Everyone knows the rhythm. You can probably recite the first four lines without even trying. It’s ingrained in our collective DNA at this point, right alongside the smell of pine needles and the taste of way too much eggnog. But if you ask a room full of historians about the author of Twas the Night Before Christmas, you might actually start a fight. Most people will confidently shout "Clement Clarke Moore!" Others—the ones who spend their weekends digging through 19th-century archives—will swear it was a Dutch-American soldier named Henry Livingston Jr.
It's a weirdly heated debate for a poem about a jolly guy in a red suit.
We’re talking about a piece of literature that basically invented the modern American Christmas. Before this poem showed up in a Troy, New York newspaper in 1823, Santa Claus wasn't really "Santa." He was a stern, thin, somewhat judgmental figure. This poem gave us the eight reindeer. It gave us the "twinkle in his eye" and the "belly like a bowl full of jelly." It created the magic. Yet, the question of who actually sat down with a quill to write it remains a literary mystery that involves linguistic forensic experts, family grudges, and a whole lot of "he said, she said" from two centuries ago.
The Case for Clement Clarke Moore
For the longest time, Moore was the undisputed champ. He was a wealthy, highly educated scholar of Hebrew and Greek living in Manhattan. He finally claimed authorship in 1837, about 14 years after the poem first appeared anonymously in The Troy Sentinel. Why the wait? Well, Moore was a serious academic. He allegedly thought the poem was a bit "beneath" him—a frivolous nursery rhyme that didn't fit his image as a dignified professor.
He eventually included it in a collection of his own poetry, Poems, published in 1844.
He told a story about how he wrote it for his children during a sleigh ride on a snowy day. It’s a charming image. The wealthy father, inspired by the jingling bells, whipping up a masterpiece to surprise his kids by the fireplace. Most history books stick with this version because, frankly, Moore put his name on it while he was still alive. His friends backed him up. His family backed him up. For the general public, that was usually enough.
✨ Don't miss: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy
But there's a catch.
Moore's other poetry is... well, it’s not great. It’s heavy. It’s moralistic. It’s often quite somber and stiff. When you read his known works alongside "A Visit from St. Nicholas" (the poem's actual title), the tone shift is jarring. It’s like finding out a guy who only writes technical manuals for vacuum cleaners suddenly penned a whimsical, world-class Pixar script. It’s possible, sure, but it raises some eyebrows.
Henry Livingston Jr.: The Dark Horse Candidate
Now we get to the fun part. The Livingston family has been fighting Moore's claim for generations. They insist that Henry Livingston Jr., a gentleman farmer from Poughkeepsie, was the true author of Twas the Night Before Christmas.
Henry was a different kind of guy. He was known for being lighthearted, funny, and fond of writing "anapestic" verse—which is that "da-da-DUM, da-da-DUM" rhythm the poem uses. His children claimed they heard him read the poem to them as early as 1804 or 1805. That’s nearly two decades before it appeared in print. The problem? Henry never claimed it publicly. He died in 1828, years before Moore took credit.
The evidence for Livingston is almost entirely circumstantial, but it’s compelling as heck.
🔗 Read more: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
- The Meter: Livingston wrote almost exclusively in the exact rhythm of the poem. Moore rarely did.
- The Dutch Connection: The poem mentions "Dunder and Blixem" (Thunder and Lightning). These are Dutch words. Livingston was of Dutch descent and lived in an area where these terms were common. Moore, a New Yorker with a very different background, likely wouldn't have used those specific spellings.
- The Vibe: Livingston’s known poems are full of joy, nature, and playfulness. They feel like the same "soul" that wrote the St. Nick story.
What the Data Scientists Say
In the early 2000s, this wasn't just a campfire story anymore. It became a job for Donald Foster, a Vassar College professor famous for using "literary forensics" to identify anonymous authors. He’s the guy who correctly identified Joe Klein as the author of Primary Colors.
Foster took a deep dive into the vocabulary, sentence structure, and even the use of certain adverbs. His conclusion? It’s probably Livingston. He pointed out that Moore’s typical writing style was filled with "thee" and "thou" and a very stern moral compass. Meanwhile, "A Visit from St. Nicholas" is uniquely devoid of the moralizing that Moore seemed obsessed with.
More recently, in 2016, New Zealander MacDonald P. Jackson used statistical analysis to compare the poem to the works of both men. He looked at high-frequency words and the way they were used. His findings also tipped the scales toward Livingston. It turns out, we all have a "linguistic fingerprint," and Moore’s fingerprint just doesn't seem to match the poem as well as Livingston’s does.
Why Does It Still Matter?
You might wonder why we’re still talking about two dead guys and a poem about a chimney.
It matters because this poem is the foundation of our modern Christmas mythology. It took the figure of St. Nicholas—a real 4th-century bishop—and transformed him into the Santa Claus we see on every Coca-Cola can and greeting card today. If we don't know who wrote it, there’s a missing piece in our cultural history.
💡 You might also like: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
Honestly, the author of Twas the Night Before Christmas debate is a bit like a Rorschach test for historians. If you value written records and legal claims, you side with Moore. If you value stylistic consistency and oral tradition, you’re team Livingston.
The Mystery Remains (Sorta)
We might never have a "smoking gun." There’s no original handwritten manuscript with a date on it. Moore’s handwritten copies were all made years after the poem was famous, basically as souvenirs for his friends. Livingston’s original draft supposedly burned in a house fire, according to his descendants.
It’s a classic literary stalemate.
But here is what we know for sure: whoever wrote it was a genius of branding. They managed to capture the exact feeling of anticipation that every child feels on December 24th. They turned a cold winter night into something warm and magical.
How to Explore the Mystery Yourself
If you're a bit of a history nerd or just want to win your next holiday trivia night, there are a few things you can do to dig deeper into this mystery.
- Compare the texts side-by-side. Read Clement Clarke Moore’s poem "The Trip into the Country" and then read Henry Livingston Jr.’s "The Invitation to the Country." Pay attention to the "bounce" of the words. You’ll immediately see why people think they were written by different brains.
- Check out the forensic reports. Look up Donald Foster’s book Author Unknown. It has a massive chapter dedicated to the statistical breakdown of this specific poem. It’s surprisingly gripping for a book about grammar.
- Visit the source. If you’re ever in Troy, New York, you can visit the site where The Troy Sentinel first published the poem anonymously on December 23, 1823. There’s a bronze plaque and everything.
- Listen to the "Dutch" clues. Next time you read the poem, look for the names of the reindeer. In the original 1823 version, they weren't "Donder and Blitzen." They were "Dunder and Blixem." This is a huge clue for the Livingston camp, as those are Poughkeepsie-area Dutch terms for thunder and lightning.
Whether it was the scholarly professor or the playful farmer, the poem remains a masterpiece. It’s one of the few things in this world that seems to get better with age, regardless of whose name is on the title page.