When you think of Jessie the Yodeling Cowgirl, you probably hear that high-energy, slightly frantic, but deeply soulful voice in your head immediately. It’s iconic. But if you’ve ever sat through the credits of Toy Story 2, 3, or 4, you might have noticed that the answer to who plays Jessie from Toy Story isn’t just one person. It’s a tag-team effort that has stayed remarkably consistent for over twenty-five years.
The primary voice—the one doing the fast-talking, the "Yee-haws," and the emotional heavy lifting—is Joan Cusack.
She’s the heart of the character. But here’s where it gets interesting: Cusack doesn’t do the singing, and she doesn't do the voice for every single video game or theme park attraction. The world of Pixar casting is way more layered than most people realize. It’s a blend of A-list Hollywood talent and specialized session performers who keep the magic alive when the big stars are busy on other film sets.
Joan Cusack: The Emotional Core of the Cowgirl
Joan Cusack was a stroke of genius casting by Pixar. Before Toy Story 2 dropped in 1999, she was already a massive deal, known for Working Girl and In & Out. She brought this specific kind of frantic, vulnerable energy that Jessie needed. Remember, Jessie isn't just a "spunky sidekick." She’s a toy with severe abandonment issues and claustrophobia.
Cusack’s voice cracks at just the right moments. When she’s talking about Emily—her original kid—you can hear the decades of heartbreak in her tone. It’s not just "cartoon acting." It’s a legitimate dramatic performance that happens to be wrapped in a plastic cowgirl hat.
Interestingly, Joan wasn't the first choice for every female role in the franchise, but once she stepped into the recording booth for Jessie, the character was rewritten to match her manic-yet-lovable cadence. She has returned for every major theatrical release and the TV specials like Toy Story of Terror!. Without her, the character loses that jittery, high-octane personality that makes her the perfect foil to Woody’s often uptight leadership.
The Secret Behind the Singing: Mary Kay Bergman and Sarah McLachlan
Wait. If Joan Cusack is the voice, who is doing that incredible yodeling?
👉 See also: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
That’s where things get technical. Joan Cusack, by her own admission, isn't much of a yodeler. For the actual yodeling calls you hear when Jessie is doing stunts or celebrating, Pixar brought in Mary Kay Bergman.
Bergman was a legendary voice actress—honestly, a titan in the industry. She voiced almost all the female characters in the early seasons of South Park and was the go-to for Disney character voices for years. Sadly, she passed away shortly around the time Toy Story 2 was released, making her performance as Jessie's "yodeling voice" one of her final contributions to film.
Then there’s "When She Loved Me."
You know the song. It’s the one that makes grown adults weep in the middle of a movie theater. While Jessie is the one "singing" it in the context of the story, the vocals actually belong to Sarah McLachlan. Pixar director John Lasseter specifically wanted a voice that sounded like a pure, melancholic memory. McLachlan’s breathy, haunting delivery turned that sequence into one of the most famous moments in animation history. So, technically, three different women collaborated to create the Jessie we met in 1999.
Why the Voice Sometimes Changes in Games and Toys
Have you ever bought a Jessie doll or played a Toy Story spinoff game and thought, "That sounds almost like her, but something is off?"
You aren't crazy.
✨ Don't miss: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
When it comes to the "peripheral" media—think Disney Parks shows, certain Mattel toys, or the Disney Infinity video games—Kat Cressida often steps into the boots. Cressida is a prolific voice over artist who has mastered the "Sound-Alike" art form.
Big stars like Joan Cusack are expensive and usually have "right of first refusal" in their contracts, but they rarely have the time to record 5,000 lines of dialogue for a mobile game or a talking pull-string toy. Cressida is so good at mimicking Cusack’s specific pitch and energy that most kids (and honestly, most parents) can't tell the difference. This is a standard practice in Hollywood; Tom Hanks’ brother, Jim Hanks, often voices Woody for toys and games for the exact same reason.
