When the first trailer for Bohemian Rhapsody dropped, the internet collectively lost its mind over one thing: the teeth. Specifically, the prosthetic overbite Rami Malek wore to channel Freddie Mercury. People were skeptical. How could the guy from Mr. Robot, known for his wide-eyed, tech-anxious stare, possibly embody the most flamboyant frontman in rock history?
The cast of Bohemian Rhapsody had a massive weight on their shoulders. They weren't just making a movie; they were stepping into the shoes of deities in the eyes of Queen fans.
It worked. Mostly. While critics complained about the film’s "Wikipedia-style" pacing and historical liberties, the audience didn't care. They showed up for the performances. They showed up to see if a group of actors could actually recreate that lightning-in-a-bottle energy of the 1985 Live Aid performance. Honestly, the casting was the only reason the movie didn't collapse under the weight of its own production drama.
Rami Malek as Freddie Mercury: Beyond the Teeth
Rami Malek didn't just play Freddie. He lived him.
To get the movement right, Malek didn't hire a choreographer. He thought a choreographer would make him look too much like a dancer, and Freddie Mercury wasn't a dancer. He was a performer. Instead, he worked with a movement coach, Polly Bennett. They studied every eye flick, every microphone grab, and every strut. They even looked at Freddie’s influences, like Liza Minnelli and Marlene Dietrich.
The physical transformation was intense. Malek had to wear those heavy prosthetic teeth throughout the shoot. He reportedly kept a set of gold-plated ones after filming as a souvenir. Pretty wild, right? But the voice was the real trick. What you hear in the film is a "sound-alike" cocktail. It’s a mix of Freddie’s actual master tapes, Malek’s own singing, and the incredible vocal work of Marc Martel, a Canadian singer whose voice is almost indistinguishable from Mercury’s.
It paid off. Malek took home the Academy Award for Best Actor. Whether he deserved it over some of the other nominees that year is still a heated debate in film circles, but you can’t deny the sheer effort. He captured that specific mix of onstage bravado and offstage loneliness that defined Freddie's later years.
💡 You might also like: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Gwilym Lee, Ben Hardy, and Joe Mazzello: The Band Behind the Man
While Malek got the spotlight, the rest of the cast of Bohemian Rhapsody was arguably even more accurate in terms of look and feel.
Gwilym Lee, who played Brian May, looked so much like the legendary guitarist that May’s own daughter reportedly found it eerie. May himself was heavily involved in the production, often hanging out on set to give Lee pointers on how to hold the Red Special (May's famous homemade guitar). Lee nailed the gentle, professorial vibe that Brian May carries.
Then you have Ben Hardy as Roger Taylor. Hardy actually lied to director Bryan Singer during his audition. He told Singer he could play the drums. He couldn't. He had to take a crash course in drumming to look convincing because Taylor—a notorious perfectionist—was going to be watching. If you watch closely during the "I'm In Love With My Car" scene, you can see the comedic friction Hardy brings to the role, capturing Taylor's rock-and-roll attitude perfectly.
Joe Mazzello played John Deacon, the quietest member of the group. If Mazzello looks familiar, it’s because he was the little kid being chased by raptors in Jurassic Park. As "Deacy," he provided the grounded, stoic energy the band needed. His portrayal of the man who wrote "Another One Bites the Dust" was subtle, mostly because John Deacon himself has stayed out of the limelight for decades.
Lucy Boynton and the Heart of the Story
Lucy Boynton played Mary Austin, the woman Freddie called the "love of his life."
The chemistry between Malek and Boynton wasn't just acting—the two ended up in a long-term relationship after meeting on set. This helped the film’s emotional core. While the movie glosses over some of the messier parts of Freddie’s life, the scenes between Malek and Boynton feel grounded. She plays Mary with a specific kind of grace, representing the one constant in Freddie’s chaotic rise to fame.
