If you spend any time watching Kill Tony, you know the drill. Tony Hinchcliffe sits up there in a sharp jacket, usually roasting some poor soul who just bombed for sixty seconds. He’s the "Golden Pony," the master of the roast, and a guy who seems to have an answer for everything. But there’s one question that usually gets met with a smirk or a quick pivot to a joke about Brian Redban: who is Tony Hinchcliffe dating?
Honestly, the guy is a vault. While other comedians spill their entire lives—divorces, kids, weird Tinder dates—into their microphones, Tony keeps his romantic life under a pretty heavy lock and key. It’s kinda ironic, right? He spends his life digging into the personal business of strangers on his stage, yet his own dating status is a mystery that fans have been trying to solve for years.
The Heidi Hall Rumors and the "Look"
Lately, if you scroll through any Reddit thread or YouTube comment section, one name keeps popping up: Heidi Hall.
She’s the "lovely Heidi" we see on Kill Tony every week. If you’ve watched the show recently, you might have caught those moments during ad breaks or transitions where Tony and Heidi are caught in the background. Fans have gone full Zapruder-film on these clips. They point to the way they look at each other, or the "sexual tension" that supposedly radiates off the screen. Some swear they've seen Tony mouth "I love you" during a commercial lead-in.
Is there any actual proof? Not really. It’s all speculation based on body language and "vibes."
💡 You might also like: Dale Mercer Net Worth: Why the RHONY Star is Richer Than You Think
Neither of them has confirmed a thing. In the world of comedy, sometimes a "look" is just two people who have worked together for years being comfortable. Or, because it's Tony, it's a bit. He knows people are watching. He knows what starts a rumor.
The Australian "Green Card" Marriage
To understand why Tony is so private now, you have to look back at the one time he actually did get married. It was a weird, fast situation that caught even his closest friends off guard.
Back around 2017 or 2018, Tony married Charlotte Jane. She’s an Australian model and the daughter of a fairly wealthy family. It was a secret at first, but other comedians eventually started roasting him about it on stage. The rumor mill—as it always does—labeled it a "green card marriage" so she could stay in the States. Tony has laughed this off in interviews, even recently on Howie Mandel's podcast, describing the divorce as "surprisingly smooth" and wholesome.
They weren't married long. By the time Tony moved the show to Austin in 2020, the ring was gone. Charlotte moved on, and Tony went back to being the single, elusive bachelor of the comedy world.
📖 Related: Jaden Newman Leaked OnlyFans: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the "Is He Gay?" Joke Never Dies
You can't talk about Tony Hinchcliffe's dating life without mentioning the elephant in the room: the constant jokes about his sexuality.
It’s the most common roast directed at him. From his "sassy" hand gestures to his love of high-fashion vests and wrestling, the "Tony is gay" bit is a staple of Kill Tony. Joe Rogan has even weighed in, saying on his podcast that it’s hilarious because Tony actually "gets the hottest women."
Basically, the joke works because it contrasts with his actual life. Tony leans into the persona because it's good for the show. It gives the bucket pulls a target to hit. If he were constantly posting "couple goals" photos with a girlfriend on Instagram, the mystery—and the comedy—would vanish.
The Reality of Dating a "Golden Pony"
Being a top-tier comedian in 2026 isn't like it used to be. Every date is a potential "leaked" photo.
👉 See also: The Fifth Wheel Kim Kardashian: What Really Happened with the Netflix Comedy
Reports from people "in the know" around the Comedy Mothership in Austin suggest Tony isn't exactly lonely. There are whispers of him dating local musicians, yoga instructors, or even people behind the scenes at LiveNation. But he never brings them into the spotlight.
He’s seen what happens when comedians make their relationships their "content." It's messy. When it ends, the audience feels like they own part of the breakup. By staying quiet, Tony keeps the focus on the roast and the show.
What we know for sure:
- He is definitely divorced from Charlotte Jane.
- He is currently living in Austin, Texas.
- He has zero interest in hard-launching a relationship on social media.
What to Look for Next
If you're looking for an official announcement, don't hold your breath. Tony seems to prefer the "player" lifestyle or, at the very least, the privacy that comes with it. Your best bet for clues isn't a press release; it's watching the margins of the Kill Tony livestream.
If you want to stay updated on the Austin comedy scene or the latest guest list for the Mothership, keep an eye on official tour dates and podcast drops. The real "tea" usually slips out during a late-night set where someone forgets the cameras are rolling.