’s own words.
📖 Related: Clayton County News: What Most People Get Wrong About the Gateway to the World
The police presence at the Audubon Ballroom on February 21, 1965, was strangely light. Malcolm had survived a firebombing of his house just a week prior. He was a marked man. Usually, there would be a significant NYPD presence at his events, but that day? Almost nobody.
Furthermore, we now know there were at least nine undercover police officers and informants in the room that day. Gene Roberts, one of Malcolm’s own security guards, was actually an undercover NYPD officer. He was the one seen giving Malcolm mouth-to-mouth resuscitation in the famous photos. The government was watching in real-time. They didn't pull the trigger, but they certainly created the environment where the trigger could be pulled, and then they stayed silent while innocent men went to jail.
Why the Nation of Islam Targeted Him
The tension between Malcolm X and the Nation of Islam (NOI) had reached a boiling point by 1964. It wasn't just a "religious split." It was deeply personal. Malcolm had discovered that his mentor, Elijah Muhammad, had fathered several children with young secretaries within the movement. For Malcolm, who lived by a strict moral code, this was a devastating betrayal.
When Malcolm went public with these accusations, he became a "dead man walking." The NOI’s newspaper, Muhammad Speaks, published cartoons of Malcolm’s head rolling in the street. Louis Farrakhan, then known as Louis X, wrote that "such a man as Malcolm is worthy of death."
While the men who pulled the triggers were from the Newark mosque, the orders—or at least the permission—came from the top. It was an internal execution fueled by external manipulation from federal agencies who wanted to see the Black nationalist movement tear itself apart.
👉 See also: Charlie Kirk Shooting Investigation: What Really Happened at UVU
The Evidence That Was Ignored
Why did it take 56 years to clear the names of the innocent? Because the truth was inconvenient.
- The Shotgun Shells: The ballistics didn't match the handguns the police focused on initially.
- The Hayer Affidavits: In 1977 and 1978, Talmadge Hayer gave detailed accounts naming the Newark crew. The courts rejected the motion to reopen the case, claiming the information wasn't "new."
- The Witness Statements: Several witnesses described a man who looked exactly like William Bradley, not the men the police had in custody.
- The FBI Files: Thousands of pages of documents were classified for decades. When they were finally unsealed, they showed that the FBI knew within days that the Newark mosque was responsible, yet they did nothing to correct the record for Aziz and Islam.
It’s a haunting reminder of how the legal system can be used as a weapon of convenience rather than a tool for justice.
The Legacy of the Investigation
The assassination of Malcolm X changed the course of American history. If he had lived, his work with the OAAU might have bridged the gap between the civil rights movement in the South and the more militant movements in the North. We’ll never know.
But what we do know now is that the quest to find out who shot Malcolm X is as much about government complicity as it is about the triggermen. The exoneration of Muhammad Abdul Aziz and Khalil Islam in 2021 wasn't just a legal formality; it was a confession by the state that they had knowingly participated in a cover-up.
Actionable Steps for Understanding the Case
If you want to go deeper into the facts of this case and avoid the many myths surrounding it, there are specific resources and steps you should take. The history is still being written as more documents are declassified.
- Read "The Autobiography of Malcolm X" carefully: Pay attention to the final chapters where he describes his feeling of being watched by both "the Muslims" and "the state." It sets the psychological stage for the ballroom.
- Consult the Manning Marable Biography: Malcolm X: A Life of Reinvention is the definitive scholarly text. Marable spent years tracking down the Newark connection long before it became mainstream news.
- Watch the 2020 Documentary: Search for Who Killed Malcolm X? on Netflix. This series follows the work of investigative historian Abdur-Rahman Muhammad, whose relentless legwork actually forced the Manhattan DA's office to reopen the case.
- Review the Vacated Conviction Documents: You can find the summary of the 2021 legal filings online. They outline exactly which pieces of evidence the FBI and NYPD hid, providing a masterclass in how institutional bias functions.
- Examine the COINTELPRO Files: The National Security Archive has digitized many of the FBI's memos regarding Malcolm X. Reading the raw intelligence reports gives you a chilling look at how the government viewed his "threat level."
The story of Malcolm X’s death is no longer just a "whodunnit." It is a documented account of a multi-layered conspiracy involving local hitmen, religious rivalry, and federal interference. Understanding the players involved is the only way to honor the actual history of the man who died on that stage.
To fully grasp the scope of this, look into the civil settlement reached in 2022. The city and state of New York agreed to pay $36 million to the families of the two exonerated men. That figure alone tells you everything you need to know about the scale of the "error" the government made. Justice in this case didn't come from the system working; it came from decades of outsiders refusing to accept a lie.