Netflix took a massive gamble. Adapting Anthony Doerr’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, All the Light We Cannot See, wasn't just about finding actors who could read lines; it was about finding a very specific kind of soul for characters that millions of readers already "saw" in their heads. When the all the light we cannot see movie cast was finally announced, it sparked a lot of conversation—mostly because the production team made a decision that sounds obvious but is actually quite rare in Hollywood. They actually cast a blind actress to play a blind lead.
It’s easy to forget how often big studios take the "safe" route. They usually hire a household name and have them "act" a disability. This time, director Shawn Levy and writer Steven Knight went a different way. It changed everything about the show's energy.
Aria Mia Loberti: The Breakout as Marie-Laure LeBlanc
Honestly, Aria Mia Loberti is the heart of the whole thing. Before this, she wasn't an actor. She was a Fulbright scholar and an academic. Imagine jumping from a PhD program straight into a leading role in one of the most anticipated limited series of the year. It’s wild. Loberti plays Marie-Laure, the blind French girl who navigates the Nazi occupation of Saint-Malo with a combination of sheer terror and incredible intellectual grit.
She has this stillness. It’s not something a sighted actor can easily fake. Because Loberti is legally blind, her movements—the way she touches the wooden model of the city her father built, the way she reacts to sound—feel grounded in a physical reality that adds layers to the story. She isn’t "playing" blind; she is simply living in that space. It makes the scenes where she broadcasts from the attic feel incredibly intimate. You’re not watching a performance as much as you’re witnessing a person existing in a high-stakes environment.
There’s also Nell Sutton. She plays the younger version of Marie-Laure. Like Loberti, Sutton has a visual impairment (glaucoma), and her inclusion in the all the light we cannot see movie cast reinforces the show's commitment to authentic representation. She’s charming and brings that necessary spark of childhood wonder before the world starts falling apart.
Louis Hofmann as Werner Pfennig: The Face of Conflict
If Marie-Laure is the light, Werner is the shadow trying to find his way back to it. Louis Hofmann plays the young German soldier. If he looks familiar, it’s probably because you’ve seen him in Dark, the mind-bending German sci-fi series. Hofmann has this specific face—he looks like he’s perpetually carrying the weight of the world.
Werner isn't your typical villain, and he’s not a hero either. He’s a radio genius who gets sucked into the Nazi machine because it's his only way out of the coal mines. Hofmann plays him with a sort of quiet, desperate intelligence. He’s a "good" person doing "bad" things, and the nuance Hofmann brings prevents the character from becoming a caricature. He’s pale, blonde, and looks exactly like the "Aryan ideal" the Reich wanted, but his eyes tell you he hates every second of it.
💡 You might also like: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
The chemistry between Werner and Marie-Laure is weird because they barely spend any time together on screen. Their connection is through the airwaves. It’s all about voices. Hofmann has to sell the idea that he’s falling in love with a girl he’s never met, just by listening to her read Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea over the radio. It’s a tough acting job.
The Heavy Hitters: Mark Ruffalo and Hugh Laurie
You need anchors. For a project this big, Netflix brought in the veterans. Mark Ruffalo plays Daniel LeBlanc, Marie-Laure’s father. He’s the locksmith at the Museum of Natural History in Paris.
Ruffalo is... well, he’s Mark Ruffalo. He brings that "warm dad" energy he’s perfected over the last decade. But there’s a frantic edge to him here. He’s obsessed with protecting his daughter, not just from the Germans, but from the darkness of losing hope. He builds those intricate models of their neighborhood so she can learn to navigate by touch. It’s a heartbreaking performance because you know he’s preparing her for a world he won't be in forever.
Then there is Hugh Laurie. He plays Etienne LeBlanc, Marie-Laure’s great-uncle. Etienne is a WWI veteran with massive PTSD. He’s a recluse. He hasn't left his house in decades.
