Ask anyone on a street corner in New York or London who made the plane first and they’ll give you the same answer. The Wright Brothers. It's ingrained in us from grade school, right? Orville and Wilbur, the bicycle mechanics from Ohio, Kitty Hawk, 1903. Simple. But if you ask that same question in a pub in Brazil, you’re going to get a very different, very passionate answer involving a guy named Alberto Santos-Dumont. If you’re in France, they might bring up Clément Ader.
History isn't usually a straight line. It's more of a messy, tangled web of people failing, crashing, and occasionally gliding into a haystack.
Actually, the "first" depends entirely on how you define a plane. Are we talking about a glider with a lawnmower engine? Does it have to take off under its own power? Does the pilot need to be able to actually steer the thing, or is just not dying considered a "flight"? When we look at the timeline of aviation, the Wrights certainly hit a massive milestone, but they weren't working in a vacuum. They were standing on the shoulders of some very brave, very eccentric, and occasionally very bruised people.
The Kitty Hawk Narrative and Why It Stuck
December 17, 1903. That’s the date. The Flyer stayed up for 12 seconds and covered 120 feet. By today’s standards, you could throw a paper airplane further if you had a good breeze, but back then, it was everything. What Orville and Wilbur Wright understood that nobody else quite nailed was three-axis control.
✨ Don't miss: Why Everyone Asks Google to Show Me a Picture of a Dog (and What We’re Actually Looking For)
Most people trying to fly at the turn of the century were just trying to get lift. They wanted to go up. The Wrights realized that once you're up, you have to stay level, turn, and not pitch into the sand head-first. They developed wing-warping (the ancestor of modern ailerons) to control roll. They had a rudder for yaw. They had an elevator for pitch.
This is why they usually win the "who made the plane first" debate. Their machine was truly "controlled, powered, and sustained."
But there’s a catch.
The 1903 flight used a rail system to launch. It didn't have wheels. It needed a headwind. Because of this, a lot of international critics—especially the French—spent years arguing that it didn't count as a "real" takeoff. The Wrights were also intensely secretive. They were terrified of people stealing their patents, so they didn't do public demonstrations for years. While they were hiding in Ohio, the rest of the world was catching up.
The Brazilian Contender: Santos-Dumont
Now, let's talk about Alberto Santos-Dumont. In Brazil, he is the undisputed Father of Aviation. In 1906, he flew his 14-bis aircraft in Paris.
Here is the thing: Santos-Dumont’s flight was the first publicly witnessed flight in the world. Thousands of people saw it. He didn't use a catapult. He didn't use a rail. His plane had wheels and took off under its own power from a flat field.
For many purists, this is the true "first plane." They argue that if you need a specialized track and a bungee-cord-style launch system, you haven't really solved the problem of flight; you’ve just built a high-tech kite. Santos-Dumont was also a bit of a rockstar. He lived in Paris, wore high-collared shirts, and famously designed the first wristwatch (with Louis Cartier) because he couldn't check his pocket watch while his hands were on the controls. He gave his designs away for free because he believed aviation would bring world peace.
He was wrong about the peace part, unfortunately. When he saw planes being used for reconnaissance and bombing in World War I, it reportedly broke his heart.
The People Who Almost Did It (The Pioneers Before 1903)
If we’re being honest, the question of who made the plane first usually ignores the 1800s, which is a crime. You’ve got Sir George Cayley, an English baronet who basically figured out the physics of flight in 1799. He carved the four forces of flight—lift, weight, thrust, and drag—into a silver disc. He knew how it worked; he just didn't have an engine light enough to make it happen.
Then there’s Otto Lilienthal, the "Glider King."
Lilienthal was a German engineer who made thousands of successful flights in gliders he designed himself. He proved that curved wings (airfoils) were the key to lift. The Wright brothers studied his data religiously. Tragically, Lilienthal died in 1896 when a gust of wind stalled his glider and he fell 50 feet, breaking his spine. His last words were reportedly, "Sacrifices must be made."
That’s a heavy price for a patent.
The Weird Case of Clément Ader
In 1890, a Frenchman named Clément Ader built a steam-powered, bat-winged contraption called the Éole. It actually lifted off the ground. About 8 inches off the ground. For about 160 feet.
The French military was interested, but the machine was basically uncontrollable. It had no way to steer. Most historians don't count it as a "plane" in the modern sense because it was more of a "hop." If you jump over a puddle, are you flying? Probably not. But Ader is the reason we use the word "avion" in French—he coined the term.
Gustave Whitehead: The Conspiracy Theory
Then there’s the wild card. Some folks in Connecticut swear that a German immigrant named Gustave Whitehead flew a powered machine in 1901—two years before the Wrights.
There were newspaper reports about it. There were witnesses. But there are no photos of the flight. Only a blurry photo of the plane on the ground. The Smithsonian Institute has a legal contract with the Wright estate that forbids them from ever saying anyone flew before the Wrights, which fuels the fire for Whitehead supporters. It’s a classic historical rabbit hole. Did he do it? Most experts say his engine probably wasn't powerful enough, but the debate still gets people's blood boiling in aviation circles.
Why the Wrights Won the History Books
The reason the Wright Brothers are the answer to "who made the plane first" isn't just because of Kitty Hawk. It’s because of what they did in 1904 and 1905.
While everyone else was trying to just get off the ground, the Wrights were at Huffman Prairie in Ohio, flying in circles. They built the Flyer III, which could stay in the air for 30 minutes, perform figure-eights, and land safely. This was the first practical airplane.
They weren't just "hopping." They were navigating.
The Wrights were also meticulous. They built their own wind tunnel because the existing data on lift was wrong. They carved their own propellers based on ship propeller theory, realizing a propeller is just a spinning wing. Their engineering was lightyears ahead of the "trial and error" guys who were just slapping wings on carriages and hoping for the best.
The "First" is a Technicality
So, who made the plane first?
If you mean the first person to understand how a plane should work: George Cayley.
If you mean the first person to fly a powered, controlled, sustained aircraft: The Wright Brothers.
If you mean the first person to fly a plane that didn't need a special launch rail: Alberto Santos-Dumont.
If you mean the first person to survive a flight in a glider: Otto Lilienthal.
It’s a team effort spread across centuries. Every time you sit in an aluminum tube at 35,000 feet eating stale pretzels, you’re riding on a machine that required the failures of hundreds of people to exist.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs
If you want to actually understand this evolution beyond just a name and a date, you’ve got to see these things in person. History feels different when you’re standing next to the wood and canvas.
- Visit the Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum: They have the original 1903 Wright Flyer. It’s smaller than you think. Seeing the fragility of it makes the courage of Orville and Wilbur much more real.
- Research the "Great Aerodrome" Failure: Look up Samuel Langley. He was the head of the Smithsonian and had a massive government grant to build a plane at the same time as the Wrights. He crashed into the Potomac River twice, just days before the Wrights succeeded. It’s a great lesson in how money doesn't always beat raw engineering.
- Compare the Control Systems: If you’re a tech nerd, look at the diagrams of Santos-Dumont’s 14-bis versus the Wright Flyer. The difference in how they solved the problem of "turning" is fascinating. The Wrights used "wing warping," which basically twisted the entire wing structure.
- Read the Primary Sources: Don't just take a textbook's word for it. Read the Wright brothers' diaries and the newspaper accounts of Santos-Dumont’s flights in Paris. The excitement (and skepticism) of the time is palpable.
The story of the first plane isn't a single "Eureka!" moment. It’s a story of crashes, lawsuits, brilliant insights, and a lot of broken wood in the pursuit of the sky.