It was the question that defined a generation of television. For six years, millions of viewers tuned into The CW to watch the scandalous lives of Manhattan’s elite, all while wondering: who is the Gossip Girl? The show was built on a mystery. It wasn't just about who was dating whom or who got into Yale; it was about the voice. Kristen Bell’s iconic narration provided the snarky soundtrack to every betrayal on the Upper East Side. We all wanted to know who held the power. We wanted to know who was hitting "send" on those ruinous blasts.
Then came the finale.
In a move that basically broke the internet before "breaking the internet" was even a common phrase, the show revealed that Dan Humphrey was the anonymous blogger. Yeah. Lonely Boy. The guy from Brooklyn. The one who supposedly had a moral compass.
Honestly, it didn't make a lot of sense to everyone. Actually, to a lot of people, it made zero sense. If you rewatch the pilot, Dan is looking at the Gossip Girl site with a look of genuine surprise. How do you surprise yourself with your own post? You don't. That’s the disconnect that still fuels Reddit threads and TikTok deep dives over a decade later.
The Dan Humphrey Reveal and Why It Felt Like a Betrayal
When we finally found out who is the Gossip Girl, the reaction was mixed, to put it mildly. Dan Humphrey, played by Penn Badgley, explained that he "wrote himself into" the world of Serena van der Woodsen and Blair Waldorf. He realized that if he wasn't born into the Upper East Side, he had to make himself a character in their story.
It was a meta-commentary on class and fame. But for the average viewer? It felt like a massive plot hole.
Think about it. There are dozens of scenes throughout the series where Dan is alone, looking at his phone, and reacting with shock to a Gossip Girl blast. Why would he do that? Is he a sociopath? Does he have a split personality? The writers, including showrunner Stephanie Savage, have since admitted that they didn't always know it was Dan. In fact, for a long time, it wasn't supposed to be him.
The Candidates Who Almost Made the Cut
Before the writers settled on Dan, there were two other major contenders for the hood.
💡 You might also like: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
- Eric van der Woodsen: Originally, Serena’s younger brother was the prime candidate. It made sense. He was observant, quiet, and had a front-row seat to all the drama. However, the New York Post leaked this theory early on. The writers, wanting to stay ahead of the audience, pivoted away from Eric.
- Nate Archibald: This was the second choice. Nate was the only character who never sent a tip to Gossip Girl. The irony of the most "honest" guy being the puppet master would have been a great twist. But again, the writers changed course.
By the time they reached the final season, Dan was the only one left who fit the narrative of an outsider wanting in. But the execution was messy. If Dan was Gossip Girl, he effectively posted about his own sister’s sex life and his own private heartbreaks. That's a level of commitment to a bit that borders on terrifying.
Rewatching With the Knowledge of Who Is the Gossip Girl
If you go back and watch the show today, knowing the ending changes everything. It turns the show from a teen soap into a psychological thriller about a social climber. Every time Dan is "clueless" about a rumor, you realize he’s actually the one who started it.
The pilot is the biggest offender. When the first blast goes out about Serena being at Grand Central, Dan is there. He's looking at his phone. He looks stunned. In hindsight, we have to assume he’s just a really, really good actor—or that he was checking to see if his post had successfully uploaded.
There’s a famous scene where Gossip Girl posts a photo of Dan and Serena in bed. Dan is outraged. But if Dan is the one who sent it... why? The explanation given in the finale is that he had to be "fair." He had to leak stuff about himself to keep the suspicion off. It’s a classic "unreliable narrator" trope, but applied to a CW show about headbands and mimosas.
The Cultural Impact of the Reveal
The reveal of who is the Gossip Girl signaled a shift in how we consume media. It was one of the first major shows where the "online" world was as important as the physical one. It predicted the era of the influencer and the way we all curate our lives for an audience.
Dan wasn't just a blogger. He was the original "keyboard warrior."
He understood that in the 21st century, the person who controls the narrative controls the room. Even if that person is a middle-class kid from a loft in Dumbo. The power dynamics of the show were always about money versus "cool." By becoming Gossip Girl, Dan bypassed the money and went straight for the influence.
📖 Related: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
The 2021 Reboot: A Different Approach
When HBO Max (now Max) decided to reboot the series in 2021, they chose a completely different path regarding the identity of the blogger. They didn't want a mystery.
In the first episode of the reboot, they told us exactly who it was: the teachers.
The logic was that the teachers were tired of being bullied by their rich students and wanted to regain control. It was an interesting experiment, but it lacked the "whodunnit" energy of the original. People didn't want to see the mechanics of the posts; they wanted the shock of the reveal. The reboot's choice to be transparent took away the magic. It proved that the question of who is the Gossip Girl was more important than the actual answer.
Why We Are Still Talking About It in 2026
Even now, years after both versions have ended, the original mystery holds up. Why? Because it reflects our own obsession with privacy and public image. We all have a "Gossip Girl" in our pockets now—it’s called social media.
We are all Dan Humphrey in a way. We post, we edit, we wait for the "likes" (or the "blasts") to validate our existence.
The reveal that Dan was the one behind the curtain was the ultimate cynical ending. It told the audience that you can't be a hero in a world built on secrets. To win the game, you have to be the one playing it. Dan didn't just join the elite; he owned them.
How to Handle Gossip Girl Spoilers (For the Three People Who Haven't Seen It)
If you are somehow just starting the show now, my advice is simple: ignore the logic.
👉 See also: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
Don't try to solve the mystery like it's a Sherlock Holmes novel. The writers weren't playing fair with the clues. Instead, watch it as a character study of a guy who is willing to destroy his own reputation to get the girl and the zip code.
- Watch for the reactions: Look at Dan’s face whenever a blast goes out. It’s hilarious once you know.
- Pay attention to Jenny: Dan’s sister actually knew for a long time. Their interactions have a totally different vibe once you realize they’re in on it together.
- Forget the "why": Sometimes the answer to "how could he do that?" is simply "because it makes for good TV."
The Final Verdict on the Reveal
So, was it a good ending? Probably not. Was it a memorable one? Absolutely.
The fact that we are still debating who is the Gossip Girl and whether Dan Humphrey was a genius or a villain is a testament to the show's staying power. It was messy, it was inconsistent, and it was deeply dramatic. In other words, it was exactly what Gossip Girl was always supposed to be.
If you're looking to dive deeper into the lore, your best bet is to look at the original book series by Cecily von Ziegesar. In the books, the identity of Gossip Girl is never actually revealed. The blogger remains an anonymous, omnipresent force. Some fans argue that’s how the show should have ended, too. But TV demands a face. And for better or worse, that face belonged to Dan Humphrey.
Next Steps for Fans
If you've just finished the series or are planning a rewatch, here is how to get the most out of the experience:
- Check out the "Pilot" again. Seriously. Focus only on Dan. It’s a completely different show.
- Read the books. The tone is much darker and more satirical than the show. You get a better sense of why the "anonymous" voice was so feared.
- Follow the cast. Penn Badgley has been very vocal (and funny) about his dislike for Dan's actions on his podcast, Podcrushed. It adds a great layer of meta-commentary to the whole thing.
The mystery is over, but the drama lives on. You know you love it. XOXO.