The Impact of Jessie on the Pixar Universe
Jessie changed the "boys' club" dynamic of the original Toy Story. Before she arrived, the female representation was basically Bo Peep (who stayed in the house) and Mrs. Potato Head. Jessie brought chaos. She brought athleticism. She brought a backstory that was actually darker and more complex than Woody’s.
The casting of Joan Cusack was pivotal because it prevented Jessie from becoming a stereotype. A lesser actress might have played her as a "tough girl" and left it at that. Cusack played her as a survivor.
The nuance in the performance is what allowed Jessie to move from a newcomer in the second film to a literal leader by the end of Toy Story 4. When Buzz Lightyear falls for her, it’s not because she’s a "damsel"—it’s because she’s the most vibrant person in the room. That energy is 100% a result of the vocal performance.
Tracking the Credits: A Quick Reference
If you are looking for a specific era or version of Jessie, here is the breakdown of who was behind the mic:
🔗 Read more: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
- The Main Movies (1, 2, 3, 4): Joan Cusack (Voice), Mary Kay Bergman (Yodeling in TS2), Sarah McLachlan (Singing voice in TS2).
- Television Specials (Toy Story of Terror, Toy Story That Time Forgot): Joan Cusack.
- Disney Parks and Attractions: Kat Cressida.
- Video Games (Disney Infinity, Kingdom Hearts III): Kat Cressida.
- Small Fry (Short Film): Joan Cusack.
It’s a massive team effort to keep a character sounding the same for nearly three decades.
Beyond the Voice: The Physicality of Jessie
While we focus on the voice when asking who plays Jessie, we shouldn't ignore the animators. The "performance" is also a result of the lead animators at Pixar who studied Joan Cusack’s recording sessions. They watched how her mouth moved and how she gestured with her hands while she was yelling into the microphone.
They took those real-life quirks and put them into the character’s "rig." When Jessie pulls her hat down or tucks her hair, those are often movements inspired by the voice actress herself. It’s a symbiotic relationship between the woman in the booth and the artist at the computer.
Identifying the "Authentic" Jessie
Next time you watch the movies, listen for the "Cusack Crack." It’s that little break in her voice when she gets excited. That’s the easiest way to tell you’re listening to the original performer. In the fourth movie especially, Jessie takes on a more grounded, mature tone as she prepares to inherit Woody’s badge.
The legacy of the character is safe. Whether it’s Joan leading the way in the features or Kat Cressida filling in for the games, the "Jessie" brand is one of the most carefully guarded assets in the Disney/Pixar portfolio.
Actionable Steps for Fans and Collectors
If you're looking to dive deeper into the world of Pixar's voice acting or want to ensure you're getting "authentic" Jessie content, here is how to navigate it:
- Check the Credits on Toys: If you are a collector looking for the actual voice of Joan Cusack in a toy, look for the "Signature Collection" released by Thinkway Toys. These used actual movie dialogue rather than sound-alike recordings.
- Watch the Behind-the-Scenes: The Blu-ray sets for Toy Story 2 and Toy Story 3 contain "In the Booth" features. Watching Joan Cusack record her lines is a masterclass in voice acting; she’s often moving as much as the character is.
- Follow the Voice Actors: Performers like Kat Cressida are often very active in the fan community and share insights into what it’s like to maintain the legacy of such a massive character.
- Listen to the Soundtrack: To truly appreciate the "three-person" approach to the character, listen to the Toy Story 2 soundtrack. You can clearly hear the transition between the speaking voice, the yodeling, and the singing—it’s a fascinating bit of audio engineering.
The character of Jessie remains a pillar of modern animation because she feels real. She’s loud, she’s scared, she’s brave, and she’s loyal. Knowing the voices behind the doll only makes the performance more impressive. It’s not just one person; it’s a decades-long collaboration designed to make sure that whenever Jessie yells "Yee-haw," it sounds exactly like home.