When Tim Burton first started scouting for his "bio-exorcist" back in the late 80s, he didn't exactly have a clear blueprint. He just knew he needed someone who could vibrate with a sort of dangerous, chaotic energy. He found that in Michael Keaton. If you’re asking who plays Beetlejuice in the movie, the answer is almost always Michael Keaton, but the story of how he claimed that moldy, striped suit is way more interesting than just a name on a casting call. He didn't just play the role; he basically invented the guy from scratch.
Keaton is the heartbeat of the franchise. It’s wild to think about now, but he’s actually only on screen for about 17 minutes in the original 1988 film. Only 17 minutes! Yet, he owns the entire legacy. When fans talk about who plays Beetlejuice in the movie, they aren't just talking about an actor reading lines. They’re talking about the guy who decided the character should have mold on his face and hair that looks like it was electrified by a car battery.
The Michael Keaton Era and the Birth of a Ghost
In 1988, Michael Keaton was mostly known for comedies like Mr. Mom. Nobody expected him to turn into a gravel-voiced, lecherous ghoul from the Netherworld. Burton reportedly gave Keaton a lot of freedom, and Keaton ran with it. He spent weeks working with makeup artist Ve Neill to get the look just right. He wanted the character to look like he’d "crawled out from under a rock," which explains the mossy skin and the stained teeth.
It’s a masterclass in physical acting. Keaton uses his entire body to convey that Beetlejuice (or Betelgeuse, if we’re being technical about the star) is barely contained within his own skin. He’s twitchy. He’s gross. He’s hilarious. This performance is why, even decades later, the question of who plays Beetlejuice in the movie usually starts and ends with him. He returned for the 2024 sequel, Beetlejuice Beetlejuice, proving that even at 70-plus years old, he could still bring that same manic, "Juice is loose" energy without missing a beat.
Wait, Is There Anyone Else?
While Keaton is the definitive cinematic version, he isn't the only person to ever put on the stripes. This is where things get a bit more nuanced for the hardcore fans. If you’re looking at the broader "movie" universe, including spin-offs and stage versions that feel like movies, the list grows a little.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
- Alex Brightman: If you’re lucky enough to have seen the Broadway musical, you know Brightman. He’s the one who took over the mantle for the stage. He didn't try to do a Keaton impression. Instead, he developed a scratchy, "growl-voice" that sounded like he’d been eating gravel for breakfast. It was a massive hit and earned him a Tony nomination.
- Stephen Ouimette: For a whole generation of 90s kids, this is the voice of Beetlejuice. He played the character in the animated series. In that version, Beetlejuice was more of a prankster best friend to Lydia rather than a terrifying creep trying to marry a teenager.
- Will Blum: Another Broadway powerhouse who stepped into the shoes (and the makeup) when Brightman was away.
Honestly, it’s a heavy burden to play this role. You’re competing with a legendary performance. Most actors who try it end up leaning too hard into the "wacky" and lose the "menace" that Keaton balanced so perfectly.
Why the Casting Was Almost Very Different
Believe it or not, Michael Keaton wasn't the first choice. Can you imagine Sammy Davis Jr. as Beetlejuice? Because Tim Burton could. Burton initially wanted the Rat Pack legend for the role, envisioning a more "Vegas lounge act" vibe for the character. It sounds crazy now, but that’s the beauty of early production—nothing is set in stone.
The producers also considered Dudley Moore. Yeah, the guy from Arthur. Thankfully, that didn't happen. When Burton eventually met with Keaton, the actor initially turned the role down. He didn't "get" the script. It was too weird, too non-linear. It took a few meetings and a lot of trust for Keaton to finally say yes and start building the character’s iconic wardrobe and mannerisms.
