When the "original sinner" finally stepped out of a luxury sports car in the middle of Los Angeles, fans of the Netflix hit Lucifer knew things were about to get messy. She wasn't some dusty, biblical figure wrapped in animal skins. No. She was a cocktail-drinking, high-heel-wearing force of nature. But the question that burned through the fandom immediately wasn't just about her backstory—it was specifically about who played Eve in Lucifer and why she felt so familiar.
The answer is Inbar Lavi.
She didn't just play a character; she hijacked the show's dynamic. Honestly, walking into a series that already has a cult-level following is terrifying for most actors. You have the "Deckerstar" shippers who want Lucifer and Chloe together at all costs. Then you drop in the ex-girlfriend from the literal Beginning of Time. It’s a recipe for fan backlash. Yet, Lavi managed to make Eve someone you kind of rooted for, even when she was making terrible, soul-crushing decisions.
Why Inbar Lavi Was the Only Choice for the First Woman
Casting a biblical icon is a nightmare. If you go too "holy," it's boring. If you go too "evil," it’s a cliché. The showrunners, Joe Henderson and Ildy Modrovich, needed someone who could project a sense of ancient innocence mixed with a modern desire for self-destruction.
Inbar Lavi brought an energy that felt incredibly grounded despite the supernatural stakes. Before she landed the role of Eve, Lavi had already been putting in serious work across Hollywood. You might remember her as the lead in Imposters, where she played a con artist named Maddie who shifted identities like most people change clothes. That specific skill set—the ability to be vulnerable one second and manipulative the next—was exactly what the character of Eve required.
She arrived in Season 4, which was a pivotal moment for the show. This was the first season produced by Netflix after the "Save Lucifer" campaign rescued the series from Fox's cancellation. The stakes were sky-high. Lavi had to represent the "old" Lucifer—the hedonistic, uncaring Devil—while the audience was busy falling in love with the "new," evolving Lucifer. It's a testament to her acting that people didn't just hate Eve for being an obstacle; they felt sorry for her. She was a woman who had been defined by a rib and a husband for eons and just wanted to have some fun for once.
A Career Built on Range
Lavi’s resume is more diverse than people realize. If you’re sitting there thinking, "I know that face," but you haven't seen Imposters, you likely caught her in Prison Break. She played Sheba, a much more hardened, grit-under-the-fingernails character than the bubbly Eve.
She also popped up in The Last Ship and Sons of Anarchy. When you look at her filmography, a pattern emerges. She doesn't do "background." Even in smaller roles, she has this magnetic, slightly off-kilter presence. That’s likely why she beat out a long list of actresses for the role of Eve. The producers didn't want a "bombshell" in the traditional, empty sense. They wanted someone who felt like they had lived for several thousand years and was finally having a mid-life (or mid-eternity) crisis.
📖 Related: Break It Off PinkPantheress: How a 90-Second Garage Flip Changed Everything
The Chemistry That Shook the Show
We have to talk about the chemistry. When we look at who played Eve in Lucifer, we aren't just talking about a name on a call sheet; we're talking about the chemistry she had with Tom Ellis.
It was electric. And dangerous.
In Season 4, Eve represents a relapse. For Lucifer, she is the ultimate "bad influence" friend who calls you at 2:00 AM to go to a club when you have a job interview the next morning. Lavi played this with such infectious joy that you almost forgot she was leading the protagonist toward a literal demonic transformation. Her performance highlighted the toxicity of "loving" someone for who they used to be rather than who they are now.
But it wasn't just about Lucifer.
The "Mazeve" arc—the relationship between Eve and Maze (Lesley-Ann Brandt)—is arguably one of the most beloved romantic subplots in the entire series. This is where Lavi’s performance really deepened. She shifted from this flighty, party-girl persona into someone grappling with actual identity and rejection. Watching a demon who has never felt love and the first woman who has only known "duty-bound" love navigate a relationship was some of the best writing the show ever produced.
The Biblical Twist You Might Have Missed
The writers took some liberties, obviously. In the show, Eve didn't leave Eden because of a snake or an apple—she left because she was bored. She was the first person to ever experience "The Golden Cage" syndrome.
