If you’ve spent any time binge-watching the Scranton crew, you’ve probably felt a weird mix of pity and annoyance for the guy in the annex. He’s the "sad sack" of Dunder Mifflin. The man who Michael Scott famously claimed was "everything that is wrong with the paper business." But who plays Toby in The Office, and how did a guy with zero acting experience end up becoming one of the most iconic "punching bag" characters in television history?
The man behind the beige polyester is Paul Lieberstein.
He isn’t just some actor who showed up for an audition. Honestly, he never even wanted to be on camera. Paul was actually one of the lead writers and producers for the show. His journey from the writers' room to being the most hated man in HR is kind of a fluke—one of those "happy accidents" that turned into comedy gold.
The Writer Who Accidentally Became Toby Flenderson
It’s pretty wild to think about, but Paul Lieberstein was a behind-the-scenes guy through and through. Before The Office, he was writing for shows like King of the Hill and The Bernie Mac Show. When the American version of The Office started, Greg Daniels (the show’s creator) had this experimental idea: he wanted some of the writers to also play minor characters.
The logic was simple. If the writers were in the scenes, they’d get a better "feel" for the rhythm of the show.
Paul’s first appearance was supposed to be a one-off. Just a tiny blip. In the episode "Diversity Day," he has a single line where he tries to join Michael’s meeting, and Michael immediately kicks him out. That was it. But then, the president of NBC at the time saw the footage. He reportedly said, "That red-haired guy is terrific, we should see more of him."
💡 You might also like: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
And just like that, Toby Flenderson was born.
Paul was actually terrified. He’s a naturally shy guy—sorta the opposite of the "thespian" type. He even went to the other actors, including Steve Carell, and asked for advice on how to actually act. Carell told him something like, "Just don't do anything. Barely move your lips." That deadpan, defeated energy became Toby’s entire brand.
Why Michael Scott Actually Hated Him (The Birthday Card Incident)
One of the biggest mysteries for fans is why Michael’s hatred for Toby is so... visceral. It’s not just a professional rivalry; it’s a deep, soul-level loathing.
Interestingly, a lot of that came from a real moment on set. During a season 1 scene (that actually ended up being deleted), Toby was supposed to sign a birthday card for Meredith. Paul Lieberstein took a long time to write his message. He was just being methodical, but Steve Carell, staying in character as Michael, sat there watching him with growing, genuine annoyance.
Carell later told Paul that in those few seconds of watching him slowly write in a card, he decided that Michael just hated this man.
📖 Related: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
It wasn’t scripted to be that intense. It just happened. From that point on, every time Toby tried to be a "voice of reason," Michael saw it as an attack on fun itself. Since Toby worked for HR, he technically reported to corporate, meaning Michael couldn't fire him. That powerlessness is what fueled those legendary outbursts, like the "NO! GOD! NO!" scream when Toby returns from Costa Rica.
Paul Lieberstein’s Massive Influence Behind the Scenes
While Toby was getting bullied on screen, Paul Lieberstein was actually one of the most powerful people on the set.
- Showrunner: From Season 5 to Season 8, Paul was actually the showrunner. That means he was the "boss" of the whole production while his character was being treated like dirt.
- Director: He directed some of the show’s best episodes, including "Money" and "Gossip."
- The Annex Secret: Have you ever noticed why Toby, Ryan (B.J. Novak), and Kelly (Mindy Kaling) are all tucked away in the "Annex"? It wasn’t just a weird office layout. It’s because all three of those actors were also full-time writers. Placing them in the annex meant they didn’t have to be in the background of every single scene in the main office, which gave them more time to actually write the scripts.
It’s a funny dynamic. You have this guy who is essentially the "architect" of the show’s success, yet he’s playing a character whose biggest achievement is losing a trial as a juror for the Scranton Strangler.
Life After Dunder Mifflin
What happened to Paul after the cameras stopped rolling in 2013?
He didn't exactly go the "leading man" route, which makes sense given his personality. He’s stayed busy, mostly in the writer/producer chair. He worked on The Newsroom and later created a show called Ghosted with Craig Robinson (Darryl from The Office). He also directed a movie called Song of Back and Neck, which is a very "Toby-esque" dark comedy about a guy with chronic back pain.
👉 See also: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
In 2025 and 2026, you might have even seen him popping up in commercials, occasionally leaning into that "bumbling HR guy" persona because, let’s be honest, he’s just too good at it.
Lessons from the Man Who Played Toby
If you're a fan of the show, knowing that Paul Lieberstein was actually a high-level executive makes re-watching the series a lot more fun. You realize that every time Michael calls him an "evil snail," the man receiving the insult is actually the one who probably approved the joke in the first place.
What you can do next:
- Watch the "Office Ladies" podcast: Jenna Fischer (Pam) and Angela Kinsey (Angela) have a great episode where they interview Paul. He goes deep into how much he hated being in the "hot seat" for the more cringey Toby moments.
- Look for the "Annex" clues: Next time you watch, notice how often Toby is missing from big group scenes. It’s a fun game to spot when the "writer" had to go back to his real desk.
- Check out his directorial work: If you want to see his "real" talent, watch the episode "Money" (Season 4). It’s widely considered one of the best-directed episodes of the series.
Toby might be the "worst," but Paul Lieberstein is arguably one of the most important reasons The Office worked as well as it did. He turned a background extra into a cultural icon of corporate misery.