📖 Related: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
Supporting Players You Might Have Missed
There’s a funny bit of meta-casting in this movie. Mike Myers plays Ray Foster, the EMI executive who tells the band that "Bohemian Rhapsody" is way too long and that "no one is going to be headbanging in their car to this."
It’s a direct wink at Wayne’s World.
Remember the iconic scene where Wayne and Garth do exactly that? Having Myers play the guy who hates the song was a stroke of genius. He’s almost unrecognizable under the prosthetics and the 70s wig.
Then there’s Tom Hollander as Jim "Miami" Beach and Aidan Gillen as John Reid. Gillen, fresh off playing Littlefinger in Game of Thrones, brought that same slick, slightly untrustworthy vibe to Queen’s early manager.
The Live Aid Recreation: A Technical Marvel
The climax of the film is the Live Aid set. The producers built a massive replica of the Wembley Stadium stage at an airfield outside London.
The cast of Bohemian Rhapsody performed the entire 20-minute set every single day of the shoot. They didn't just do snippets. They did the whole thing, top to bottom, to maintain the stamina and the flow. Every camera angle from the original 1985 broadcast was mapped out and recreated. If you watch the movie side-by-side with the real footage, the synchronization is terrifyingly accurate.
👉 See also: Tim Dillon: I'm Your Mother Explained (Simply)
Why the Casting Saved a Troubled Production
This movie was in "development hell" for over a decade. At one point, Sacha Baron Cohen was supposed to play Freddie. That version would have been a gritty, R-rated look at the singer's life. When that fell through due to creative differences with the surviving members of Queen, the project stalled.
When the film finally got moving with Dexter Fletcher (who took over after Bryan Singer was fired mid-production), the cast had to remain the anchor. They were the ones who kept the morale up during the directorial transition. The bond between the four actors playing the band members became genuine, which is probably why the "found family" theme of the movie resonates so well with audiences even when the script feels a bit thin.
Reality vs. Hollywood: What the Cast Had to Navigate
It's worth noting that the cast had to navigate a script that changed the timeline of Freddie's life. In the movie, Freddie tells the band he has AIDS right before Live Aid. In reality, he wasn't diagnosed until 1987, two years after the concert.
The actors had to play the emotional truth of the scenes rather than the historical truth. Malek, in particular, had to balance the knowledge of Freddie's fate with the high-energy performance of a man at his peak. It’s a delicate line to walk. If he played it too somber, the ending wouldn't feel triumphant. If he played it too happy, it would feel disrespectful to the tragedy that followed.
Actionable Takeaways for Queen Fans and Cinephiles
If you're revisiting the film or watching it for the first time, keep these specific things in mind to get the most out of the performances:
- Watch the eyes: Pay attention to Rami Malek’s eye movements during the press conference scene. He captures the defensive, overwhelmed nature of Mercury perfectly.
- Listen for the bass: Notice how Joe Mazzello handles the bass. He learned the actual fingerings for the songs, which is rare for actors playing musicians.
- Spot the cameos: Look for the real Adam Lambert (the singer currently touring with Queen) making a blink-and-you'll-miss-it cameo as a truck driver at a rest stop.
- Check the background: In the studio scenes, Gwilym Lee uses the actual techniques Brian May used, like playing with a sixpence coin instead of a plastic pick.
The cast of Bohemian Rhapsody succeeded because they were fans first. They understood that you don't just "play" icons like Queen; you pay homage to them. The film might not be a perfect documentary, but as a showcase for a group of actors dedicated to capturing the spirit of a legendary band, it's pretty hard to beat.
To truly appreciate the work put in by the actors, your next step should be watching the "Live Aid" side-by-side comparison on YouTube. It reveals the frame-by-frame dedication the cast maintained to ensure the 1985 performance was honored with total precision. From there, listen to the Bohemian Rhapsody soundtrack to see if you can pick out the subtle differences between the original Freddie vocals and the Martel/Malek layers used for the film's unique soundscape.