When Inbar Lavi took the role, she leaned into the idea that Eve was the first thrill-seeker. It changes the perspective on the Garden of Eden entirely. Instead of a tragedy, Lavi played it as a breakout. This interpretation is what makes her version of Eve so different from any other media portrayal. She wasn't a victim of the Devil's temptation; she was his partner in crime who was arguably more reckless than he was.
👉 See also: Bob Hearts Abishola Season 4 Explained: The Move That Changed Everything
Honestly, the way she ate the apple (or, in this case, walked into Lux and ordered an Appletini) was a brilliant nod to the source material without being heavy-handed.
Life After the Garden: What Inbar Lavi Did Next
After Lucifer wrapped its sixth and final season, Lavi didn't just disappear into the sunset. She has remained a staple in the world of high-concept television and film.
- She starred in the film Eight for Silver (also known as The Cursed), a gothic horror that is about as far from the neon lights of Lucifer as you can get.
- She has been involved in several international projects, leaning into her Israeli roots.
- Lavi is also a singer—if you listen closely to some of her scenes in Lucifer, that musicality is present in her voice.
Many fans were surprised to see her return for the final season. Usually, when a "love interest" character leaves, they stay gone. But the writers realized that Eve’s journey—especially her growth alongside Maze—was essential to the show’s themes of redemption. You can't have a show about the Devil becoming a better man without showing that the "Original Sinner" can also find her own path.
Common Misconceptions About the Character
People often confuse the actress with other stars who have a similar "vibe." No, it wasn't Gal Gadot (though they share an Israeli heritage). And no, it wasn't any of the actresses from The Good Place, even though both shows deal with the afterlife.
Another big point of confusion is the timeline. Some viewers think Eve was only in Season 4. In reality, while she was a "Big Bad" (sort of) in the fourth season, her character arc spans through to the series finale. She evolves from a catalyst for Lucifer’s chaos into a bounty hunter alongside Maze. It’s a wild character progression that Lavi handled with incredible grace.
How to Watch Her Best Episodes
If you want to see the peak of Lavi’s performance, you need to revisit Season 4, Episode 3, "O, Ye of Little Faith, Father." That's her grand entrance. But for her best emotional work, look at Season 5, Episode 13, "A Little Harmless Stalking."
She brings a specific brand of chaotic energy that is hard to replicate. Most actors try to play "ancient" by being stiff or overly formal. Lavi went the opposite direction. She played Eve as someone who is constantly discovering things for the first time. The way she looks at a cell phone or tastes a new drink—there's a genuine sense of wonder there.
✨ Don't miss: Black Bear by Andrew Belle: Why This Song Still Hits So Hard
Actionable Steps for Fans of Inbar Lavi
If you’ve finished Lucifer and you’re wondering where to go next to see more of the woman who played Eve, here is your roadmap:
1. Binge-watch Imposters
This is her masterclass. She plays multiple "characters" within one show. If you liked her range in Lucifer, this will blow your mind. It’s currently available on various streaming platforms like Netflix or Prime Video depending on your region.
2. Follow her Social Media for BTS Content
Lavi is quite active on Instagram and often shares behind-the-scenes stories from her time on the Lucifer set. She has a great relationship with the "Lucifam" and frequently interacts with fan art and theories.
3. Check out Fauda
If you want to see her in a much more serious, intense role, she appeared in this critically acclaimed series. It’s a stark contrast to the whimsical nature of Eve, showing her ability to handle heavy, political drama.
4. Explore her Music
Inbar Lavi has released singles like "Puppet" which showcase her sultry, jazz-influenced vocal style. It adds a whole new layer to her performance as Eve if you realize she’s actually a trained singer.
The legacy of Eve in Lucifer isn't just about a romantic foil. It's about a character who reclaimed her own narrative. Inbar Lavi took a figure that history has blamed for the fall of man and turned her into a symbol of independence and self-discovery. Whether she was fighting demons or just trying to figure out how to be a "person," she was consistently the most interesting human on the screen.
Next time you’re rewatching the series and that signature theme song hits, pay attention to the nuance Lavi brings to the later seasons. She took a role that could have been a one-dimensional trope and made it the heart of the show’s final act. That’s not just good casting; that’s a career-defining performance.