Laurie is fascinating here. We’re so used to him as House—acerbic, loud, brilliant. As Etienne, he’s fragile. He’s terrified of the world. But he’s also the one with the sophisticated radio equipment in the attic. Watching him slowly find his courage because of Marie-Laure is one of the better arcs in the series. He brings a gravitas to the all the light we cannot see movie cast that makes the historical stakes feel personal.
Lars Eidinger: The Villain You Love to Hate
Every story like this needs a foil. Lars Eidinger plays Reinhold von Rumpel. He’s the gemologist/Nazi officer hunting for the "Sea of Flames," a legendary diamond that Marie-Laure’s father might be hiding.
📖 Related: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
Eidinger is a German acting legend, and he plays von Rumpel with a terrifying, sickly persistence. He’s dying of cancer in the story, which makes his quest for the "immortal" diamond feel desperate. He doesn't scream or shout much. He just lingers. He’s like a vulture. His presence provides the ticking clock for the whole series. Without his looming threat, the story would just be two kids listening to the radio. He makes it a thriller.
Marion Bailey as Madame Manec
We have to talk about Madame Manec. Marion Bailey plays Etienne’s housekeeper and the secret backbone of the resistance in Saint-Malo. She’s the one who organizes the local women to bake codes into loaves of bread.
Bailey brings a "no-nonsense" British/French grit to the role. She’s the catalyst for Etienne’s growth. While everyone else is paralyzed by fear, she’s just getting on with the business of fighting back. It’s a supporting role, but it’s the glue that holds the Saint-Malo scenes together.
Why This Specific Cast Works (And Where People Argue)
There was some pushback when the series dropped. Some book fans felt the all the light we cannot see movie cast didn't quite match the lyrical, almost dreamlike quality of Doerr’s prose. The show is much more "Hollywood" than the book. It’s louder. The villains are more villainous.
But the casting of Aria Mia Loberti is the shield against most of that criticism. It’s hard to argue with the emotional honesty she brings. When she’s navigating that bombed-out house, she’s using her ears and her cane in a way that creates a genuine sense of tension. You aren't worried because the script tells you to be; you're worried because you see how difficult the physical world is for her in that moment.
- The Authentic Factor: Casting blind actors wasn't just a PR move. It changed the blocking of scenes and the pacing of the dialogue.
- The Experience Gap: You have a first-time actor (Loberti) playing against a 3-time Oscar nominee (Ruffalo). That power dynamic actually works for the characters—a daughter looking up to her father.
- The Language Choice: One thing that bothers some purists is the accents. You have Americans, Brits, and Germans all speaking English with various "European-ish" accents. It’s a common trope in historical dramas, but if you can get past that, the emotional performances hold up.
Looking Back at the Production
The series was filmed largely in Budapest and Saint-Malo itself. Shawn Levy, who is known for Stranger Things, used a lot of natural light (ironic, given the title) to give the actors a specific atmosphere to work in.
👉 See also: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
The all the light we cannot see movie cast had to deal with some pretty intense conditions. The recreation of the 1944 siege of Saint-Malo involved massive sets and practical pyrotechnics. For Hofmann, playing Werner meant spending a lot of time in cramped, dark spaces—radio rooms, bunkers, and collapsed buildings. It’s a physical show.
Final Take on the Casting Choices
If you’re going into this expecting a 1:1 recreation of the book, you might be surprised by some of the tonal shifts. However, the cast is the strongest argument for the adaptation's existence.
Loberti is a revelation. Ruffalo and Laurie provide the emotional scaffolding. Eidinger provides the rot. It’s a well-balanced ensemble that manages to take a very "internal" book and make it work for a visual medium.
Next Steps for Fans:
If you want to see more of the cast's range, check out Louis Hofmann in Dark (Netflix) or Aria Mia Loberti's various interviews regarding disability advocacy in film. For those interested in the historical accuracy of the costumes and settings used by the cast, the "Making Of" featurettes on Netflix provide a deep look at how they reconstructed 1940s France. It’s also worth comparing the performances to the audiobook narrated by Zach Appelman, which offers a completely different "vocal cast" interpretation of the same characters.
---