The question of who is the front runner for pope used to be a parlor game played in the hushed, marble hallways of Rome. It was all about the "papabile"—those cardinals whose names were whispered with a mix of reverence and strategy. But everything changed in early 2025. When Pope Francis passed away on April 21, the speculation turned into a high-stakes reality that ended with a result almost nobody saw coming.
Today, in early 2026, we aren't looking for a front runner anymore. We have him. His name is Robert Francis Prevost, now known to the world as Pope Leo XIV.
It’s kind of wild to think about. For years, experts bet their houses on names like Cardinal Pietro Parolin or the charismatic Luis Tagle from the Philippines. Instead, the College of Cardinals went with a Chicago-born Augustinian who had spent most of his life in the trenches of Peru.
How Robert Prevost Became the Man in White
If you’d asked a casual observer in 2024 who is the front runner for pope, they probably wouldn't have pointed at the guy running the Dicastery for Bishops. Robert Prevost was a "quiet" power. He wasn't on the talk show circuit. He wasn't Twitter-famous. Honestly, he was just a hardworking administrator with a massive pastoral heart.
But that’s exactly why he won.
🔗 Read more: Joseph Stalin Political Party: What Most People Get Wrong
The conclave in May 2025 was the largest in history. 133 cardinal electors. It was messy. You had the "continuity" crowd wanting someone exactly like Francis, and the "traditionalists" who wanted to hit the brakes on things like synodality. Prevost was the bridge. He was an American—the first ever—but he didn't feel "American" to the global south because he’d lived in the Andes for decades. He spoke fluent Spanish. He understood the "peripheries" Francis always talked about, but he also knew how to make the Vatican bureaucracy actually function.
Basically, he was the candidate who didn't offend anyone enough to get vetoed, and impressed everyone enough to get the two-thirds majority.
The Other "Front Runners" Who Almost Made It
It’s worth looking back at the guys who were leading the pack before the white smoke went up. These men are still the "princes" of the church today, and they’re currently helping Leo XIV navigate a pretty turbulent world.
- Pietro Parolin: The Vatican’s former Secretary of State. For a long time, he was the "safe" pick. He’s a diplomat’s diplomat. But some felt he lacked the "smell of the sheep," that raw pastoral energy people wanted after Francis.
- Luis Antonio Tagle: Often called the "Asian Francis." He has the smile, the charisma, and the theological chops. But he had some management hiccups at Caritas Internationalis that stayed in the back of some cardinals' minds.
- Péter Erdő: The Hungarian favorite for the conservatives. If the church wanted a sharp turn toward traditionalism and canon law, Erdő was the guy. He’s brilliant, but perhaps a bit too "Old World" for a church that is exploding in growth in Africa and Asia.
- Matteo Zuppi: The "bicycle-riding archbishop" of Bologna. He was the progressive darling. He’s incredibly close to the poor, but some feared he was too much of a Francis clone for a College of Cardinals that wanted a slightly different flavor.
Why a US Pope is a Massive Deal
Having an American on the Chair of St. Peter is a tectonic shift. For centuries, the Vatican was wary of the "superpower" pope. They didn't want the Catholic Church to look like an arm of Washington D.C.
💡 You might also like: Typhoon Tip and the Largest Hurricane on Record: Why Size Actually Matters
Leo XIV has spent his first months in office proving those fears wrong. In his "State of the World" address this past January 9, he actually slammed the current global order for its "paralysis" in the face of ongoing wars. He’s not a mouthpiece for the West; he’s a critic of it from the inside.
He’s kept the focus on "listening," a carryover from Francis's Synod on Synodality, but he’s added a layer of American-style organizational efficiency. The curia is actually answering emails now. That sounds like a small thing, but in the Vatican, it’s a miracle.
What Leo XIV is Doing Right Now
If you follow the news out of Rome this week, you’ll see the Pope is holding an "extraordinary consistory." He’s basically pulled all the cardinals to Rome to talk about peace and "correcting the past."
He’s not just sitting in the Apostolic Palace. He’s been seen visiting local parishes in Rome without much fanfare. He’s trying to keep that "street priest" vibe he had in Peru. It’s a tough balance. You’ve got the weight of 1.3 billion Catholics on your shoulders and a security detail that won't let you breathe.
📖 Related: Melissa Calhoun Satellite High Teacher Dismissal: What Really Happened
Key Insights for 2026
If you’re trying to understand where the church is headed under this new leadership, here’s the reality:
- Stability over Revolution: Leo XIV isn't trying to rewrite the catechism. He’s trying to make the existing rules work for people.
- Focus on the Global South: Even though he’s from Chicago, his heart is in the missions. Expect more cardinals from places like Myanmar, Congo, and Vietnam.
- Diplomatic Activism: He’s using his "American" identity to push harder on international peace negotiations, especially in the Middle East and Ukraine.
The era of "who is the front runner for pope" is over for now. We are in the era of Leo XIV. It’s a time of transition, a bit of a "deep breath" for the church after the whirlwind years of the mid-2020s.
Keep an eye on the June consistory. That’s when we’ll see the next batch of cardinals named, and that’s when we’ll start seeing who might be the next front runner a decade or two down the line. For now, stay updated by following the official Vatican News bulletins or reputable outlets like the National Catholic Register and the Tablet, as they provide the most granular detail on Leo XIV's daily decrees.