Wait, didn't you hear? The "who is Pope Francis successor" question isn't a hypothetical anymore. It actually happened. In a move that caught half the world sleeping and the other half glued to Vatican News, the Catholic Church underwent its biggest transition in over a decade last year.
Pope Francis passed away on April 21, 2025. The white smoke rose from the Sistine Chapel chimney on May 8, 2025, after only four ballots. It was fast. Surprisingly fast, actually, given how divided the College of Cardinals supposedly was. The man who stepped out onto the balcony of St. Peter’s Basilica wasn't an Italian favorite or a "safe" European bureaucrat.
It was Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, an American-born prelate who took the name Pope Leo XIV.
The Man in White: Who is Pope Leo XIV?
Honestly, if you weren't a Vatican nerd, you probably hadn't heard much about Robert Prevost before he became the "successor to Pope Francis." He’s a Chicago native, which makes him the first-ever American pope. That’s a massive deal. For centuries, the papacy was an Italian club, then it went Polish, then German, then Argentinian. Now? It's gone to the Midwest.
Leo XIV spent decades as an Augustinian friar. He isn't some corporate executive in a cassock; he’s got a "pastoral heart" but also knows how the gears of the Vatican grind. Before the 2025 conclave, he was running the Dicastery for Bishops. That’s basically the HR department for the entire global Church. He was the guy vetting every new bishop on the planet. He knew where all the bodies were buried—metaphorically speaking—and he knew exactly which cardinals were actually getting things done.
🔗 Read more: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
He’s roughly 70 years old, which is the "Goldilocks" age for a pope. Not so old that he’s just a placeholder, but not so young that he’ll reign for forty years and block the next generation.
Why he was chosen
The cardinals were looking for someone who could bridge the gap. Pope Francis was a disruptor. He broke things. He challenged people. But by 2025, the Church was feeling a bit... frayed. There was a lot of internal "infighting" between the traditionalists and the progressives.
Leo XIV was seen as the bridge. He’s progressive on social issues—kind of a "Francis 2.0" in that regard—but he’s much more orderly. He likes a clean process. He’s a "law and order" guy who still cares deeply about the poor.
The "Runners Up": Who Almost Got the Job?
The 2025 conclave was wild. There were names flying around for months. If you followed the "papabile" (the fancy Italian word for "pope-able" candidates), you saw a lot of familiar faces who ultimately went back to their day jobs.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
- Cardinal Pietro Parolin: The Vatican Secretary of State. He was the "continuity" candidate. Everyone thought he’d win because he’s a brilliant diplomat, but the cardinals often shy away from the #2 guy. They wanted a fresh face, not the old boss’s right hand.
- Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle: Often called the "Asian Francis." He’s from the Philippines and has this incredible, infectious joy. He was a huge favorite, but some feared he was too much like Francis. The College wanted a slight course correction.
- Cardinal Péter Erdő: The Hungarian. He was the "lawyer." If the Church wanted to go back to strict doctrine and traditional liturgy, he was the guy. He had a strong showing in the first two ballots but couldn't get the two-thirds majority.
- Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa: The Patriarch of Jerusalem. Talk about a "tough job" guy. He’s Italian but has lived in the Middle East for decades. He was the dark horse. People loved his bravery during the conflicts in Gaza and Israel, but at 60, he was considered "too young."
What Pope Leo XIV has done so far (January 2026 Update)
We’re about eight months into the "Leonine" era now. It’s been busy. If you’re looking for the "successor to Pope Francis" to be a quiet wallflower, you’re looking at the wrong guy.
Just last week, in January 2026, Leo XIV summoned all the world's cardinals to Rome for an "Extraordinary Consistory." He basically told them, "I’m here to listen, not just talk." He’s trying to implement something called "synodality"—which is basically a fancy word for "making the Church less of a dictatorship and more of a conversation."
But he’s also doing things Francis didn't. He’s cleaning up the Vatican finances with a much heavier hand. He’s also been meeting with survivors of clergy abuse more frequently and without the media circus. It feels... different. More business-like, but still deeply spiritual.
The "American" Influence
It’s weird seeing a Pope who speaks with a Chicago accent sometimes. He’s been very vocal about global peace, specifically in Ukraine and Gaza, but he brings a certain American pragmatism to the table. He doesn't like waste. He doesn't like "clericalism"—that thing where priests act like they're better than everyone else.
📖 Related: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
What most people get wrong about the succession
There’s this myth that the next pope is "chosen" by the previous one. Nope. Francis didn't pick Robert Prevost. He did appoint about 80% of the cardinals who voted for him, which obviously tilted the scales toward someone who shared his vision. But a conclave is a "locked room" for a reason. Once those doors shut, the Holy Spirit (and a lot of intense political whispering) takes over.
People also thought the next pope would "undo" everything Francis did. That hasn't happened. Leo XIV is keeping the focus on the environment and the marginalized, but he’s also being a bit more "gentle" with the traditionalists who felt alienated by Francis. He’s trying to stop the bleeding.
Actionable Insights: What to watch for next
If you want to understand where the "successor to Pope Francis" is taking the 1.4 billion Catholics on Earth, keep your eyes on these three things over the next twelve months:
- The October 2026 Synod: This will be the big "reveal" of his specific theological roadmap.
- New Cardinal Appointments: Look at who he picks. If he picks more Americans, he's building a power base. If he picks more from Africa and Asia, he's continuing the "peripheral" focus of Francis.
- Vatican Bank Reform: This is the boring stuff that actually matters. If he can finally clean up the money, his papacy will be a historic success.
The question of "who is Pope Francis successor" has been answered with a surprising "American" twist. Pope Leo XIV is currently steering the Barque of Peter through some pretty choppy 2026 waters. It isn't just about who sits on the throne; it's about how the Church survives in a world that’s increasingly skeptical of "organized religion."
Check the Vatican's official bulletin, the Bollettino, for daily updates if you want the raw data. But for the "vibe check"? Leo XIV is proving that he's his own man, not just a shadow of the man who came before him.
Key Next Steps:
Keep an eye on the Pope’s upcoming trip to Spain this year. It’s his first major international test. Also, look into his recent "consistory" speeches—they’re being published in English much faster than Francis’s were, which says a lot about his Chicago roots. Reading his first encyclical (expected by mid-2026) will be the final word on his long-term vision.