If you’ve spent any time in the more chaotic corners of the Nintendo fandom, you know things get weird fast. We aren't just talking about speedruns or "bowsette" fan art anymore. Lately, there’s this obsession with a specific, gritty narrative: who ratted out luigi? It sounds like something straight out of The Godfather or Goodfellas, and honestly, the way the internet has run with it, it basically is. But where did this idea of a "rat" even come from? Luigi is a plumber who fights ghosts and rescues princesses. He isn't exactly a high-ranking lieutenant in the Gambino family. Or is he?
The whole "Mafia Luigi" thing isn't just some random fever dream. It’s rooted in decades of subtle character design, some very specific voice acting choices, and a mountain of memes that grew into a genuine piece of internet folklore. When people ask who ratted out luigi, they’re usually looking for the lore behind the "Death Stare" or the various fan-made parodies that reimagine the Mushroom Kingdom as a gritty, crime-ridden underworld.
The Origins of the Luigi Mobster Myth
Luigi has always been the underdog. He’s taller, thinner, and perpetually nervous. In the early days of the NES, he was just a palette swap. But as the consoles got better, his personality got weirder. By the time we hit the GameCube era with Luigi’s Mansion, he was established as the "cowardly" brother.
Then came Mario Kart 8.
When that game dropped on the Wii U, everything changed. Players noticed that when Luigi passed an opponent, his face didn't show the usual "wa-hoo!" joy. He looked cold. He looked vengeful. He looked like a man who had seen too much and was ready to settle a debt. This became the "Luigi Death Stare." It went viral. Suddenly, Luigi wasn't just the scaredy-cat; he was a silent assassin. This shift in perception is why the question of who ratted out luigi started gaining traction in forums. If Luigi is a cold-blooded enforcer, someone must have betrayed him to make him this way.
Was it Mario? The Case for Brotherly Betrayal
In most "mob" versions of this story, the finger points at the big guy in red. It makes sense if you think about it. Mario gets the fame. Mario gets the girl. Mario gets the "Super" title while Luigi is just... Luigi.
There’s a specific clip from Mario Power Tennis on the GameCube that fans always cite as evidence of their fractured relationship. During the trophy ceremony, if Luigi wins, Mario comes up to "congratulate" him but ends up stepping on his foot and grinding his heel down. Mario’s face is smiling, but the action is pure malice. People who dig into the lore of who ratted out luigi often point to this as the moment the resentment became real. In a crime syndicate context, Mario is the boss who keeps his more talented brother under his thumb to prevent a coup. If anyone ratted Luigi out to the "authorities" (maybe Bowser’s Koopa Troop or the Mushroom Kingdom Police), it would be the guy who stood the most to gain from Luigi being sidelined.
👉 See also: Little Big Planet Still Feels Like a Fever Dream 18 Years Later
The Role of the Toads and the Mushroom Kingdom Underground
You can't talk about a snitch without looking at the informants. In the games, Toads are everywhere. They’re "loyal" servants of Princess Peach, but they’re also kind of incompetent and seemingly terrified of everything.
In the fan-narrative of who ratted out luigi, the Toads represent the civilian population that knows too much. Some theorists suggest a specific "Toad" snitched to Bowser about Luigi’s whereabouts during the events of Luigi's Mansion. Think about it: Bowser always knows exactly where the brothers are. How? You don't just "find" a guy in a haunted mansion by accident. Someone talked. Someone told the King of the Koopas that the green one was vulnerable.
Examining the Fan-Made "L-Is-Real" Lore
We have to mention the "L is Real 2401" mystery from Super Mario 64. For years, kids stared at that blurry statue in the castle courtyard, convinced it was a sign that Luigi was in the game. When the 2020 Nintendo "Gigaleak" happened, we found out he was actually in the source code. He was cut.
This felt like a betrayal to the fanbase. In the meta-narrative of who ratted out luigi, Nintendo itself is the snitch. They took him out of his brother's greatest adventure. They buried the evidence. The "rat" isn't a character; it’s the developers who kept Luigi in the shadows for years while Mario took the spotlight. This meta-commentary is a huge part of why the "mobster Luigi" meme has so much staying power. It’s a way for fans to reclaim a character that felt "betrayed" by his creators.
The "Family" Business: Daisy and the Mob Wife Trope
Then there’s Princess Daisy. If Luigi is the "Godfather," Daisy is the ride-or-die who knows where the bodies are buried. In the fan theories surrounding who ratted out luigi, Daisy is often the only one he can trust. Or, in the darker versions, she's the femme fatale who leads him into a trap.
Think about their dynamic in Mario Kart. They’re a powerhouse duo. But in the world of organized crime tropes, the person closest to you is usually the one who delivers the "kiss of death." While there’s no official game where Daisy betrays Luigi, the fan fiction and "Mushroom Mafia" art often depict a world where their romance is complicated by shifting loyalties. If you're looking for a specific name of who ratted him out, Daisy is the "prestige" answer—the twist ending nobody saw coming.
