You’ve probably seen the black and yellow polos on the news more times than you can count. But if you try to pin down exactly who the leader of the Proud Boys is today, things get murky fast. It’s not like looking up the CEO of a tech company. It’s a disorganized, chaotic, and increasingly localized mess.
Honestly, the group is a shell of what it used to be during the 2020 election cycle.
Back then, the hierarchy was clearer. You had Enrique Tarrio at the top, acting as the public face and the strategic coordinator. Now? Tarrio is serving a 22-year prison sentence for seditious conspiracy related to the January 6th Capitol riot. His predecessor, Gavin McInnes, who actually started the whole thing as a joke in a Manhattan office, distanced himself years ago to avoid legal heat.
The "National" structure basically dissolved under the weight of federal indictments and internal infighting.
From McInnes to Tarrio: A Quick History of the Top Spot
Gavin McInnes founded the group in 2016. It started in the offices of Taki’s Magazine. Weirdly enough, the name comes from a song in the Disney musical Aladdin. McInnes wanted a "pro-Western" men's club. It was supposed to be about drinking beer and fighting, but it spiraled into political violence almost immediately. McInnes left in 2018, shortly after a brawl outside the Metropolitan Republican Club in New York led to several arrests.
📖 Related: Typhoon Tip and the Largest Hurricane on Record: Why Size Actually Matters
Then came Enrique Tarrio.
Tarrio changed the vibe. He was more media-savvy. He moved the group toward more overt political activism, aligning heavily with the "Stop the Steal" movement. Under Tarrio, the leader of the Proud Boys role became synonymous with national protest organizing. He wasn't even at the Capitol on January 6th—he’d been arrested two days prior for burning a Black Lives Matter banner and ordered to leave D.C.—but prosecutors proved he was still pulling the strings from a hotel room in nearby Baltimore.
The Great Shattering: Who’s Running Things Today?
Right now, there isn't one single leader of the Proud Boys.
After the January 6th fallout and the subsequent "Seditious Conspiracy" trials, the national leadership council, often called the "Elder Chapter" or the "Ministry of Self-Defense," largely collapsed. What we’re seeing in 2026 is a "franchise" model. It’s like a fast-food chain but with no corporate headquarters.
👉 See also: Melissa Calhoun Satellite High Teacher Dismissal: What Really Happened
Local chapters in places like Florida, Ohio, and the Pacific Northwest now operate almost entirely on their own. They don't take orders from a central figure.
- Chapter Autonomy: Most local groups have their own "President."
- The Power Vacuum: Several members, like Joe Biggs and Ethan Nordean, were also hit with massive prison sentences, leaving no "heir apparent" to the national throne.
- Internal Rifts: Some chapters have officially broken away from the national brand, calling themselves "Western Chauvinists" but refusing to associate with the "Proud Boy" name because of the FBI scrutiny.
It's a decentralized network. Think of it as a series of autonomous cells rather than a pyramid. If you see a protest in a small town in Oregon, those guys aren't calling a guy in Miami for permission. They are doing their own thing, fueled by Telegram chats and local grievances.
The Legal Hammer and the "Leaderless" Strategy
The Department of Justice really did a number on the organization's ability to coordinate. When the leader of the Proud Boys and his inner circle were hit with decades of prison time, it sent a shockwave through the ranks.
Many members got scared. They deleted their accounts. They stopped showing up to rallies.
✨ Don't miss: Wisconsin Judicial Elections 2025: Why This Race Broke Every Record
But here is what most people get wrong: they think "no leader" means "no threat." It’s actually the opposite in some ways. When a group has a leader, the police know who to wiretap. They know who to flip. When you have fifty different "leaders" of fifty different chapters, it becomes a game of whack-a-mole for law enforcement.
The Southern Poverty Law Center and the Anti-Defamation League have both noted that while national numbers are down, the radicalization at the local level is still very much alive. They’ve traded large-scale D.C. marches for showing up at local school board meetings or drag brunch protests.
What You Should Actually Be Watching
If you are looking for who has influence now, don't look for a title. Look for the people with the biggest Telegram channels.
Names like Brien James (a co-founder of the Proud Boys and the Indiana chapter leader) have tried to maintain some semblance of order, but it’s a constant struggle against infighting. There is a deep divide between the "political" wing, which wants to work within the GOP, and the "accelerationist" wing, which just wants to see the system burn.
Key Takeaways and Reality Check
Trying to identify a single leader of the Proud Boys in the current climate is a fool's errand. The group has evolved—or devolved, depending on how you look at it—into a decentralized movement.
- Follow the local chapters. If you want to understand what the group is doing, you have to look at the state and city level. The national story is mostly a legal one now.
- Monitor the platforms. They aren't on Twitter (X) or Facebook much. They live on Telegram and Rumble. That's where the "thought leaders" of the movement actually reside.
- Understand the legal precedents. The sentencing of Enrique Tarrio set a massive legal precedent for "vicarious liability." It means leaders can be held responsible for the actions of their followers even if they aren't physically present at a crime. This is exactly why nobody wants the "Leader" title anymore. It’s a one-way ticket to a federal penitentiary.
- Watch the rebranding. Many former members are joining other groups like the "Active Clubs" or "Patriot Front." The ideology hasn't vanished; it’s just changing its clothes to avoid the "Proud Boy" stigma and the associated law enforcement heat.
The era of the "celebrity" militia leader is likely over. What replaces it is a more quiet, fragmented, and unpredictable landscape of local actors. Keep your eyes on the court transcripts from the ongoing civil suits in D.C.; that’s where the real remaining power structures—and the remaining money—are being exposed.