Go to any pub in Buenos Aires, a cafe in Madrid, or a Sunday league sideline in London, and you’ll hear it. The same heated argument. Usually, someone is shouting. Hands are waving. It’s the question that has basically defined sports discourse for the last twenty years: who is the goat of soccer?
Honestly, the answer used to be simpler. For decades, you were either a Pelé person or a Maradona person. That was it. But then the 21st century happened. We got spoiled. We watched two guys rewrite every record book in existence simultaneously, and suddenly, the "Greatest of All Time" title became a moving target.
It's not just about the trophies, though those matter. It’s about the feeling. It’s about that weird, prickly sensation on the back of your neck when a player does something that shouldn't be physically possible.
The Lionel Messi Argument: The peak of pure talent
If you look at the stats, the debate almost feels over. Lionel Messi has won everything. Literally everything. After the 2022 World Cup in Qatar, the "he hasn't won a trophy for Argentina" crowd finally had to sit down and be quiet.
But Messi isn't the GOAT because of a trophy cabinet. He’s the GOAT because of the way he manipulates time. Have you ever noticed how he walks for 60% of a match? He’s not lazy. He’s calculating. He’s scanning the pitch like a supercomputer, looking for the one blade of grass that isn't being guarded. Then, he explodes.
Pep Guardiola once said that Messi is the only player who runs faster with the ball than he does without it. It sounds like hyperbole, but if you watch his low center of gravity, it’s basically physics. He doesn't do step-overs or flashy tricks. He just shifts his weight a tiny bit, and a world-class defender falls over like a folding chair.
With over 800 career goals and the most Ballon d'Or awards in history, his resume is bulletproof. Yet, his fans will tell you the numbers are the least interesting thing about him. It's the vision. It's the passes that no one else even saw on the TV broadcast, let alone on the pitch.
Cristiano Ronaldo: The machine that wouldn't stop
You can't talk about who is the goat of soccer without looking at the guy who decided that "natural talent" wasn't enough. Cristiano Ronaldo is a different beast entirely.
If Messi is art, Ronaldo is engineering.
👉 See also: Why the 2025 NFL Draft Class is a Total Headache for Scouts
He transformed himself from a skinny, flashy winger at Manchester United into the most clinical goal-scoring machine the sport has ever seen. His work ethic is legendary—and honestly, kinda terrifying. There are endless stories of teammates arriving at practice at 7:00 AM only to find Ronaldo already drenched in sweat, having finished a full workout.
Ronaldo's claim to the throne rests on his dominance across different leagues. He did it in England. He did it in Spain. He did it in Italy. He conquered the Champions League like it was his own personal playground. For many, his "clutch" factor puts him above Messi. When the pressure is at its absolute highest, Ronaldo usually finds a way to jump three feet into the air and header home a winner.
The ghosts of the past: Pelé and Maradona
We have a bad habit of forgetting the giants whose shoulders we’re standing on.
Pelé is the only human to win three World Cups. Read that again. Three. He scored over 1,000 goals (though some of those were in friendlies that people argue about now). In the 1950s and 60s, he was more than a player; he was a global phenomenon who allegedly caused a ceasefire in a civil war just because people wanted to watch him play.
Then there's Diego Maradona.
Maradona didn't just play soccer; he lived a Greek tragedy on grass. His 1986 World Cup run is arguably the greatest individual performance in the history of sports. He scored the "Hand of God" and the "Goal of the Century" in the same game. That tells you everything you need to know about him. He was a flawed, brilliant, chaotic genius who carried a mediocre Napoli side to two Serie A titles in a league that was, at the time, the toughest in the world.
For many older fans, Messi can win ten World Cups and it won't matter. They saw Diego. They saw the soul he put into the ball. To them, that’s the only metric that counts.
Why we can't ever really agree
The problem with deciding who is the goat of soccer is that we all value different things.
✨ Don't miss: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different
If you value longevity and physical perfection, you pick Ronaldo.
If you value magic and playmaking, you pick Messi.
If you value the World Cup legacy above all else, you might still stick with Pelé.
If you value "it factor" and cultural impact, it's Maradona.
Modern sports science has changed the game so much that comparing eras is almost impossible. Pelé played on pitches that looked like cow pastures and wore boots that weighed as much as bricks. Messi plays on carpets with balls designed by aerospace engineers. Does that make Messi's feats less impressive? Or does it mean Pelé would have been even better today?
We’ll never know.
The surprising dark horses
Every now and then, someone brings up Johan Cruyff. And honestly? They have a point.
Cruyff didn't just play; he invented a whole new way of thinking. "Total Football" exists because of him. He is the father of the modern game. If the GOAT is the person who had the biggest impact on how soccer is actually played, Cruyff might actually win.
Then you have the specialists. Zinedine Zidane made the game look like ballet. Ronaldinho made us all fall in love with the sport again with a smile and a flick of his heel. They might not have the raw numbers of the Big Two, but their peak "ceiling" was just as high.
What the experts say
If you ask the pros, they’re just as split as we are.
- Ronaldinho famously said he wasn't even the best at Barca because he watched a teenage Messi in training.
- Sir Alex Ferguson once suggested that while Messi is a Barcelona player, Ronaldo could play for "Stockport County and score a hat-trick."
- Zlatan Ibrahimovic, in his typical humble fashion, usually implies he belongs in the conversation too, though most people see him as the tier just below the absolute summit.
Data analysts at places like Opta or StatsBomb have tried to settle this with "Expected Goals" (xG) and "Progressive Carries," but even the math is inconclusive. Messi usually wins the statistical battle for efficiency and creation, while Ronaldo wins on volume and athleticism.
🔗 Read more: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
The verdict (Sorta)
There isn't a right answer. That’s the beauty of it.
The GOAT debate is a mirror. It shows you what you love about soccer. Do you love the grind? The beauty? The history?
Most people today have landed on Messi, especially after he lifted the trophy in Lusail Stadium. It felt like the final piece of the puzzle. The "narrative" was completed. But in five years, a kid currently playing in a favela or a suburban academy might start doing things we haven't even dreamed of yet.
For now, we should probably stop fighting and just realize how lucky we were to see the Messi-Ronaldo era in real-time. We spent fifteen years watching the two greatest players to ever live go head-to-head every single weekend. That will likely never happen again.
How to actually "judge" the GOAT yourself
If you're tired of the circular arguments, try evaluating players based on these three distinct buckets. It helps clear the fog:
- Peak Dominance: Who was the best at their absolute, 2-3 year ceiling? (Think Ronaldinho 2005 or Maradona 1986).
- Career Longevity: Who stayed at the top for the longest? (This is where Ronaldo and Messi crush everyone else).
- The "Eye Test": Forget the stats. Who made you jump out of your seat the most?
Actionable Insight for Fans: If you want to dive deeper into the history, go watch full match replays of Pelé in 1970 or Maradona in 1986 on YouTube. Don't just watch the highlight reels. Highlights lie. They make everyone look perfect. Watch the full 90 minutes. See how they moved when they didn't have the ball. That’s where the real GOATs are revealed.
Stop looking at TikTok "Who is better" polls and start looking at the influence these players had on their teammates. The greatest players don't just put up numbers; they make the ten people around them play 20% better. That's the real "Greatest of All Time" metric.
---