✨ Don't miss: Why the 20 Questions Card Game Still Wins in a World of Screens
Real-World Influence: The Italian-American Connection
It’s impossible to ignore the cultural stereotypes at play here. The Mario brothers are Italian-American plumbers from Brooklyn. That’s their origin story from the 1989 Super Mario Bros. Super Show. By default, pop culture tends to mash those origins with the most famous Italian-American cinematic genre: the Mob Movie.
When people ask who ratted out luigi, they are subconsciously leaning into the tropes established by The Sopranos or Casino. They want to know who wore the wire. They want to know who met with the feds. In the Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023), we see a bit more of their family life in Brooklyn. We see them being picked on by Spike, their former boss.
Wrecking Crew’s Spike: The Original Snitch?
If we're looking for an actual character with a motive, Foreman Spike is a prime candidate. Appearing in the 1985 game Wrecking Crew, Spike is a rival who actively tries to sabotage the brothers' work. In the movie, he’s a bully who mocks their business. If anyone was going to go to the authorities—or the rival plumbing unions—to "rat" on Luigi for some shady business dealings, it’s Spike. He’s the classic small-time hood who resents the brothers' success.
Why This Meme Won't Die
The "who ratted out luigi" question persists because it’s funny. It’s the juxtaposition of a bright, colorful kids' game with the dark, gritty reality of a crime syndicate. It’s the "Luigi Death Stare" taken to its logical conclusion.
But it’s also about character depth. Mario is a bit of a blank slate—he’s the hero because the script says so. Luigi has layers. He has fear, he has anxiety, and he has a clear "breaking point." When we imagine him being betrayed, we’re engaging with a version of the character that feels more human than the one who just jumps on Goombas.
The Evidence in the "Gigaleak"
When the Nintendo internal files leaked a few years ago, it was like the "Pentagon Papers" for gamers. We saw early models of Luigi that were even more disheveled than his final versions. This "lost history" gave more fuel to the fire. People started joking that Luigi was "erased" from the original Mario 64 because he knew too much. In this version of the story, who ratted out luigi was simply the corporate machine.
🔗 Read more: FC 26 Web App: How to Master the Market Before the Game Even Launches
Sorting Fact from Fiction
Let's be clear: Nintendo is never going to release a game titled Mario Kart: The Snitch. They are a family-friendly company that guards their IP with a level of ferocity that would make a mob boss blush.
- Fact: Luigi has a "Death Stare" in Mario Kart 8.
- Fact: Mario has been shown to be a bit of a jerk to Luigi in various sports spin-offs.
- Fact: Foreman Spike is a canonical rival who dislikes the brothers.
- Fiction: There is an official storyline involving Luigi being "ratted out" to a crime syndicate.
Actionable Insights for the Curious Fan
If you're deep down this rabbit hole, you don't have to stop at memes. There are ways to actually explore this "darker" side of the Mushroom Kingdom through official media and high-quality fan projects.
1. Revisit the "Wario" Connection
Wario is the literal antithesis of Mario. If you want to see what happens when the "plumber" archetype goes full greed, look at the Wario Land series. While Wario hasn't officially "ratted" on Luigi, their rivalry is built on the kind of spite that fuels a mob war.
2. Watch the 2023 Movie with a New Lens
Pay attention to the scenes in Brooklyn. Look at the background characters. The movie leans heavily into the 1980s NYC vibe. You can see the seeds of the "tough guy" personas that fans have built up over the years.
3. Check out "The SMB Movie" (1993)
If you want truly gritty, weird, and borderline nonsensical "crime" vibes, the live-action movie from the 90s is a masterpiece of "what were they thinking?" It’s set in Dinohattan, a literal dystopia. Luigi is a main character here, and the betrayal themes are rampant throughout the city’s underground.
4. Support Fan Animators
Creators on YouTube and Newgrounds have been making "Mafia Mario" parodies for decades. Some of them are surprisingly well-written and explore the "who ratted out luigi" concept with more depth than any official game ever could.
In the end, the person who "ratted out" Luigi is whoever you want it to be. That's the beauty of internet lore. It's a collaborative story we’re all writing together. Whether it was a jealous brother, a disgruntled Foreman Spike, or a shady Toad in a back alley, Luigi’s "betrayal" is just another chapter in the weirdest, most enduring mythology in gaming history. He might be the one getting ratted out, but with that death stare, he’s clearly the one who’s going to have the last laugh. Or at least the last "Mamma Mia."
Next Steps for Deep Lore Hunters:
To get the full picture of Luigi's "criminal" evolution, your best bet is to track down the original Mario Kart 8 replay footage from 2014. Look for the "Luigi Death Stare" compilations—it's the primary source for the entire "tough guy" persona. After that, look into the Foreman Spike lore in the Super Mario Bros. Movie and compare it to his original 1985 sprites in Wrecking Crew. You'll see exactly how Nintendo has slowly started embracing the idea that Luigi's world is a lot tougher than it looks on the surface.