The 2024 Return: Why It Had to Be Keaton
When Warner Bros. finally greenlit the sequel, Beetlejuice Beetlejuice, there was no debate about who plays Beetlejuice in the movie. It had to be Michael Keaton. Recasting would have been a death sentence for the film. Fans have a specific emotional connection to Keaton’s portrayal; it’s a mix of nostalgia and genuine appreciation for his craft.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
In the sequel, Keaton steps back into the role alongside Winona Ryder (Lydia Deetz) and Catherine O'Hara (Delia Deetz). The movie explores the afterlife decades later, but the character of Beetlejuice hasn't changed a bit. He’s still stuck in the bureaucracy of the Neitherworld, still obsessed with Lydia, and still causing absolute mayhem. The fact that Keaton could slide back into that persona after 36 years is a testament to how much of himself he put into the original creation.
Behind the Makeup: The Physical Toll
Playing Beetlejuice isn't just about yelling and jumping around. It’s an endurance test. Back in '88, the makeup process took hours every single morning. They used foam latex appliances that were glued to Keaton’s face. It’s itchy, it’s hot, and it’s incredibly restrictive.
Keaton has mentioned in interviews that the hardest part isn't the makeup—it’s the vocal strain. That specific, gravelly rasp isn't his natural voice. It requires a lot of diaphragm control to keep that sound going for a full day of shooting without blowing out his vocal cords. When you ask who plays Beetlejuice in the movie, you have to respect the physical labor involved. It’s a dirty, sweaty, exhausting job.
What to Look for in a Beetlejuice Performance
If you’re watching the films or even a local theater production, there are a few "Keaton-isms" that define the character.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
- The Eye Bulge: Keaton has this way of making his eyes look twice their size when he’s excited or angry.
- The "Sandworm" Walk: A sort of hunched-over, predatory shuffle.
- The Rapid-Fire Delivery: Beetlejuice talks like a used car salesman on ten cups of espresso.
Whoever takes on the role in the future—and eventually, someone will likely try to reboot it again—will have to decide whether to mimic these traits or invent new ones. Most fail because they try to do a "Michael Keaton impression" instead of playing the character.
Breaking Down the Legacy
The reason we still care about who plays Beetlejuice in the movie is that the character represents something rare in cinema: a pure, unadulterated anarchist. He doesn't have a complex backstory or a "tragic" reason for being the way he is. He’s just a chaos demon.
In the original film, he was a side character who stole the show. In the sequel, he’s a legacy icon. We’ve seen other actors try to capture this kind of "lightning in a bottle"—think Jim Carrey in The Mask or Johnny Depp in Pirates of the Caribbean. But there’s a grit to Keaton’s Beetlejuice that feels more authentic. He’s not "Disney" weird; he’s "disturbing" weird.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
If you want to dive deeper into the world of the "Ghost with the Most," here is how you can truly appreciate the performance:
- Watch the Original with Commentary: If you can find the special features, listen to how Burton and Keaton talk about the improvisation on set. A lot of the best lines were ad-libbed by Keaton.
- Compare the 1988 and 2024 Versions: Pay attention to how Keaton’s movement has changed. He’s older, but he uses that to make the character feel even more "crusty" and ancient.
- Check Out the Broadway Cast Recording: Even if you can't see the show, listen to Alex Brightman’s "The Whole Being Dead Thing." It’s a great example of how to reinterpret a character without copying the original actor.
- Look for the Easter Eggs: In the sequel, there are several visual nods to Keaton’s original performance, including the way he wears his hat and the specific props he uses.
Michael Keaton’s legacy as the man who plays Beetlejuice in the movie is set in stone. While others have voiced him or played him on stage, the cinematic version belongs entirely to him. He took a thinly written ghost and turned him into one of the most recognizable figures in pop culture history. Whether it’s the 80s or the 2020s, if you say his name three times, Keaton is the one who shows up.
To get the full experience, revisit the original 1988 Beetlejuice first, then head straight into the 2024 sequel. Seeing the evolution of the character over nearly four decades is one of the coolest journeys in modern film history. Pay close attention to the small details—the way he adjusts his suit, the weird noises he makes under his breath, and the way he interacts with the practical effects. It’s a masterclass in character acting that you won't want to miss.