If you were watching TV in the early 2000s, you probably remember the moment Robert Barone—the perpetually overlooked, towering police officer—finally caught a break. It happened during that iconic two-part Season 5 premiere where the whole Barone clan heads to Italy. Amidst the pasta and the scenery, Robert meets a woman who actually seems to like him.
But who played Stefania on Everybody Loves Raymond?
That would be Alex Meneses. She stepped into the role of Stefania Fogagnolo and immediately became one of the most memorable guest stars in the show's nine-season run. Honestly, she was the perfect foil for Robert’s insecure, "crazy chin" energy.
The Woman Behind Stefania Fogagnolo
Alex Meneses brought a specific kind of vibrant, "luscious" energy to the screen that made Robert’s instant obsession totally believable. While Stefania was supposed to be a local Italian girl, Meneses herself is a Chicago native. She’s of Mexican and Ukrainian descent, but her time living and modeling in Milan, Italy, clearly paid off. She nailed the accent and the mannerisms so well that many fans still think she was cast straight out of a village in Lazio.
📖 Related: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
She didn't just appear in the Italy episodes, though. The writers knew they had something good.
Stefania actually followed Robert back to America—well, her father Marco (played by the intimidating David Proval) moved the family to open a pizza shop. This led to some of the funniest tension in the series, as Robert had to navigate a relationship while being terrified of his girlfriend's dad.
Why Alex Meneses Was the Perfect Choice
Casting is everything in a sitcom. If Stefania hadn't been likable, the audience would have stayed on "Team Amy." But Meneses made Stefania charming, fiery, and just a little bit too much for the neurotic Barone family to handle.
👉 See also: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
- The Chemistry: Standing at 5'9", she was one of the few actresses who didn't look tiny next to Brad Garrett’s 6'8" frame.
- The Comedy: She held her own against heavyweights like Doris Roberts and Peter Boyle.
- The Accolades: Her performance was actually quite decorated. She earned nominations for an ALMA Award and an American Comedy Award for her guest role.
You’ve Definitely Seen Her Elsewhere
If you're looking at her and thinking, "I know her from somewhere else," you’re probably a Friends fan. Before she was Robert's Italian flame, she was one of Joey Tribbiani’s many sisters—Cookie—the one who punched Phoebe in the face.
She also had a huge role in the Eva Longoria comedy Telenovela, where she played the aging diva Isabella Santamaria. It was a role that let her lean into her comedic timing even more than she did on Raymond. Beyond that, she’s popped up in everything from Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman (as Teresa Morales) to Jane the Virgin and Why Women Kill.
The "Annoying" Legacy
One of the funniest, and most brutal, moments for the character of Stefania happens during the episode "The Intervention." After she and Robert have broken up, she makes a guest appearance to help the family talk to him.
✨ Don't miss: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
In a moment of pure honesty, she tells Robert, in her thick accent, that he is simply "annoyingah." It was a full-circle moment for the show. Robert spent years feeling like the annoying second son, and here was the "love of his life" confirming it to his face. It was heartbreaking but peak Everybody Loves Raymond comedy.
What Happened to Stefania?
In the world of the show, the relationship fizzled out because the "holiday romance" couldn't survive the reality of Long Island. Robert eventually found his way back to Amy McDougall, which most fans agree was the right ending. Stefania was a spark, but Amy was the steady flame.
Today, Alex Meneses continues to act and is also heavily involved in philanthropy. She remains a fan favorite at sitcom conventions and is often cited as the guest star who gave Robert Barone his best "win" in the series.
Facts at a Glance:
- Full Name: Alexandra Estella DeAnna Meneses.
- First Appearance: Season 5, Episode 1 ("Italy").
- Last Appearance: Season 6, Episode 22 ("Lucky 21") - though she is mentioned and appears in "The Intervention."
- Famous Line: "Robert... you are annoyingah!"
If you're planning a rewatch, keep an eye out for her episodes in Season 5. They represent some of the best "fish out of water" comedy the show ever produced.
Your next step: To see Alex Meneses in a completely different light, check out the Friends episode "The One with All the Jealousy" (Season 3, Episode 11) to see her play Joey’s sister Cookie. It’s a great example of her range before she became the "Italian" dream girl of Lynbrook.