You’d think we would have a receipt. Or at least a photo. But figuring out who made the first hamburger is honestly like trying to find a needle in a haystack of greasy napkins and 19th-century fairground lore. It’s a mess. People get heated about this, too. Mention the wrong name in a small town in Wisconsin or Connecticut, and you’re basically asking for a lecture.
The truth is, nobody just woke up one day and invented the concept of putting meat between bread. We’ve been doing that since the Earl of Sandwich got bored at a card table. But the specific transition—taking a Hamburg-style chopped steak and slapping it between two slices of bread for a guy on the go—that’s where the drama starts. It wasn't a corporate boardroom decision. It was a chaotic byproduct of the American Industrial Revolution and the rise of "fair food."
The Library of Congress Weighs In (Sorta)
If you’re looking for the "official" answer, the Library of Congress points its finger at Louis Lassen.
In 1900, in New Haven, Connecticut, a guy rushed into Louis’ Lunch. He was in a hurry. He wanted something he could eat while walking. Louis took some steak trimmings, ground them up, grilled them, and shoved them between two slices of toast.
Boom. A sandwich.
But was it a hamburger? Purists argue about the bread. Louis’ Lunch still serves their burgers on vertical cast-iron broilers, and they still use toast. No buns. No ketchup. If you ask for ketchup there today, they might actually ask you to leave. It’s a point of pride. They claim the crown because they have the oldest documented lineage, but plenty of people in the Midwest think that’s total nonsense.
The 1885 Contenders: Charlie and the Menches
Fifteen years before Louis Lassen supposedly "invented" it, a 15-year-old boy named Charlie Nagreen was allegedly crushing it at the Outagamie County Fair in Seymour, Wisconsin.
"Hamburger Charlie," they called him.
📖 Related: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
He was selling meatballs. People liked the meatballs, but they were hard to eat while walking around looking at cows and prize-winning pumpkins. Charlie had a "lightbulb" moment. He flattened the meatballs and put them between slices of bread. Seymour, Wisconsin, now holds a massive Burger Fest every year and has a giant statue of Charlie. They aren't joking around.
Then you have the Menches brothers. Frank and Charles Menches were at the Erie County Fair in Hamburg, New York, also in 1885. Legend says they ran out of pork sausage for their sandwiches. The local butcher, a guy named Andrew Klein, didn't have more pork because it was too hot to slaughter hogs. He sold them ground beef instead. The brothers seasoned it with coffee grounds and brown sugar—which sounds weird but okay—and named it the "hamburger" after the town of Hamburg.
It’s a great story. Is it true? Who knows. Fairground stories are notoriously shaky because everyone was too busy selling snacks to file patents.
Why the "Hamburg" Name Matters
We have to talk about Germany. Obviously.
The "Hamburg Steak" was a real thing long before it hit American shores. In the mid-1800s, German immigrants coming out of the port of Hamburg brought their recipe for shredded, seasoned beef. It was considered "gourmet" at first. High-end restaurants like Delmonico’s in New York had it on the menu as early as 1837.
But that was a steak. You ate it with a fork and knife.
The real innovation of who made the first hamburger isn't the meat; it's the portability. America was moving fast. Workers in factories needed something high-protein that they could hold with one hand while the other hand kept a machine running. The bun was the final piece of the puzzle.
👉 See also: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
The Fletcher Davis Factor
Down in Athens, Texas, they swear by a guy named "Old Dave," or Fletcher Davis. He reportedly sold a ground beef sandwich at his lunch counter in the 1880s and then took the show on the road to the 1904 St. Louis World’s Fair. This is a huge deal because the 1904 World’s Fair was basically the Instagram of the turn of the century. If it was popular there, it became a national sensation.
A reporter for the New York Tribune wrote about a "hamburger" at the fair, which gives the Texas claim some serious weight.
The Great Bun Debate
You can’t have a modern hamburger without a bun. Toast is just a patty melt’s cousin.
Most historians give the credit for the commercial bun to Walter Anderson. He’s the guy who co-founded White Castle in 1921. Before him, people were using whatever bread was lying around. Anderson realized that if you wanted to sell a lot of burgers fast, you needed a uniform, soft roll that could soak up the juices without falling apart.
He didn't just invent a sandwich; he invented a system.
White Castle changed everything because, before 1921, ground beef was actually considered "dangerous." People thought it was made of scraps and floor sweepings (thanks, Upton Sinclair and The Jungle). Anderson made his kitchen sparkling white and ground the meat in front of the customers to prove it wasn't "mystery meat." That trust-building exercise is what allowed the hamburger to go from a fairground oddity to a staple of the American diet.
It’s All About Regional Pride
When you look at the evidence, there isn't one "inventor." It’s more like a spontaneous combustion of meat and bread across the country.
✨ Don't miss: January 14, 2026: Why This Wednesday Actually Matters More Than You Think
- Wisconsin: Claims the fairground origin.
- Connecticut: Claims the oldest continuous restaurant.
- Texas: Claims the 1904 World's Fair debut.
- New York: Claims the naming rights.
Is one of them lying? Not necessarily. It’s entirely possible that four different guys in four different states all had the same idea within a decade of each other. That’s how trends work.
Moving Past the Legend
The obsession with who made the first hamburger usually overlooks the actual evolution of the food. It didn't stop with Fletcher Davis or Louis Lassen. It kept changing. In the 1920s, it was a "slider." In the 1940s, the McDonald brothers turned it into a high-speed assembly line. By the 1950s, it was the symbol of the American middle class.
Today, we have $100 wagyu burgers with truffle oil and $2 "value menu" patties. The core identity is still the same, though. It’s a democratic food. It’s for everyone.
How to Verify the History Yourself
If you’re a real food nerd and want to dig deeper into the archives, don't just take a blogger's word for it. Look at the primary sources.
- Search digitized newspaper archives: Look for the term "Hamburger Steak Sandwich" in papers from 1880 to 1900. You'll see the terminology shift in real-time.
- Visit the sites: Louis’ Lunch is still there. Go to New Haven. Eat the burger on toast. See if it feels like the "original" to you.
- Check the "Burger Hall of Fame": Seymour, Wisconsin, has an actual museum dedicated to this. They have more documentation on Charlie Nagreen than you’d expect for a 19th-century teenager.
- Read Josh Ozersky: The late food writer Josh Ozersky wrote "The Hamburger: A History." It is widely considered the definitive text on how this sandwich conquered the world. He cuts through a lot of the small-town myths with a pretty sharp knife.
The most important thing to remember is that food history is often oral history. It’s told by grandsons and local chamber of commerce presidents. It’s meant to be a little bit legendary. Whether it started in a small town in Texas or a lunch wagon in Connecticut, the hamburger is now the closest thing we have to a global culinary language.
Go to your local library or use a database like Newspapers.com to search for "Hamburg Steak" mentions in your own town's history. You might be surprised to find that your local diner was serving them earlier than the "official" legends claim.
Next time you’re at a cookout, you can tell the story of the Menches brothers or "Hamburger Charlie," but be prepared—somebody else will probably have a different version. And honestly, that’s half the fun.